Iron Balls McGinty
Registered User
- Aug 5, 2005
- 8,711
- 8,308
Player Discussion: Yegor Chinakhov
- Thread starter ViD
- Start date
Double-Shift Lasse
Just post better
You mean when he came back from a few months off and the coach decided he couldn’t wait for him to get in game shape in a playoff race so he iced Luke Kunin instead?
Iron Balls McGinty
Registered User
- Aug 5, 2005
- 8,711
- 8,308
I mean he technically was "healthy scratched"
He was healthy enough to play which is why he was active but he was ineffective and maybe still out of shape and was a hinderance to the team at that time. I'm sure it was tied to his long term nagging back injury but if you are healthy enough to be activated but still being scratched I don't know what else you can call it.
If he wasn't healthy enough to contribute he shouldn't have been activated. Maybe it should have been handled differently. We are changing the strength and conditioning staff this year after all. But in the end, he could not keep up while the team was chasing a playoff spot. I hope that was only a temporary setback and the summer is a better reset for him.
spintheblackcircle
My cat would be a Tkachuk
- Mar 1, 2002
- 66,596
- 14,470
To me, these forwards are in the lineup before we get to Chinaknov:
Fantilli
Boone
KJ
Marchenko
Monahan
Olivier
Sillinger
Voronkov
I would also put LDBB in there before him, given that his PPG was the same as Chinakhov last year and he is 3 years younger coming off a healthy year. There is also ZAR who is signed for next year. This is a make or break season for him here.
Fantilli
Boone
KJ
Marchenko
Monahan
Olivier
Sillinger
Voronkov
I would also put LDBB in there before him, given that his PPG was the same as Chinakhov last year and he is 3 years younger coming off a healthy year. There is also ZAR who is signed for next year. This is a make or break season for him here.
CBJWerenski8
Formerly CBJWennberg10 (RIP Kivi)
- Jun 13, 2009
- 42,643
- 30,011
I think we all need to recognize the talent at hand here. When he was healthy he was one of our better players to start last year. He’s done that a few times in his career. When he plays and consistently stays healthy, he’s a legitimate player and a high scoring threat.
The problem is he doesn’t stay healthy. And never has. That’s not a small thing either. There’s no downplaying that issue, his availability is his biggest problem.
I’m good with whatever they do with him and see the value in keeping him. I doubt they’d get full value in a trade for him but he could be an attractive add in to a bigger deal. We’ll see what happens.
The problem is he doesn’t stay healthy. And never has. That’s not a small thing either. There’s no downplaying that issue, his availability is his biggest problem.
I’m good with whatever they do with him and see the value in keeping him. I doubt they’d get full value in a trade for him but he could be an attractive add in to a bigger deal. We’ll see what happens.
If Waddell goes big game hunting and they ask for Chinakhov as an addition to the package as a cheap low risk high reward piece, sure trade him. Trading him for the hell of it because others are viewed above him is completely nonsensical
spintheblackcircle
My cat would be a Tkachuk
- Mar 1, 2002
- 66,596
- 14,470
I'm not saying that. But if they are talking trade and the other team says "I'll take any of these 10 forwards on your active roster", I would have him at 10.
(and behind a few prospects, but we are talking the big club)
I’m genuinely curious if the players are paid differently from when they are “healthy” and scratched, or when they are on the IR or miss games due to an official injury.
Teams have done the same in the past, calling guys up and down to get guys paid NHL money instead of AHL money.
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Holy shit, you're using decimals? You must be really passionate about the guy.
I like him and I'm rooting for him but I can also see why he's being considered expendable as a result of those health issues. It's reminding me too much of the pain I went through with Murray.
KJ Dangler
Registered User
I tend to agree with @thebus88 .. Chinakov has the tools to be better than Marchenko.. he needs to stay healthy , and like Fantilli learned from really working with Monahan last year , he needs to let the game come to him , use his speed when the opportunity is there , but at the same point not skating 100mph in every situation
KJ Dangler
Registered User
That’s crazy talk… I’ll agree that Like Boone it’s hard to count on him to be healthy .. I will also say, I don’t find it a coincidence that Don axed the trainer here as well. Chinny, Voronkov , I think Don realized pretty quick there was an issue and took decisive action . But Chinakov when he’s been healthy is one of our best forwards .. dynamic speed , shot , size , etc .. it’s easy for forget he just turned 24 .. has a favorable contract , and any move involving him would likely be selling at a diminished asset value .. I think if your confident the training staff had a part in some of these guys missing games , you let it play out this year .. he could turn into an elite forward
Cyclones Rock
Registered User
- Jun 12, 2008
- 10,778
- 8,017
Players on an NHL roster are paid the same wage whether they play or are scratched for whatever reason. IR pay is the same as regular pay as well.
If a player is on a one way contract, he gets paid the same whether he's in the AHL or NHL. Players on 2 way deals get paid a different wage in the AHL than the NHL. For instance, Jack Williams would be paid at the daily rate of $775,000 contract next season for each day he's on the CBJ roster. If he's sent down to the AHL, he'd be paid at a daily rate based on an $85,000 contract. Puckpedia is a pretty good source for this info as to who is on one way or two way deals.
Iron Balls McGinty
Registered User
- Aug 5, 2005
- 8,711
- 8,308
I don't think so. I believe if you are on the NHL roster you are paid the same way regardless. Salaries are different between the NHL and AHL in most contracts but since NHL contracts are guaranteed I don't think IR status means a thing as long as you are on the roster.
If an AHL guy is called up and injured in the NHL and gets put on the NHL IR, then he gets lucky to be making NHL money while he recovers instead of his AHL salary. Even if an AHL guy gets called up and is a scratch for that night and sent back down, he still gets a full NHL payday just for being there.
...an AHL guy is called up and injured in the NHL and gets put on the NHL IR, then he gets lucky....
Maybe one of the most CBJ things ever written.
I know that's not what you meant, IBM, and I removed the context of how the injured player is paid (you are correct), but I found the phrase ironic/humorous/descriptive in a vacuum.
Iron Balls McGinty
Registered User
- Aug 5, 2005
- 8,711
- 8,308
Simply that if he suffered the same injuries in the AHL, he'd be paid his AHL salary on IR. If he was called up and played a single game in the NHL and got injured in that game, they can't send him down when he's injured even their original intention was to only have them play a game or 2 so he spends his time on NHL IR making an NHL salary.
He's then making an NHL salary for a longer period of time because he spends more time on the NHL roster. Nothing more than that. His "luck" is that the injury happened in a situation where he'd make more money.
Uhh, to be clear that’s the joke. It’s sarcasm. Pretty dumb reason not to criticize a player, just for the simple facts he plays on the team.
Everyone has “favorites”, and at the same time dislikes certain players from their favorite teams for a number of different reasons.
While some people may portray my opinions on players are based on something other than their impact on the ice, and on the TEAM overall, I assure you that is not true. Which is what makes it SO INSANE that there are CBJ fans (who apparently watch him play regularly) downplaying Chinakhov in ANY way.
I wholeheartedly believe people just have terrible and/or terribly selective memories. Chinakhov literally looked like our best forward last October and people are acting like that means nothing and that he’s “expendable” or not a potential long term piece.
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
The one predominant thing folks are getting on him for is his injury history. Again, it feels to me a lot like Ryan Murray, who was blatantly and obviously top-pairing when he was healthy but was practically never healthy.
spintheblackcircle
My cat would be a Tkachuk
- Mar 1, 2002
- 66,596
- 14,470
KJ Dangler
Registered User
SteelCityCannon
Registered User
- Mar 25, 2017
- 632
- 2,829
This whole thread is the dumbest argument ever 
Chinakhov's pure skill speaks for itself. He's the fastest skater and hardest shot on the team. Is anybody debating this? Dude just cant stay healthy, none of it matters from the press box. Is anybody debating this?
What are we even doing here?
Chinakhov's pure skill speaks for itself. He's the fastest skater and hardest shot on the team. Is anybody debating this? Dude just cant stay healthy, none of it matters from the press box. Is anybody debating this?
What are we even doing here?
