Which active players will be HHoFers someday?

[kevsh]

Yeah, I wouldn't be surprised if they all made it.

At least a dozen or more are mortal locks and from the rest most are still young enough that they have (prime) years to make their case (Kaprizov & Matthews for example).

 

[LeBrun is a Clown]

All aside from Kaprizov and maybe Rantanen/Panarin/Pasta

 

[Golden_Jet]

The only guy I have question about is Erik Karlsson. Everyone else I think has a good shot.

He’s a lock imo, every 2x or more winner is in but Keith, who will get in.
He has 3 Norris’s and twice runner up,

 

[Pavel Buchnevich]

On my personal list, all aside from MAF, Marchand, Kaprizov, Rantanen, Panarin, and Pastrnak.

 

[wetcoast]

The only guy I have question about is Erik Karlsson. Everyone else I think has a good shot.

I'm not even a huge EK65 fan but this is a really bad take.

On my personal list, all aside from MAF, Marchand, Kaprizov, Rantanen, Panarin, and Pastrnak.

I think all 6 of those guys are going to have enough in their resumes when it's all said and done.

MAF has probably the weakest case but Vegas probably gets him in.

 

[Skolman]

I voted for all of them. I’d be surprised if every single one didn’t get into the hall. The only ones that even give me pause are Fleury and Rantanen, but if guys like Carbonneau and Lowe can make it then they’re getting in too.

Panarin....?

Dude is already 33 years old, and has 804 career points.

Not to mention he hasn't really done much for his resume in the playoffs, 61 points in 73 playoff games.

 

[amnesiac]

the only forwards I question is Pasta and Marchand who may finish with the lowest PPG amongst the forwards (other than Barkov who has Selkes)

The only guy I have question about is Erik Karlsson. Everyone else I think has a good shot.

3 Norrises and (surely) 1000 points gets you into the HOF, no question

 

[amnesiac]

Panarin....?

Dude is already 33 years old, and has 804 career points.

Not to mention he hasn't really done much for his resume in the playoffs, 61 points in 73 playoff games.

in 687 GP, which puts him 5th in PPG amongst active players, and is currently 13th all-time in assists/game

many have got in the Hall with lower GP (Bossy, Lindros, Bure, Forsberg, Lafontaine, Stastny etc)

 

[Xspyrit]

It’s actually funny that some guys like Crosby, McDavid, Ovechkin, etc don’t have 100% of votes

 

[tarheelhockey]

Panarin....?

Dude is already 33 years old, and has 804 career points.

Not to mention he hasn't really done much for his resume in the playoffs, 61 points in 73 playoff games.

He didn’t even arrive in the NHL till 24. During the time he’s been in the league, he’s 5th in assists (ahead of Crosby).

Unless something bad happens, he’ll easily blow past 1000 and finish closer to 1200 or so despite his very late start. He’s been named the top LW in the league twice and finished 2nd two other times. As low as the bar is, there’s no reason he shouldn’t get in.

 

[Ben Grimm]

Panarin....? Dude is already 33 years old, and has 804 career points. Not to mention he hasn't really done much for his resume in the playoffs, 61 points in 73 playoff games.

in 687 GP, which puts him 5th in PPG amongst active players, and is currently 13th all-time in assists/game. many have got in the Hall with lower GP (Bossy, Lindros, Bure, Forsberg, Lafontaine, Stastny etc)

He didn’t even arrive in the NHL till 24. During the time he’s been in the league, he’s 5th in assists (ahead of Crosby). Unless something bad happens, he’ll easily blow past 1000 and finish closer to 1200 or so despite his very late start. He’s been named the top LW in the league twice and finished 2nd two other times. As low as the bar is, there’s no reason he shouldn’t get in.

