Where did Yzerman go wrong with the rebuild?

Winger98

Moderator
Feb 27, 2002
23,282
5,448
Cleveland
Exactly. and from a business perspective the team has no identity or face to put on the marketing materials.

I truly think part of the Abdelkader contract was just to have a name people knew to carry the Wings through years where there was going to be a lot of turnover.

we would also have no leader in that locker room. By all appearances Larkin does everything the right way, he's the kind of guy you want around a bunch of young players learning what they have to do to make it in the NHL.
 

SirKillalot

Registered User
Feb 27, 2008
6,090
450
Norway
I think Zegras can be had with pennies on the dollar. Not that he is a 'needle mover' but we need more young dynamic players in this lineup.
Yeah I think Zegras by himself doesn't move the needle, but if the trade is good value wise, if he can find chemistry with someone, it could potentially be a great fit. If he found that with Kasper or Danielson when they come up and another two-way player on such line.

Also why I think they should have been in on Fabbro, idk if they were. Him alone doesn't move the needle much, but if he would have landed in Detroit, finding a solid d-partner for him could make it overall good if the chemistry would be there.
 

Steve Yzerlland

Registered User
Jul 18, 2018
8,819
4,468
Yeah I think Zegras by himself doesn't move the needle, but if the trade is good value wise, if he can find chemistry with someone, it could potentially be a great fit. If he found that with Kasper or Danielson when they come up and another two-way player on such line.

Also why I think they should have been in on Fabbro, idk if they were. Him alone doesn't move the needle much, but if he would have landed in Detroit, finding a solid d-partner for him could make it overall good if the chemistry would be there.
Yeah I wanted Fabbro as well.
 

wingsfannn919191

Registered User
Oct 3, 2024
263
175
I think Zegras can be had with pennies on the dollar. Not that he is a 'needle mover' but we need more young dynamic players in this lineup.
Think zegras is the exact type of player we should target. Top 10 pick,still young & hasn't seen a bunch of teams like perlini (who didnt see that disaster coming?)

Had 60-65 back to back seasons to start his career. Dont know what happened there but the whole teams struggling there. Definetly think he can be a 70-80 pt guy

Zegras larkin raymond

Think that could be a hell of a line next year... sadly I dont think yzerman would entertain it anyways

Yeah I wanted Fabbro as well.
Keep hearing david jiricek and columbus not going well. Doubt it happens with seider pellika here but that could solidify the right side for 10+yrs

Seider
Pellika
Jiricek

I know a veteran right dman likely fills that spot but coulda been nice haha
 

Oddbob

Registered User
Jan 21, 2016
16,677
11,230
we would also have no leader in that locker room. By all appearances Larkin does everything the right way, he's the kind of guy you want around a bunch of young players learning what they have to do to make it in the NHL.

There is one thing that still pisses me off about Larkin and he seems to be doing more again the past 2 seasons. The looking for calls and "diving" a lot of times and on a lot of ticky tack garbage. It is the one thing that has always bothered me about him and wish he would knock off. Trying to make the refs look bad just gets you fewer calls in the future, and isn't respectable. He seems like a great leader in every other way except for this issue.
 

Zetterberg4Captain

Registered User
Aug 11, 2009
14,210
2,510
Detroit
I think Zegras can be had with pennies on the dollar. Not that he is a 'needle mover' but we need more young dynamic players in this lineup.

SY needs to do something both upfront and in the backend...

If it's not actively looking to improve then send guys back down and start selling off...the middle ground is not the right plan
 

lilidk

Registered User
Mar 4, 2008
10,985
4,226
It's time to start selling off.

Kane
Fischer
Berggren
Lyon

Maybe Veleno/Rasmussen/Gustafsson. Idk if Petry/Chaiort/Holl/Motte hold any trade value at all.
Fischer only makes 1.1, id keep him, also Motte should stay , underpaid local guy .
 

Steve Yzerlland

Registered User
Jul 18, 2018
8,819
4,468
So many bad contracts I don’t even know where to start
Yzerman has done a terrible job since 2019 let's just call a spade a spade. I loved him as a player. Probably my second favorite wing all time after Fedorov but who cares about all that shit. This team has zero direction. Is old. Has horrible contracts.
Zero elite young superstar dynamic offensive players. Yeah you could say Raymond but I don't ever see him as a perennial 90-100pt season kind of guy. Its just a complete shit show. And the owner sucks too. Yzerman has zero pressure of losing his job. Country club vibes.
 

Snuggs

Registered User
Jun 24, 2018
2,702
1,358
Selling off in November. OK dude....
Even if you wanted to, I don't think all could be sold off. I'm just saying in-general, yeah it's sell time anyone of those players at any moment. Unless you've got some sort of confidence this is a playoff capable team?

I like some of these guys even but if you're going to suck this year, and they're on one-year deals, you have to squeeze some value out.
 
