What Would You Do?

[Cloned]

Well let’s hear it.

I left out completely unrealistic things like trading Nurse or McDrai.

Click to read more...

 

[Mr Kot]

Just picked the obvious ones, trade jeff and stuart skinners if you can, they are movable in some respect. Open up cap space to try for a starting goalie. Then, if possible, go for the top 4 d with what assets we have available.

 

[Senor Catface]

Follow cricket.

 

[Cloned]

Follow cricket.

I hear the Melbourne Oilers are quite good.

 

[guymez]

Try to stay in the playoff hunt until things open up (and more options are available) in the new year.
The best opportunities to improve the team are going to happen when its clear that certain teams (who expected to be better) are not likely to make the playoffs.

 

[Reasonable Oil Fan]

A lot of these choices cannot be done on their own some need to combined.
Like trade RNH and Hyman for defensemen

 

[McDNicks17]

I went with:

1) Trade for Depth F/D - Dermott needs to go. Get an actual NHL leftie for the third pair, so you can play it for more than 10 minutes a night.
2) Trade Skinner for a starter - Get an NHL goalie. Doesn't even have to be anyone special.
3) Trade RNH - He won't waive his NMC, but he's long been the human embodiment of everything wrong with the Oilers. Fire him into the sun.
4) Trade Jeff Skinner - Same as RNH.
5) Fire Schwartz - For obvious reasons.

 

[brentashton]

Great poll.

Fire Schwartz

Trade RNH and Skinner for a real goalie and bottom depth player.

A lot of these choices cannot be done on their own some need to combined.
Like trade RNH and Hyman for defensemen

The poll allows multiple choices…put them together.

 

[Tobias Kahun]

Keep Hyman, and the coaching staff minus Schwartz, keep bowman and jackson.

 

[McAsuno]

Trade one of Pickard/Skinner and obtain a goalie like Blackwood unless they think they can hit the Gibson route, fire Schwartz so that idiot can't ruin another Oilers goalie, and trade for that elusive top four d man that Stauffer keeps yapping about.

 

[thadd]

I feel that we need to chill.
We don't have a ton of assets.

I have no use for our president, GM and goalie coach.

For reference regarding Bowman -> History of hockey trades by general manager Stan Bowman - NHL Trade Tracker

When we hired him, I was shocked. I don't understand how he got a job in the NHL given his trade history.

All 3 of his cups were due to Dave Talon's efforts.

 

[Dorian2]

We're good.

 

[Sheikyerbouti]

Fire Jackson but that's not happening.

We have to chill because we have no assets or cap room to do anything. I would like to see Jeff Skinner jettisoned, it would create flexibility and raise the standards for effort.

 

[JeffSkinner53]

Priority 1- need a goalie. Blackwood or Gibson.
Priority 1A- fire Schwartz
Priority 2- need a bottom pairing D-man. Keep Dermott off the ice.

We are actually underrated defensively, it's really Skinner that's the problem unfortunately. We can however shore up on D.

We lack cap space but it's doable. Time for Bowman to get creative.

 

[LTIR]

J.Skinner is the only option.
No one else is going to waive their NMC and the ones without NMC have no value.

 

[Kerberos]

Trade Skinner. His moustache is nasty and ridden with diseases.
Trade RNH. His lack of compete and coattail riding doesn't help us win.
Trade Jeff Skinner. One dimensional player who was supposed to bring offense but doesn't.
Trade for a RHD that can anchor a pairing with Nurse since Bouchard is playing like a flaming bag of dog shit this season and doing his best to tank Ekholm's game.
Fire Schwartz and give him an award for being one of the most unqualified hirings in human history.
Fire Gulutzan who doesn't actually coach anything.
Fire Stan Bowman because he's a despicable human.
Fire JJ because people who can be called JJ are saddled with generational curses.

 

[MessierII]

Nothing for at least another month

 

[TheGingaNinja]

The only moves imo that can realistically be done are upgrading Pickard to a 1B situation, and using what little assets we have to secure a top 4D (Prolly at the deadline) which hopefully stabilizes the D, spreads out the minutes better and gives us some depth in case of injuries. I don't think any sort of impactful forward is realistic (To make cap room you'd both need to get someone to waive and use assets better used elsewhere.), nor is a significant upgrade at 1A goalie due to availability and cap.

For the offence, the answer will have to be in the room imo, for better or worse. At least there's the hope Kane can comeback and make an impact up front.

Any which way you slice it, some improvement has to come from within as a large roster turnover just isn't realistic.

I think most will agree on Schwartz though, lol.

 

[Cloned]

The only moves imo that can realistically be done are upgrading Pickard to a 1B situation, and using what little assets we have to secure a top 4D (Prolly at the deadline) which hopefully stabilizes the D, spreads out the minutes better and gives us some depth in case of injuries. I don't think any sort of impactful forward is realistic (To make cap room you'd both need to get someone to waive and use assets better used elsewhere.), nor is a significant upgrade at 1A goalie due to availability and cap.

For the offence, the answer will have to be in the room imo, for better or worse. At least there's the hope Kane can comeback and make an impact up front.

Any which way you slice it, some improvement has to come from within as a large roster turnover just isn't realistic.

I think most will agree on Schwartz though, lol.

Surprisingly only 76% so far lol.

 

[Drivesaitl]

Surprisingly only 76% so far lol.

Undeniably some people would always think its a one option poll. So that the 76% would likely be higher, just saying. People are conditioned to have one option. In democracy bad options. whoops.

 

[Hockeylife2018]

I'm all for packaging
1)Skinner or pickard
2)a luxury forward, likely nuge for cap reasons
3) picks

For a legit starter, however I don't want this move done unless the supervisor of the goalie graveyard in on his way out aswell

 

[TheGingaNinja]

Surprisingly only 76% so far lol.

Gotta be some folks just missed it or something. Or there's a larger, silent, Schwartz fanbase than I would have ever guessed, lol.

 

[5 Mins 4 Ftg]

Trade J Skinner for that Accrued Cap Space guy. Kane replaces Skinner.

Fire Schwartz and replace him with Hunter or the rando guy in Section 117, Row 15, Seat 11 or the weatherman from Global as they can’t do any worse.

Find a bottom line energy player with size who hits and hits and then hits some more who can Pk. I also bring up Philp and farm Ryan.

At or near the TDL use that accrued cap space with double retention and all the draft picks and prospects necessary to find a replacement starter for Skinner with Skinner being moved out at the same time for the cap space, and a top 4 RD to play with Nurse.

Get a brain transplant for Bouchard.

Kane McDavid Hyman
Henrique Draisaitl Arvidsson
Podkolzin RNH Perry/Brown
Janmark Philp Energyman

Ekholm Bouchard with new brain.
Nurse Top4RDman
Kulak Emberson
Stetcher

NewStartingGoalie
Pickard

 

[NotAVacuumSalesman]

This brings me back to the Chiarelli days.

Death by a thousand cuts. It’s probably been mentioned already somewhere.

 

[rboomercat90]

The poll needs an option where we can build a Time Machine and go back to June 30 and redo our entire off season. Not sure anything else is going to help at this point.



Also, why has this site gone back to being such garbage in the last few days where it takes 20 minutes to type out a post this long between all the buffering, page freezing and reloading. I thought we were done with that crap. I haven’t experienced it since last season.