For what this board is supposed to be, which is a group of people that want to discuss the business aspects of the sport of hockey, I've always gotten a little annoyed at the "Atlanta's had two shots" crowd. I don't know if Atlanta should get another team, but I don't think anyone should really have a strong opinion until there's some detail behind a potential effort. However, dismissing it out of hand due to the Flames and Thrashers just seems lazy, and if we wanted lazy arguments, we could all go hang out on the NHL Talk Board.
It's the 11th largest metro area on the continent, and it's a lot different than it was in the Flames era. The Thrashers was its own issue.
Again, I'm not taking any side here, I'm not sure. Dismissing out of hand just seems pointless, though.