For this roster? I'd take Perron without thinking twice.
Chippy veteran who's great down low and on the cycle, has Stanley Cup pedigree and can still contribute 40-50 points in a secondary role while providing stability and leadership in the room for an immature and inexperienced core that badly needs it.
And as someone else said, Amadio is the Joseph replacement, much moreso than Perron.
The crux of it, though, is that this roster was very poorly contructed. And the results speak for themselves.
But after the last couple of weeks, we have much more balance and flexibility to move forward.
Even if, when looked at in a vacuum, some of the trades may not have returned as much "value" as fans wanted.