106		Artemi Panarin	1991	F	73	21	40	61	34	-18	21:01	17:25	3:34	0:02	15	6	0	7	3	18	21	1	6	2	33	27	1	13	5	44.3%	0.821	1.563	2.384	0.708	0.849	1.557	1.381	4.832	6.212	0.288	0.548	0.836	194	10.8%	43	30	1	5	16.67%
107		Ken Hodge	1944	F	97	34	47	81	130	16					21	12	1	6	1	34	12	1	7	0	55	24	2	13	1	29.6%										0.351	0.485	0.835	237	14.4%
108		Johnny Bucyk	1935	F	124	41	62	103	42	29					25	16	0	3	0	32	30	0	10	0	57	46	0	13	0	44.7%										0.331	0.500	0.831	211	0.0%
109		Aleksander Barkov	1995	F	71	19	40	59	28	-3	22:01	16:19	3:27	2:14	15	3	1	5	0	24	15	1	7	1	39	18	2	12	1	30.5%	0.729	1.534	2.263	0.776	1.242	2.019	0.732	3.660	4.392	0.268	0.563	0.831	216	8.8%	150	58	753	655	53.48%
110		Mike Modano	1970	F	176	58	88	146	128	0					32	24	2	15	2	52	33	3	12	3	84	57	5	27	5	39.0%										0.330	0.500	0.830	507	11.4%	21	16	1447	1332	52.07%
111		Phil Kessel	1987	F	100	34	49	83	24	23	17:09	13:49	3:18	0:01	22	12	0	4	0	25	23	1	8	1	47	35	1	12	1	42.2%	1.189	1.713	2.902	0.955	1.085	2.040	2.180	4.178	6.358	0.340	0.490	0.830	305	11.2%	36	24	2	12	14.29%
112		Tom Lysiak	1953	F	76	25	38	63	49	-2					15	10	0	2	0	29	8	1	8	3	44	18	1	10	3	28.6%										0.329	0.500	0.829	194	12.9%
113		Ryan O'Reilly	1991	F	81	26	41	67	15	0	21:05	16:08	2:53	2:04	16	10	0	5	1	28	10	3	8	3	44	20	3	13	4	29.9%	0.913	1.440	2.352	0.734	1.285	2.019	2.566	2.566	5.132	0.321	0.506	0.827	174	14.9%	50	61	886	798	52.61%
114		Anze Kopitar	1987	F	97	25	55	80	45	15	21:46	16:18	3:28	1:59	17	6	2	5	3	34	20	1	10	4	51	26	3	15	7	32.5%	0.710	1.562	2.273	0.645	1.289	1.934	1.067	3.555	4.622	0.258	0.567	0.825	222	11.3%	211	84	1060	948	52.79%
115		Bryan Trottier	1956	F	221	71	111	182	277	31					49	18	4	12	1	67	40	4	16	2	116	58	8	28	3	31.9%										0.321	0.502	0.824	472	15.0%
116		Ryan Nugent-Hopkins	1993	F	74	17	44	61	28	-18	20:17	14:14	3:43	2:19	11	6	0	3	0	18	25	1

Is being ahead of those guys in playoff PPG really that horrible? @amnesiac @tarheelhockey

 

[Skolman]

106		Artemi Panarin	1991	F	73	21	40	61	34	-18	21:01	17:25	3:34	0:02	15	6	0	7	3	18	21	1	6	2	33	27	1	13	5	44.3%	0.821	1.563	2.384	0.708	0.849	1.557	1.381	4.832	6.212	0.288	0.548	0.836	194	10.8%	43	30	1	5	16.67%
107		Ken Hodge	1944	F	97	34	47	81	130	16					21	12	1	6	1	34	12	1	7	0	55	24	2	13	1	29.6%										0.351	0.485	0.835	237	14.4%
108		Johnny Bucyk	1935	F	124	41	62	103	42	29					25	16	0	3	0	32	30	0	10	0	57	46	0	13	0	44.7%										0.331	0.500	0.831	211	0.0%
109		Aleksander Barkov	1995	F	71	19	40	59	28	-3	22:01	16:19	3:27	2:14	15	3	1	5	0	24	15	1	7	1	39	18	2	12	1	30.5%	0.729	1.534	2.263	0.776	1.242	2.019	0.732	3.660	4.392	0.268	0.563	0.831	216	8.8%	150	58	753	655	53.48%
110		Mike Modano	1970	F	176	58	88	146	128	0					32	24	2	15	2	52	33	3	12	3	84	57	5	27	5	39.0%										0.330	0.500	0.830	507	11.4%	21	16	1447	1332	52.07%
111		Phil Kessel	1987	F	100	34	49	83	24	23	17:09	13:49	3:18	0:01	22	12	0	4	0	25	23	1	8	1	47	35	1	12	1	42.2%	1.189	1.713	2.902	0.955	1.085	2.040	2.180	4.178	6.358	0.340	0.490	0.830	305	11.2%	36	24	2	12	14.29%
112		Tom Lysiak	1953	F	76	25	38	63	49	-2					15	10	0	2	0	29	8	1	8	3	44	18	1	10	3	28.6%										0.329	0.500	0.829	194	12.9%
113		Ryan O'Reilly	1991	F	81	26	41	67	15	0	21:05	16:08	2:53	2:04	16	10	0	5	1	28	10	3	8	3	44	20	3	13	4	29.9%	0.913	1.440	2.352	0.734	1.285	2.019	2.566	2.566	5.132	0.321	0.506	0.827	174	14.9%	50	61	886	798	52.61%
114		Anze Kopitar	1987	F	97	25	55	80	45	15	21:46	16:18	3:28	1:59	17	6	2	5	3	34	20	1	10	4	51	26	3	15	7	32.5%	0.710	1.562	2.273	0.645	1.289	1.934	1.067	3.555	4.622	0.258	0.567	0.825	222	11.3%	211	84	1060	948	52.79%
115		Bryan Trottier	1956	F	221	71	111	182	277	31					49	18	4	12	1	67	40	4	16	2	116	58	8	28	3	31.9%										0.321	0.502	0.824	472	15.0%
116		Ryan Nugent-Hopkins	1993	F	74	17	44	61	28	-18	20:17	14:14	3:43	2:19	11	6	0	3	0	18	25	1

