They have 2 pairings that work:
Hamhuis - Garrison
Edler - Tanev
just figure out the 3rd. Might involve actually playing Ballard though so not sure if AV will buy that.
Based on their play earlier this season, I don't think HamJuice is going to work. They're both struggling for their own reasons, reuniting them won't fix that. Garrison is the best thing for Hamhuis right now as at least he can cover for his mistakes.
I think at this point, those aren't the 2 pairings that 'work' necessarily, and it doesn't leave anything that works for the 3rd pairing that way.
Hamhuis-Bieksa was a great shutdown tandem, and both guys look lost without each other for the most part. It clearly looks like a 'greater than the sum of their parts' type situation with HamJuice.
And we know that Ballard-Tanev is capable of really mopping up with reasonable minutes.
We also know that Edler and Garrison are paid to be top-4 blueliners. If they can't do that...Then we've got a real problem, and Gillis has created a bit of an ugly mix with big, long-term NTC contracts that don't mesh together.
So put HamJuice back together (despite Bieksa not earning it...he didn't earn it the first time around either, nor has he earned the promotion to playing with Edler. the idea of merit isn't playing into this anymore). Together they've shown in the past that they can play like a $9M pairing.
And cram Edler and Garrison together. Sooner or later, we need to find out if that pairing is going to work. Because if it doesn't...we're stuck for the next 5 years with a $5M and a $4.6M blueliner duo who can't play together, guaranteeing that we'll be spending half a decade with a minimum of $4.6M locked up in one bottom-pairing defender. Garrison appears to be adjusting well enough to the right side, so let them get together and see if they can find any shred of chemistry, with Garrison as the proposed 'steadying influence' that Edler clearly needs. If he can't pull it off...he's not half the 'rock solid shutdown machine' some people are making him out to be. And if he can? Our defence looks great top to bottom and doesn't have to be in a state of constant flux.
Hamhuis-Bieksa
Edler-Garrison
Ballard-Tanev