Not really. Jost, Nuke and PEB were their top PK forwards last year. JTC’s possession stats suck and he drags down pretty much any Avs forward he plays with in terms of possession and shot share. His Corsi stats are always absolute ass. He was -10.8% relative to his teammates last year. That’s atrocious.
He had an unusually lucky shooting season last year at 21%. He’ll never duplicate that again. 46% faceoff wins so be sucks in the circle.
$3.5mm AAV. It’s $4.5mm in cash this year is a hell of a lot to pay a defensively so so player that gets you 33 points.
So no. You haven’t swayed me.
How are those three the "top PK forwards" when Compher averaged 2:16 per game short handed this season, the most among Avs forwards who played more than 20 games (Calvert had 2:20 per game in 18 games)? When Compher is healthy enough to play, he's the top PKing forward.
And, Compher was 2nd to PEB in defensive ZS% among Avs fowards. Since he's out there in tough defensive situations much more frequently than he's getting a prime offensive chances, those Corsi results are completely expected, so I'm not sure why you're pretending it's proof of something.
I also don't know why his shooting % from a 47 shot sample is a huge negative. Ignoring this season, he's a career 11.2% shooter, which is pretty good. For comparison, Saad was a career 11.4% shooter coming into this season. Is that really bad?
Yes, he struggles in the circle, but as a winger, who cares?
His cap hit is a little higher than ideal, but Blake Coleman, another defensive specialist who averages ~33 points, just got $4.9m as a UFA.