I would only prefer one to the other with a gun at my head, but... hmm, I think
Closer is when they were really firing on all cylinders as a band, creatively and technically.
Closer is a bewilderingly inventive yet tense album where every second feels like a suspension cable about to snap; grief, in one side, but not out the other. You can't listen to it without sadly trying to imagine its successor.
That said, I think
Unknown Pleasures is kind of the portrait of Joy Division. It's an engulfing atmosphere that can never be reproduced. I love the two opening snare hits... Last Chance road sign (any album that opens with snare hits rules as far as I'm concerned.) Something about that album's sound has always been oddly comforting to me; there's this eerie prenatal-warmth to it despite sounding like they recorded on the ****ing moon. Actually, a lot of their songs, before and after, are like that for me... especially their best* song:
That suspended, far-off sound that opens the song—I don't even know what it is, synthesizer I guess... feedback, only reverb maybe—just
washes over me... every single ****ing time; vast industrial monotony. 'Dead Souls' is my runner-up favorite, same vibe. Joy Division was probably the first
good band I ever liked. I remember walking to the bus stop at, not even the literal ass-crack-of-dawn, it was still ****ing dark out until spring, ear buds in, sipping my thermos of coffee.
*'Ceremony' is the best, but that's just the best song by anyone. Period.
Definitely one of my favorites.
Have you seen the movie
Control? Came out, Idk, like six or seven years ago. It's pretty good from what I remember. And
24-Hour Party People is just awesome
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/495f1/495f185fc1f2d2bd459ec9ded3ca2eb67b513d95" alt="laugh :laugh: :laugh:"
; Steve Coogan is the funniest goddamn human being on earth.