Buffalo Bills Week 10-- Buffalo (7-2) @ Indianapolis (4-5) Sunday 11/10, 1:00 PM, CBS

Willgamesh

Registered User
Jan 31, 2019
1,204
1,200
Is Benford our best defensive player? Certainly seems that way to me. Anyone want to attemtp our top-5 players on offense and defense?
Offense: Allen, Shakir, Cooper, Cook, Kincaid. Defense: Milano, Benford, Bernard, Johnson,Groot.
Feel like D it gets more complicated Oliver when he's on Douglas etc
 

Zman5778

Moderator
Oct 4, 2005
26,734
25,411
Cressona/Reading, PA
Why not both? :p
Roger.

Top 5, in order......based on talent and nothing but:
Offense: Allen, Cooper, Dawkins, Kincaid, Brown (HM: Torrence)
Defense: Miller, Oliver, Groot, Johnson, Benford/Douglas (HM: Bishop)

Top 5, in order.....based on importance to the team:
Offense: Allen, Dawkins, Shakir, Brown, McGovern
Defense: Johnson, Milano, Douglas/Benford, Oliver, Bernard

I'm kind of treating Benford/Douglas as one......as I see them as extraordinarily similar in both talent and importance to the team. Although, I feel like we can lose ONE of Douglas OR Benford and be OK overall.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dubi Doo

buffalowing88

Registered User
Aug 11, 2008
4,526
1,966
Charlotte, NC
Is Benford our best defensive player? Certainly seems that way to me. Anyone want to attemtp our top-5 players on offense and defense?
I think we tried this a year or two ago. It's a fun exercise to discuss if nothing else. I tend to rank my top-5 by their current value to winning each game they play in. So for right now, the top-5 are:

1. Allen
75 yards of dirt
2. Bernard
3. Douglas
4. Dawkins
5. Benford

Shakir, McGovern, Oliver, and Rousseau deserve honorable mentions.

EDIT: Milano is not making any list for me until I see him in game action again. I thought he looked like he still was a step behind in training camp before he got injured. Maybe the added time to rest will be good for his leg.
 

Willgamesh

Registered User
Jan 31, 2019
1,204
1,200
The O Line has been too good for none of them to be in the top 5 best offensive players for the Bills.

I'd put Dawkins #2, TBH.
Yeh I was more focusing on players that get the ball in their hands. I would put Dawkins somewhere in there as well if I was choosing O-line
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad