Your 3 favourite and least 3 favourite current Leaf players
- Thread starter Budz
- Start date
3 Favorite
Matthews - This generations goal scoring goat
Tanev - One of the highest IQ D-men I've seen, always in position and always makes the safe/smart play
Woll - Our homegrown legitimate 1G, very likable personality. Still early in his career but he looks like the real deal
HM: Nylander, Tavares, Marner, Pacioretty
3 Least favorite
Kampf - What does he even do on this team ?
Domi - Looks awful compared to last year, offense is non-existent
Reaves - Because I have to pick 3, complete non-factor on the ice
Matthews - This generations goal scoring goat
Tanev - One of the highest IQ D-men I've seen, always in position and always makes the safe/smart play
Woll - Our homegrown legitimate 1G, very likable personality. Still early in his career but he looks like the real deal
HM: Nylander, Tavares, Marner, Pacioretty
3 Least favorite
Kampf - What does he even do on this team ?
Domi - Looks awful compared to last year, offense is non-existent
Reaves - Because I have to pick 3, complete non-factor on the ice
LeafalCrusader
Registered User
Favourites
Nylander - So much fun to watch.
McMann - Works his butt off. Great story coming up as a undrafted player.
Tanev -Warrior
Least Favourites
-Had to reach with these. Nobody I really hate just wish we moved on from.
Reaves -Doesn't fight anymore. Pretty useless out there. Disliked the signing from day one.
Holmberg - Typical busy nothing player we have iced forever.
Robertson - The whole offseason trade request and long periods of indifferent play have turned me off the guy.
Nylander - So much fun to watch.
McMann - Works his butt off. Great story coming up as a undrafted player.
Tanev -Warrior
Least Favourites
-Had to reach with these. Nobody I really hate just wish we moved on from.
Reaves -Doesn't fight anymore. Pretty useless out there. Disliked the signing from day one.
Holmberg - Typical busy nothing player we have iced forever.
Robertson - The whole offseason trade request and long periods of indifferent play have turned me off the guy.
kevsh
Registered User
- Nov 28, 2018
- 3,730
- 5,241
I realized in the 30 seconds I spent thinking about this that it's generally the newest players I like the most ..,
Tanev
Pacioretty
Kampf (Not his fault he got himself a great deal then was almost immediately dumped to the 4th line)
Tanev
Pacioretty
Kampf (Not his fault he got himself a great deal then was almost immediately dumped to the 4th line)
Ianturnedbull
Registered User
- Jun 11, 2022
- 6,259
- 5,781
Most
OEL
Tanev
Rielly
Least
Timmins
Jarnkrok (yes, I know he's never been in the line-up this year)
Robertson
OEL
Tanev
Rielly
Least
Timmins
Jarnkrok (yes, I know he's never been in the line-up this year)
Robertson
Aashir Mallik
Backcheck, Forecheck, Paycheque
- Apr 19, 2019
- 13,068
- 14,003
Atomos2
Registered User
GoonieFace
Registered User
Favorites:
Nylander
McMann
McCabe
Least Favorite:
Kampf
Reaves
Holmberg
Nylander
McMann
McCabe
Least Favorite:
Kampf
Reaves
Holmberg
Favourite:
Nylander
Rielly
Matthews
Least favourite:
Holmberg
Timmins
Robertson
Wish them all the best though.
Nylander
Rielly
Matthews
Least favourite:
Holmberg
Timmins
Robertson
Wish them all the best though.
Tie Domi Esquire
Go Real Sports Apparel Go!
- Oct 18, 2010
- 3,519
- 1,490
ACC1224
Super Elite, Passing ALL Tests since 2002
- Aug 19, 2002
- 77,406
- 44,430
BraveCanadian
Registered User
- Jun 30, 2010
- 15,619
- 5,071
Fav
Marner- don’t like the rich kid attitude but he’s our best player so.. crossing fingers
McCabe/Tanev - old school heart and soul D we have been missing
McMann/Robertson - hoping for them
HM - Stolarz, Tavares for effort, Patches for being surprising.
Least Fav
Reeves - loved him chasing fake tough guy Gudas around that one game but…
Holmberg - just blah
Hakanpaa - get it was a gamble but useless
HM -Matthew$ for just bring really unlikeable, Domi when he does dumb Domi things.
Marner- don’t like the rich kid attitude but he’s our best player so.. crossing fingers
McCabe/Tanev - old school heart and soul D we have been missing
McMann/Robertson - hoping for them
HM - Stolarz, Tavares for effort, Patches for being surprising.
Least Fav
Reeves - loved him chasing fake tough guy Gudas around that one game but…
Holmberg - just blah
Hakanpaa - get it was a gamble but useless
HM -Matthew$ for just bring really unlikeable, Domi when he does dumb Domi things.
Matthews
Nylander
Marner
Reaves
Kampf
Holmberg
I don’t have a strong dislike for pretty well anyone but I don’t think those 3 add much if anything to the team
Nylander
Marner
Reaves
Kampf
Holmberg
I don’t have a strong dislike for pretty well anyone but I don’t think those 3 add much if anything to the team
tmlms13
Registered User
Favourite for on ice:
-AM34 - obvious
-WN88 - actually gets better in playoffs, especially in elimination games where the other 2 disappear
-MR44 - actually gets better in playoffs - and significantly better
Least Favourite for on ice
-RR75 - Did he forget what he was brought in for?
-MD11 - disappeared after getting contract (though has been better lately)
-PH29 - was hard to pick a 3rd I think he is miscast so not necessarily his fault
Favourite for being likable - contracts play a big role in likability TBH
-MR44 - actually sticks up for teammates and jerk opponents, also the only person who stayed even after going through the pre-2016 era. Resigned 8 years full year ahead of being UFA
-JT91 - Goes about his business, doesn't complain, works hard, stays healthy, consistent, finally did the GTA native come home
-CT8 - too small sample for above but someone willing to sell out to block a shot in a random regular season game is a Fav
Least favourite for being unlikable
-MM16 - the holdout as a RFA and forcing the Leafs to cave still kind of whines when is coitized in media
-RR75 - Has more suspension worthy hit than fights. Is that what he was brought in for
-NR89 - don't complain about ice time or contract or trade request when you don't contribute anything, you aren't your brother, just deal with it.
-AM34 - obvious
-WN88 - actually gets better in playoffs, especially in elimination games where the other 2 disappear
-MR44 - actually gets better in playoffs - and significantly better
Least Favourite for on ice
-RR75 - Did he forget what he was brought in for?
-MD11 - disappeared after getting contract (though has been better lately)
-PH29 - was hard to pick a 3rd I think he is miscast so not necessarily his fault
Favourite for being likable - contracts play a big role in likability TBH
-MR44 - actually sticks up for teammates and jerk opponents, also the only person who stayed even after going through the pre-2016 era. Resigned 8 years full year ahead of being UFA
-JT91 - Goes about his business, doesn't complain, works hard, stays healthy, consistent, finally did the GTA native come home
-CT8 - too small sample for above but someone willing to sell out to block a shot in a random regular season game is a Fav
Least favourite for being unlikable
-MM16 - the holdout as a RFA and forcing the Leafs to cave still kind of whines when is coitized in media
-RR75 - Has more suspension worthy hit than fights. Is that what he was brought in for
-NR89 - don't complain about ice time or contract or trade request when you don't contribute anything, you aren't your brother, just deal with it.
Last edited:
From A pesonality standpoint:
Great…
WN - taking the subway is completely based
NG - gotta love “backcheck, forecheck, paycheck”
MD - he has a great sense of humour
Not so great…
MM - worst. interviews. evar.
JT - would be worst interviews if it wasn’t for MM
JMc- why so serious, bro?
Strictly on ice:
Great…
JMc - 111% effort every shift
CT - 111% effort every shift
NR - controversial pick but I love his work rate even if he does dolt out
Not so great…
PH - we already have Kampf and Dewar to do f-all
CD - we already have Holmberg and Kampf to do f-all
DK - unless you’re a little slow, you know where this is going
Great…
WN - taking the subway is completely based
NG - gotta love “backcheck, forecheck, paycheck”
MD - he has a great sense of humour
Not so great…
MM - worst. interviews. evar.
JT - would be worst interviews if it wasn’t for MM
JMc- why so serious, bro?
Strictly on ice:
Great…
JMc - 111% effort every shift
CT - 111% effort every shift
NR - controversial pick but I love his work rate even if he does dolt out
Not so great…
PH - we already have Kampf and Dewar to do f-all
CD - we already have Holmberg and Kampf to do f-all
DK - unless you’re a little slow, you know where this is going
mmalady
Registered User
Favs this year for all the same reason.. effective and hard working
JT
Tanev
McCabe
Least fav because they bring nothing to the table
Reeves
Holmberg
Kampf
Irrational dislike for their smug personality
Marner
Matthews
JT
Tanev
McCabe
Least fav because they bring nothing to the table
Reeves
Holmberg
Kampf
Irrational dislike for their smug personality
Marner
Matthews