Is being ahead of those guys in playoff PPG really that horrible? @amnesiac @tarheelhockey

You sure you want to go down that road?

I guess it's settled.. Panarin is better than Modano, Barkov, and Kopitar in the post-season.

 

[tarheelhockey]

106		Artemi Panarin	1991	F	73	21	40	61	34	-18	21:01	17:25	3:34	0:02	15	6	0	7	3	18	21	1	6	2	33	27	1	13	5	44.3%	0.821	1.563	2.384	0.708	0.849	1.557	1.381	4.832	6.212	0.288	0.548	0.836	194	10.8%	43	30	1	5	16.67%
107		Ken Hodge	1944	F	97	34	47	81	130	16					21	12	1	6	1	34	12	1	7	0	55	24	2	13	1	29.6%										0.351	0.485	0.835	237	14.4%
108		Johnny Bucyk	1935	F	124	41	62	103	42	29					25	16	0	3	0	32	30	0	10	0	57	46	0	13	0	44.7%										0.331	0.500	0.831	211	0.0%
109		Aleksander Barkov	1995	F	71	19	40	59	28	-3	22:01	16:19	3:27	2:14	15	3	1	5	0	24	15	1	7	1	39	18	2	12	1	30.5%	0.729	1.534	2.263	0.776	1.242	2.019	0.732	3.660	4.392	0.268	0.563	0.831	216	8.8%	150	58	753	655	53.48%
110		Mike Modano	1970	F	176	58	88	146	128	0					32	24	2	15	2	52	33	3	12	3	84	57	5	27	5	39.0%										0.330	0.500	0.830	507	11.4%	21	16	1447	1332	52.07%
111		Phil Kessel	1987	F	100	34	49	83	24	23	17:09	13:49	3:18	0:01	22	12	0	4	0	25	23	1	8	1	47	35	1	12	1	42.2%	1.189	1.713	2.902	0.955	1.085	2.040	2.180	4.178	6.358	0.340	0.490	0.830	305	11.2%	36	24	2	12	14.29%
112		Tom Lysiak	1953	F	76	25	38	63	49	-2					15	10	0	2	0	29	8	1	8	3	44	18	1	10	3	28.6%										0.329	0.500	0.829	194	12.9%
113		Ryan O'Reilly	1991	F	81	26	41	67	15	0	21:05	16:08	2:53	2:04	16	10	0	5	1	28	10	3	8	3	44	20	3	13	4	29.9%	0.913	1.440	2.352	0.734	1.285	2.019	2.566	2.566	5.132	0.321	0.506	0.827	174	14.9%	50	61	886	798	52.61%
114		Anze Kopitar	1987	F	97	25	55	80	45	15	21:46	16:18	3:28	1:59	17	6	2	5	3	34	20	1	10	4	51	26	3	15	7	32.5%	0.710	1.562	2.273	0.645	1.289	1.934	1.067	3.555	4.622	0.258	0.567	0.825	222	11.3%	211	84	1060	948	52.79%
115		Bryan Trottier	1956	F	221	71	111	182	277	31					49	18	4	12	1	67	40	4	16	2	116	58	8	28	3	31.9%										0.321	0.502	0.824	472	15.0%
116		Ryan Nugent-Hopkins	1993	F	74	17	44	61	28	-18	20:17	14:14	3:43	2:19	11	6	0	3	0	18	25	1

Is being ahead of those guys in playoff PPG really that horrible? @amnesiac @tarheelhockey

Panarin hasn’t even been particularly bad in the playoffs, he just doesn’t have a signature run. He was in the PPG range in 16, 18, 19, 20, 24. His 2022 looks a little weaker than you’d want, but that had a lot to do with facing Jaccob Slavin for 7 games in between going PPG in two other series.

The blemishes on his resume are 2017, when Chicago as a team scored 3 total goals while getting dusted by Nashville, and the 2023 NYR/NJD series. The 2023 series is the real black eye, getting completely shut out after the first period of Game 1 of a seven game series. That’s just ugly. But it was one series. As a whole, his playoff career has been pretty ordinary but without that shining moment.

 

[Ben Grimm]

You sure you want to go down that road? I guess it's settled. Panarin is better than Modano, Barkov, and Kopitar in the post-season.

Panarin....? Dude is already 33 years old, and has 804 career points. Not to mention he hasn't really done much for his resume in the playoffs, 61 points in 73 playoff games.

Are you sure you want to go down that road? You're the one who brought up playoff PPG. In reality and by your own argument Panarin is better than Modano, Barkov, and Kopitar in playoff PPG. In all my years here I've never seen someone get so completely trashed (by @amnesiac and @tarheelhockey) and then just keep digging the hole deeper. Just stop now while you're behind and enjoy your 30th bday, kid.

 

[Pavel Buchnevich]

Panarin hasn’t even been particularly bad in the playoffs, he just doesn’t have a signature run. He was in the PPG range in 16, 18, 19, 20, 24. His 2022 looks a little weaker than you’d want, but that had a lot to do with facing Jaccob Slavin for 7 games in between going PPG in two other series.

The blemishes on his resume are 2017, when Chicago as a team scored 3 total goals while getting dusted by Nashville, and the 2023 NYR/NJD series. The 2023 series is the real black eye, getting completely shut out after the first period of Game 1 of a seven game series. That’s just ugly. But it was one series. As a whole, his playoff career has been pretty ordinary but without that shining moment.

That’s not really true. The point totals might look not that bad, but he’s been one of the best regular season players over the last five years and in the playoffs is nowhere near that. It’s especially true at even strength. It’s a substantial difference. The lack of space is a problem. He doesn’t adapt well to that, and gets snuffed out a lot. He’s actually had some very clutch moments, but on the whole his lack of production is arguably the biggest reason the Rangers haven’t won the Cup. You can’t just turn a potential MVP candidate into an okay second line winger and act like that changes nothing.

 

[Mrb1p]

You're missing Lane Hutson

 

[Bouboumaster]

Most of them

 

[hamzarocks]

Every single one of those players will be in the hall

Marchand and MAF being the weakest inclusions

 

[ScottyMascotty]

Everyone of them.

 

[Kingfan1967]

Missing Drew Doughty, J. Quick, Roman Josi.

 

[Skolman]

Are you sure you want to go down that road? You're the one who brought up playoff PPG. In reality and by your own argument Panarin is better than Modano, Barkov, and Kopitar in playoff PPG. In all my years here I've never seen someone get so completely trashed (by @amnesiac and @tarheelhockey) and then just keep digging the hole deeper. Just stop now while you're behind and enjoy your 30th bday, kid.

Jeesh, you're taking HF way too serious pal, my apologies for offending you.

Considering how long and how often you post on HF, if that's your definition of "completely trashed" that's quite something.

31% of people that have voted agree with you, I hope that doesn't burn you up too much inside.

 

[Shark Finn]

The Celebrini disrespect around these parts of hfboards is utterly disgusting.