This is not why it was done. At least the reason given was it stems back to the vB to XF 1.5 migration. Importing/converting the database to the XF 1.5 version was taking *days*. The way the cutover was being done back then, it would have resulted in a couple weeks downtime if they attempted to import the whole DB.
I certainly would have handled it different (archive site at a minimum) but every mod here is an unpaid post janitor. The people who own the site are gonna do what they are gonna do to a certain extent. At the time I was not really in control of as much (RE: Almost nothing) as I am now, or I'd have fought harder for some form of content preservation.
It still may have been a technically surmountable problem but whatever the reasons they did not or gave up attempting so were not given to us.
In that case, the decision to migrate to Xf should have also been reconsidered. Content deletion (that is, hard deletion,) should imo be the absolute last resort, considered only when absolutely every option has bern exhausted. My issue is that I don’t think this was the case, and it seems that the powers that be were all to eager to pull the trigger on hard deletion of over a decade of content that some of us spent a significant amount of time producing. I had threads that I literally spent weeks on get simply obliterated from existence, and I’m someone who sponsored this website for over a decade.
Again, as someone who has spent over a decade in a career of database management, administration, data engineering, etc I would have happily lent my services for free had i been asked, and I am sure there are many people on this website with the same skill sets who would have done the same. This website used to mean a lot to me, and preserving all of that content was important to me.
Whether or not you’re a moderator is neither here nor there, to be honest. That’s not a job that necessarily requires any expertise on the topic. I say that not to denigrate the work, as it’s not something I would do even for money, but just to say that it requires completely different skills than solving technical problems like how to support a platform migration without losing content.
It is just so horrible, deleting all of that data in an irretrievable way. I cannot think of a single worse thing you could do as the owner of a website.
And that’s without even getting into the fact that xenforo f***ing sucks.