Your teams dream team since the 2012-2013 lockout

[All Mod Cons]

As a Leafs fan, pretty much the only player I'd bring back since those years is Phil Kessel. Harsh reality.

f*** that.

I'd die for that Kulemin, Grabbo MacArthur 3rd line again.

 

[ColbyChaos]

Sharp-Toews-Hossa
Panarin-Anisimov-Kane
DeBrincat-Strome-Bedard
Shaw-Danault-Terravainen

Keith-Seabrook
Hjalmarsson-Oduya
Vlassic-Jones

Crawford, Raanta.

Extras: Leddy, Saad, Versteeg,

if Peak Brad Richards counts im putting him at #2 C instead

 

[Peen]

Pretty similar to mine. I ended up leaving Kes off because he was injured most of 12-13 and wasn’t quite himself in 13-14. Felt he might have prickled at being lower on the depth chart as well, though he was obviously a top 12 forward still in terms of ability.

Fair point on the righties though and that’s something Kesler adds. I ended up adding Hansen instead. I feel like even with Kes I’d keep Hansen and play Kes and Horvat as the bottom 2 centers over Blueger though. I like Blueger but I think Hansen’s just the better player and also has some chemistry with the Sedins if Burrows is slumping. I was also torn on rookie Boeser or Covid year Boeser. He was a more rounded player in ‘21 but was never the same shooter as he was as a rookie and I like that on the team given there’s a lot of more rounded players here.

For the defense, I think Garrison was really good his first year here and arguably better than Bieksa in this time period. He’s a lefty but played a lot of the right. You might be right to add Juice though as he was a natural righty and had chemistry with Hamhuis. Also had some swagger/toughness otherwise missing on the back end.

Totally forgot about Bonino somehow. Definitely has a case. Would easily be above most of my HMs.

Garrison - loved him. Thought Benning sold low on him with that late 2nd trade. But I couldn’t look past the Hamhuis - Bieksa chemistry.

I know Kesler barely played in 12-13, but he was still good at that point. And given the right hand shot at matchup line role, just taking him.

Bonino above Blueger.. I’d also probably make that swap but honestly can’t remember if he was effective on the penalty kill.

 

[nucks88]

Miller - Pettersson - Boeser
Daniel - Henrik - Vrbata (14-15)
Horvat - Kesler - Garland
Pearson - Lindholm - Toffoli

EX; Debrusk/Sherwood

Hughes - Hronek
Edler - Tanev
Hamhuis - Bieksa (12-14)

EX; Myers

Demko
Markstrom

All good except I would take Burrows over Vrbata on the Hank/Dank line….

 

[Sergei Shirokov]

All good except I would take Burrows over Vrbata on the Hank/Dank line….

Burrows game kinda fell off from 12-13 onward, which is the timeframe. If it was a year or 2 earlier it would've been a no brainer.

Could make an argument either way, but that was why I put Vrbata.

 

[tarheelhockey]

Guentzel - Aho - Teravainen
Semin - E Staal - Williams
Svechnikov - J Staal - Jarvis
Skinner - Trocheck - Necas

Slavin - Hamilton
Pesce - Burns
Skjei - Faulk

Andersen
Mrazek

 

[karltonian]

Marleau - Thornton - Pavelski
Hertl - Celebrini - Meier
Eklund - Couture - Zetterlund
Ward - Tierney - Wingels
ex: Nieto

Dillon - Karlsson
Burns - Boyle
Vlasic - Braun
ex: Demers

I guess Jones? or Blackwood if you're cool with smaller samples
Askarov


Unfortunately if we cut things off at 12-13 that means missing the best years of Clowe and Douglas Mruray as well as the likes of Rob Blake, Scott Nichol, Jamie McGinn and other role players. I don't love how heavily the d corps leans on the offensive side of things, especially the adventure pair of Burns and Boyle, but really most of the team's better stay-at-home guys were from the era just before this and I'm not sure I'm giving spots to Colin White or deadline acquisition Roman Polak. Maybe you take the tail end of Paul Martin's career and toss aside Karlsson on the grounds that he wasn't a Shark as long as Burns and Boyle were and that his career in teal was more up and down even with the Norris win?

And yes, that 4th line is as checking line as I could make it because I couldn't come up with 3 more strong star-level or near-star-level players up front. That's also why the 3rd line is Couture with two of the more fun wingers on the current roster.

BURNS TO FORWARD

 

[The Nemesis]

BURNS TO FORWARD

I had Burns at forward in my initial draft to facilitate Karlsson being back there and not putting the two of them together. But then I started going through the list of available d-men and it was just so uninspired trying to talk myself into nothing names like Ian White, Kent Huskins, or those couple of games from Karl Stollery that I just said screw it because at least with him on the blueline I could pick a fun current team forward.

 

[HighNote]

Buchnevich - Thomas - Tarasenko
Schwartz - O'Reilly - Perron
Steen - Backes - Oshie
T. Thompson - Schenn - Kyrou

Suter - Pietrangelo
Bouwmeester - Parayko
Broberg - Shattenkirk

Brodeur
Binnington

 

[karltonian]

I had Burns at forward in my initial draft to facilitate Karlsson being back there and not putting the two of them together. But then I started going through the list of available d-men and it was just so uninspired trying to talk myself into nothing names like Ian White, Kent Huskins, or those couple of games from Karl Stollery that I just said screw it because at least with him on the blueline I could pick a fun current team forward.

You could slip Large Human Douglas Murray in there. Or Mariorr Ferarro, he probably does well with Boyle. Though I think 24-25 Jake Walman might make this roster without reservations, if he finishes this season strong.

Also you have to find a spot for Granlund, no? He could certainly do a Chris Kunitz on the 4th line.

 

[The Nemesis]

You could slip Large Human Douglas Murray in there. Or Mariorr Ferarro, he probably does well with Boyle. Though I think 24-25 Jake Walman might make this roster without reservations, if he finishes this season strong.

If we were only counting the player's performance within the window of 12-13 to now, that was the old, broken down Murray that the Sharks had just before they miraculously flipped him to the Pens for a pair of 2nds.

Ferraro has too much negative baggage right now for me to want to consider him. Also I didn't want to just make the blueline out of the top shelf scorers who may be question marks in their own end.

Also you have to find a spot for Granlund, no?

he was a late cut because he just didn't feel "sharky" enough to me. Obviously technically neither should Zetterlund, but he at least fills the role of a high-intensity winger. because I also didn't want to just make the whole forward unit out of centers.

 

[karltonian]

If we were only counting the player's performance within the window of 12-13 to now, that was the old, broken down Murray that the Sharks had just before they miraculously flipped him to the Pens for a pair of 2nds.

Ferraro has too much negative baggage right now for me to want to consider him. Also I didn't want to just make the blueline out of the top shelf scorers who may be question marks in their own end.


he was a late cut because he just didn't feel "sharky" enough to me. Obviously technically neither should Zetterlund, but he at least fills the role of a high-intensity winger. because I also didn't want to just make the whole forward unit out of centers.

I say walman then. He is good enough in his own zone this season. He made the OP's dream team after all

And I say granny is fair game, you can put him on the bottom line. He gutted out last season as our credible 1C. This is a dream team after all.

 

[RoyIsALegend]

Landeskog (C) - MacKinnon (A) - Rantanen
Nichushkin - O’Reilly - Duchene
Tanguay - Kadri - Iginla
Lehkonen - Stastny - Compher

Toews - Makar
Girard - E.Johnson (A)
Byram - Barrie

Varlamov
Kuemper

 

[BLNY]

Pacioretty​	Suzuki​	Caufield​
Laine​	Plekanec​	Toffoli​
Tatar​	Danault​	Gallagher​
Lehkonen​	Eller​	Armia​
​	​	​
Hutson​	Weber​	​
Markov​	Subban​	​
Guhle​	Petry​	​
​	​	​
Price​	​	​
Budaj​	​	​

 

[Agent37]

Washington (Assuming players who didn't play a game can count) Offensive stupidity incoming

Ovechkin - Backstrom - Oshie
Forsberg - Strome - Williams
Burakovsky - Kuznetsov - Protas
Mcmichael - Luc-Dubois - Wilson

(Pacioretty, Vrana... stephenson or brouwer if no forsberg for some defensive responsibility)

Chychrun - Carlson
Orlov - Niskanen
Chara - Shattenkirk
Green

Lundqvist (Best Capitals goalie of all time, lmao)
Holtby

(Thompson if no Lundqvist)

 

[FunkySeeFunkyDo]

Harkins - Acciari - Nieto
ZAR - Lafferty - Dom Simon
McKegg - Sheahan -Rowney
Glass - Sutter - Adams

Ludvig - Ruhwedel
Jack Johnson - Gudbranson
Smith - Friedman

Zatkoff
Domingue

 

[kerrabria]

Giroux - Barkov - Tkachuk
Huberdeau - Bennett - Reinhart
Verhaeghe - Trocheck - Jokinen
Marchment - Lundell - Hornqvist
Luostarinen, Hoffman

Forsling - Weegar
Campbell - Ekblad
Mikkola - Montour
Gudas

Luongo
Bobrovksy

 

[Mcnofool6110]

Presuming performance only from 2012 onwards, Oilers have a couple players who missed their prime on Edmonton but still had it just around/in that era.

Hall-McDavid-Hyman
Lucic-Draisaitl-Perry
E Kane-RNH-Eberle
Maroon-Henrique-Perron
R Strome, Hemsky (unfortunately after his prime and after injuries)

Keith-Bouchard
Ekholm-Larsson
Nurse-Klefbom
Petry

M Smith
Talbot
Dubnyk

 

[STHLM]

Panarin-Staal-Kane
Kreider-Zibanejad-Buchnevich
Nash-Brassard-St. Louis
Lafreniere-Stepan-Tarasenko

McDonagh-Fox
Yandle-Girardi
Staal-Stralman

Lundqvist
Shesterkin

 

[Eye of Ra]

Ny Islanders

Tavares - Barzal - Eberle
Lee - Nelson - Bailey
Okposo - Horvat - Palmieri
Martin - Nielsen - Clutterbuck

Toews - Boychuk
Pelech - Dobson
Romanov - Pulock

Sorokin
Varlamov

 

[Caps8112]

Washington (Assuming players who didn't play a game can count) Offensive stupidity incoming

Ovechkin - Backstrom - Oshie
Forsberg - Strome - Williams
Burakovsky - Kuznetsov - Protas
Mcmichael - Luc-Dubois - Wilson

(Pacioretty, Vrana... stephenson or brouwer if no forsberg for some defensive responsibility)

Chychrun - Carlson
Orlov - Niskanen
Chara - Shattenkirk
Green

Lundqvist (Best Capitals goalie of all time, lmao)
Holtby

(Thompson if no Lundqvist)

is it any player that has been on the team at some point from 2012 onward, but you get them in their prime? or is any player 2012 onward, but its how they were at that point in their career? Because prime Kovalchuk would knock someone out of that lineup. also might consider Knuble or Ribeiro but looks good.

 

[SimpleJack]

Most rosters look stacked as expected. I’d say weakest so far probably the islanders.

 

[Agent37]

is it any player that has been on the team at some point from 2012 onward, but you get them in their prime? or is any player 2012 onward, but its how they were at that point in their career? Because prime Kovalchuk would knock someone out of that lineup. also might consider Knuble or Ribeiro but looks good.

I was wondering this too and initially considered it too. I wrote it as if it were post 2012. If we get prime variations this roster looks different: Kovalchuk, Ribeiro... Good lord that would look wild.

 

[GrkFlyersFan]

Hartnell-Giroux-Voracek
van Riemsdyk-Couturier-Simmonds
Schenn-Frost-Konecny
Read-Laughton-Raffl

Timonen-Provorov
York-Sanheim
Gostisbehere-Streit

Mason
(Elliott)

This was harder than I thought it'd be.

 

[sbhnur]

Players:
Don't care

Coach:
no Tortorella

That's all I can ask for.