Last edited:

The Zermanator

In Yzerman We Trust
Jan 21, 2013
3,520
1,512
Yzerman has done a terrible job since 2019 let's just call a spade a spade. I loved him as a player. Probably my second favorite wing all time after Fedorov but who cares about all that shit. This team has zero direction. Is old. Has horrible contracts.
Zero elite young superstar dynamic offensive players. Yeah you could say Raymond but I don't ever see him as a perennial 90-100pt season kind of guy. Its just a complete shit show. And the owner sucks too. Yzerman has zero pressure of losing his job. Country club vibes.

Name a single example of such a player that Yzerman missed out on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoupNazi

Twinger

Registered User
Sep 28, 2017
102
51
Whatever side you're on this is pretty much the core of the rebuilt team. (I also define core as your 5 players so you can pick who you want) Larkin, Raymond, Seider and Evinsson then one of the below guys.
Butch
ASP
Nate
Kasper
Cossa

Im not sure how far that core pushes us towards a cup in the next 5 years

Yes yes yes we're going to be getting rid of the dead weight contracts and all our prospect development will be linear but probably 1 of those 5 listed prospect will be an impact player. If Kasper /Nate become 55+ and great defensively then that's amazing but is that enough of a core to push us to a cup in that window?
 

Steve Yzerlland

Registered User
Jul 18, 2018
8,819
4,468
Name a single example of such a player that Yzerman missed out on.
So i have to do his job to prove he is doing his job lower than we all expected? If I could tell you who we should have gotten wouldn't that make him look even worse? I have a question for you, are you pleased where we are almost 6 years after he was hired?
 
  • Like
Reactions: David D

norrisnick

The best...
Apr 14, 2005
31,226
16,567
So i have to do his job to prove he is doing his job lower than we all expected? If I could tell you who we should have gotten wouldn't that make him look even worse? I have a question for you, are you pleased where we are almost 6 years after he was hired?
The 6 years before he was hired led to the 6 years after. Short of Fox and Panarin saying f*** NYC, Detroit is where it's at there was no speeding it up. The franchise altering guys fall in your lap or you build slowly and incrementally. There is no other way.
 

wingsfannn919191

Registered User
Oct 3, 2024
263
175
It's time to start selling off.

Kane
Fischer
Berggren
Lyon

Maybe Veleno/Rasmussen/Gustafsson. Idk if Petry/Chaiort/Holl/Motte hold any trade value at all.
Sell berggren when hes finally producing and can build up his trade value longer he stays over likes of veleno gustafsson copp etc... ummmm ok

And if your looking for trade value you move Talbot. Hes probably the only player that can fetch a 1st with retention from a contender like Colorado that we can then use to pull another debrincat like move. We cant do that cause husso is always hurt

Kane will bring back squat cause he'll decide where to go. Likely a 3rd

If it were up to me copp at 3-3.5 might be able to be moved . Talbot retained and veleno while we still can. Prob hang on to Rasmussen for his size for now

Dont need 2 expensive 4th line guys
 

David D

Registered User
Apr 1, 2018
49
33
That's the problem with SY. He hasn't been proactive in shaking things up. Look at Vegas, how they are an aggressive organization that is proactive in trades
 
  • Like
Reactions: DamonDRW

raymond23

lgrw
Sponsor
Sep 28, 2017
7,004
7,477
Grand Rapids, MI
Negative value contracts

Husso (last year)
Rasmussen
Chiarot
Holl
Petry (last year)
Gustafsson
Tarasenko
Copp
Compher (is beginning to look that way)

That’s like $40mill off the top of my head? In contracts you’d have to pay someone to take?

Not to mention we spent a 2nd and 4th rounded this offseason to clear two other contracts
 
  • Like
Reactions: Twinger

David D

Registered User
Apr 1, 2018
49
33
Sell berggren when hes finally producing and can build up his trade value longer he stays over likes of veleno gustafsson copp etc... ummmm ok

And if your looking for trade value you move Talbot. Hes probably the only player that can fetch a 1st with retention from a contender like Colorado that we can then use to pull another debrincat like move. We cant do that cause husso is always hurt

Kane will bring back squat cause he'll decide where to go. Likely a 3rd

If it were up to me copp at 3-3.5 might be able to be moved . Talbot retained and veleno while we still can. Prob hang on to Rasmussen for his size for now

Dont need 2 expensive 4th line guys
No more draft picks!! We're beyond that now and we need to acquire prospects over picks
 

SoupNazi

Gee Wally/SoupNazi 2024
Feb 6, 2010
27,060
17,161
So i have to do his job to prove he is doing his job lower than we all expected? If I could tell you who we should have gotten wouldn't that make him look even worse? I have a question for you, are you pleased where we are almost 6 years after he was hired?
You didn’t answer his question. Can you answer it?
 

lilidk

Registered User
Mar 4, 2008
10,985
4,226
Just leave Hole and Copp, both have negative trading values , trade everyone else except first and third lines ,Ed and Seider. Talbot and Cossa tandem will be great. Sell, sell, sell, bring #3 defansman
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad