My favorite sports games:
- MVP 2005 - the gold standard for any baseball game
- NHL 96 (SNES era) - presentation was great
- NHL 2004 (PS2 era) - I don't think it was the best of that generation, and if anything it was antiquated by the time it came out, but it was the one I owned and put hours upon hours into
- FIFA 07 (PS2) - I'm not a passionate soccer follower beyond the world cup, but there's just something about FIFA games that are relaxing and hypnotic. Plus with practically every league in the world to jump around in career mode to, there's a lot of replayability.
- NFL2K2 - Not as revered as 2K5, but the features in that game were way beyond Madden for 2001 (Madden always had the better presentation though). My favorite thing was how it had realistic weather accumulation so if you had a snow game and just left the select play menu open on a kickoff for like 30 minutes the snow would pile up all over the field.
- NBA Jam Tournament Edition - Not a realistic simulation but great times were playing that game as an 8 year old. Too bad the Celtics sucked.
And if wrestling games count, WWF Wrestlemania 2000 and WCW/nWo Revenge for the N64 are the gold standards to me (I liked Wrestlemania 2000 better than No Mercy, that's my hot take)