ahh yeah spotify. thanks for that clarification. i'm curious to see what's #11 and 12.
Music: Which Band/Artist Has The Best 10 Greatest Hits?
- Thread starter Neutrinos
- Start date
11. Honky Tonk Women
12. You Can’t Always Get What You Want
Mescaleroman
Registered User
Not a Rock the Casbah fan so went with a slightly subjective list.
Although not subjective enough to include my fave Clash song ( Lose this Skin ).
Thought of having White Man in Hammersmith Palais on it but couldn't decide which song it would replace .
Mescaleroman
Registered User
Couldn't decide which song Heart of Gold would replace ? Or not a fan of it ?
Maybe have a mash up of After the Goldrush panning for a Heart of Gold
Hmmm. Tough one for me. I’d have to include Heart of Gold and Keep on Rockin in the Free World if I was doing a list of what I think people would generally have in his top 10.
My personal list of what I like would be comprised of 10 of the following but depending on my mood:
Cinnamon Girl
Everybody Knows This is Nowhere
Down by the River
After the Goldrush
Don’t Let it Bring You Down
Old Man
The Needle and the Damage Done
Ambulance Blues
Tonight’s the Night
Albuquerque
Cortez the Killer
Like a Hurricane
Powderfinger
Neutrinos
Registered User
- Sep 23, 2016
- 8,928
- 3,822
Acting as if Spotify views are now the definitive word on the matter is just being << patronizing >>
Good Times, Bad Times is #6 on Zeppelin's Spotify list, while Kashmir is #7
Over on Zeppelin's official YouTube page, Good Times, Bad Times has 5.7 million views, while the remastered version has 82k views
But for some reason there are 4 remastered versions of Kashmir on Zeppelin's YouTube page, and they have 49 million, 39 million, 8.3 million, and 64k views respectively
But as soon as you start picking and choosing randomly with no defined criteria the list becomes subjective. I was just explaining why my list excluded Jumpin’ Jack Flash.
Mescaleroman
Registered User
My subjective Springsteen list which would all be prior to Born in the USA
Jungleland
Candy's Room
Rosalita
Born to Run
Badlands
Blinded by the Light
Spirit in the Night
Tenth Avenue Freezeout
Thunder Road
Adam Raised a Cain
The objective list would include his monster hits.
Born in the USA , Glory Days , Dancing in the Dark , I'm on Fire , Hungry Heart , Cadillac Ranch etc.
Jungleland
Candy's Room
Rosalita
Born to Run
Badlands
Blinded by the Light
Spirit in the Night
Tenth Avenue Freezeout
Thunder Road
Adam Raised a Cain
The objective list would include his monster hits.
Born in the USA , Glory Days , Dancing in the Dark , I'm on Fire , Hungry Heart , Cadillac Ranch etc.
Neutrinos
Registered User
- Sep 23, 2016
- 8,928
- 3,822
Again, I go back to the hockey example where I also gave no defined criteria, yet, we can all agree who the best 4 centers are in Edmonton's history...
And we don't necessarily have to agree on exactly the 10 songs, but collectively, we should be able to come to a consensus on about 7 - 9 per band - still tough to do with the Beatles! - and then maybe we agree on an additional 4 or 5 songs to choose from for each band
For example, perhaps the majority of us agree that the following 7 songs belong in Elton John's top 10:
Tiny Dancer
Rocket Man
Goodbye Yellow Brick Road
Candle In The Wind
Daniel
Your Song
Can You Feel The Love Tonight?
And if most of us also agree in no particular order that these 6 belong in Elton's top 13:
I Guess That's Why They Call It The Blues
Crocodile Rock
Don't Go Breaking My Heart
Honky Cat
Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me
Saturday Night's Alright For Fighting
Using any 3 of those 6 will give us an accurate representation of Elton's top 10
Ceremony
blahem
- Jun 8, 2012
- 113,941
- 16,717
I think if you asked 100 people pretty much everyone would include Heart of Gold.
Plus you missed an obvious one in Horse With No Name.
Joking on the last one just to be clear.
i gotta ask as i'm very behind regarding music chart publications/services. back in the day i believe it was billboard and soundscan that for the most were supposedly the two main providers regarding airplay and sales data. is it safe to assume that spotify is the billboard of today? and who would be the replacement for soundscan? youtube?
Neutrinos
Registered User
- Sep 23, 2016
- 8,928
- 3,822
This still doesn’t make sense to me. Seems the question you’re asking is:
What do you feel are the top 10 most popular songs by a given artist?
Which seems pointless. « Popular » does not mean « best ».
For fun, here is an attempt at my personal Elton John top 10 (based on how much I enjoy each song):
1. Don’t Let the Sun Go Down on Me
2. Daniel
3. Your Song
4. Candle in the Wind
5. Rocket Man
6. Goodbye Yellow Brick Road
7. Bennie and the Jets
8. Border Song
9. Honky Cat
10. Crocodile Rock
I’m not familiar with Soundscan but I think Billboard is still good for tracking chart performance. With Spotify you can look at total streams for each song since it has been on the platform, which doesn’t always give the full picture, but it generally gives a good idea about a band’s most popular songs.
If we try real hard, we can squeeze category errors into sweet and salty pretzels.
Neutrinos
Registered User
- Sep 23, 2016
- 8,928
- 3,822
So, because it doesn't make sense to you, you'll just continue to derail the thread by posting your own personal list rather than one you think would represent a general audience?
Mescaleroman
Registered User
Dylan
Like a Rolling Stone
Mr Tambourine Man
It Ain't Me Babe
Blowin in the Wind
Tangled Up in Blue
Lay Lady Lay
Hurricane
The Times They Are a Changin
Knocking on Heavens Door
All Along the Watchtower
HM - Hard Rains Gonna Fall , It's All Over Now Baby Blue , Maggie's Farm
Like a Rolling Stone
Mr Tambourine Man
It Ain't Me Babe
Blowin in the Wind
Tangled Up in Blue
Lay Lady Lay
Hurricane
The Times They Are a Changin
Knocking on Heavens Door
All Along the Watchtower
HM - Hard Rains Gonna Fall , It's All Over Now Baby Blue , Maggie's Farm
perfect, just perfect. tiny dancer and philadelphia freedom are great as well but they won't crack into that list. i love island girl too but that would be blasphemy.
frisco
Some people claim that there's a woman to blame...
I think Presley is so far out in front he might win if you exclude his best 10 and run #11-20 in the race. I'd go (chronologically):
Heartbreak Hotel
Blue Suede Shoes
Don't Be Cruel
Hound Dog
Love Me Tender
All Shook Up
Let Me Be Your Teddy Bear
Jailhouse Rock
(Now And Then There's a...) Fool Such As I
It's Now Or Never
Are You Lonesome Tonight?
Little Sister
Can't Help Falling In Love
Good Luck Charm
Return To Sender
Devil In Disguise
Blue Christmas
Suspicious Minds
Burning Love
An American Trilogy
I'd take any 10 of those against anyone else's best 10. And that list leaves out, by my count, at least 7 Billboard #1-singles.
My Best-Carey
Heartbreak Hotel
Blue Suede Shoes
Don't Be Cruel
Hound Dog
Love Me Tender
All Shook Up
Let Me Be Your Teddy Bear
Jailhouse Rock
(Now And Then There's a...) Fool Such As I
It's Now Or Never
Are You Lonesome Tonight?
Little Sister
Can't Help Falling In Love
Good Luck Charm
Return To Sender
Devil In Disguise
Blue Christmas
Suspicious Minds
Burning Love
An American Trilogy
I'd take any 10 of those against anyone else's best 10. And that list leaves out, by my count, at least 7 Billboard #1-singles.
My Best-Carey
Last edited:
Neutrinos
Registered User
- Sep 23, 2016
- 8,928
- 3,822
Of the ones you listed, here are the 9 I'm familiar with:
Heartbreak Hotel
Blue Suede Shoes
Don't Be Cruel
Hound Dog
Love Me Tender
All Shook Up
Jailhouse Rock
Can't Help Falling In Love (you wrote Can't Stop Falling In Love)
Burning Love
As impressive as that list is, I struggle to see why that list of legendary 2 and a half minute pop-rock-love-songs should be elevated above the list of legendary 2 and a half minute pop-rock-love-songs that the early Beatles and Beach Boys can put together...
And from a technical standpoint, they're clearly a step down from some of the superior pieces you'll find on the top 10 lists of bands like Queen, Floyd, and Zeppelin...
Not to mention, Elvis didn't write his own music or lyrics, so the 10 songs on his list may very well have been written by 10 different songwriters...
Last edited:
Personally I’d put Elvis’ top 10 up against anyone else’s too. As far as being less technical that’s really just a sign of the times. His peak years were before my time so he’s not someone I listen to but he was huge for his era.
But I do have to agree that writing the songs is what separates the others like the Beatles etc from him. For me, writing great lyrics is at least as important as singing and interpreting other people’s lyrics.
Neutrinos
Registered User
- Sep 23, 2016
- 8,928
- 3,822
It's a sign of the times... until it isn't
IMO, that's part of what makes Floyd's top 10 so impressive... they brought innovation into the studio that still impresses half a century later...
As I said in the OP, I think judging a song is in some ways like judging competitive diving... degree of difficulty needs to count for something
Those early Elvis, Beatles, and Beach Boys tunes are each a flawless (or near flawless) 1-and-a-half in the pike position... but that's not as impressive as nailing a 3-and-a-half with 1-and-a-half twists, which is what I would consider a song like Stairway To Heaven to be...
With that said, originality certainly counts as well, as there's no doubt Elvis was a pioneer
Last edited:
