Proposal: Two Unrelated Threads Merged - Please Close

[Lightsol]

How about neither? I don't think either of them move the needle enough relative to the price you'd have to pay.

 

[Man Bear Pig]

It entirely depends what the truth is of why he ultimately left.

- some say we were outbid
- some say he didn’t like the media scrutiny
- some say he disagreed with how the team was coached vs Florida.

if it’s the 2nd, then he likely wouldn’t want to come back. If it’s the other two, neither would be a roadblock anymore.

I recall hearing on the radio that the room(culture) rubbed him the wrong. Given it's the same core, I don't see how he'd feel any different.

 

[Donnie740]

Such as who? Where is the list of 2m top 4 20 year olds teams are going to send our way?

A 35 year old stay at home d who only two years ago (just as slow then as he apparently is now) paired with Rielly to form one of the best pairings in the playoffs is not a flipping video game trade. Having that as your second pair? The Leafs didn't have a Tanev two years ago. That top four is solid come playoffs. Just need a reliable.partner for OEL now.

Mario Ferraro is light years better than Luke Schenn. He’s also NINE (9) years younger and only $500k more expensive. And he can handle huge minutes.

The sentimental love for Schenn because he was chirping Tanner Jeannot during a stoppage in play two years ago is laughably delusional.

Schenn is completely washed. Pairing him with Rielly is a mind-numbingly bad idea - - unless you only want Rielly playing 15 minutes a game. Because that’s all Schenn can handle at this point in his career. Players never get old in video game hockey, but unfortunately that’s not how it is in real life.

 

[Puckstuff]

Get both.

Minten + 1st + Kampf for Brayden at 4.5 m (**pay the premium to get the massive 8 m in cap hit savings over 4 years)
3rd round pick for Luke Schenn at 50 %

Knies - Matthews - Domi
Patches - Tavares - Nylander
McMann - Schenn - Marner
Lorentz - Holmberg - Grebenkin/Dewar/Reaves

OEL - Tanev
Rielly - Schenn
Benoit - McCabe

Stolarz
Woll

 

[Evilhomer]

Mario Ferraro is light years better than Luke Schenn. He’s also NINE (9) years younger and only $500k more expensive. And he can handle huge minutes.

The sentimental love for Schenn because he was chirping Tanner Jeannot during a stoppage in play two years ago is laughably delusional.

Schenn is completely washed. Pairing him with Rielly is a mind-numbingly bad idea - - unless you only want Rielly playing 15 minutes a game. Because that’s all Schenn can handle at this point in his career. Players never get old in video game hockey, but unfortunately that’s not how it is in real life.

I'm not sure how anyone can disagree with this. The Leafs should be targetting someone better than Luke Schenn, and I suspect they are.

 

[hullsy47]

Who will be the first Schenn brother to be traded to Toronto?

schennbros.com

This is the problem .every year for the past like 10,the leafs let their plans public so they can be bent over
Wait till 255 pm fri make your offer and get on with it
Unless schenn is taking tavaras spot ill pass
Obviously its a salary dump for the blues
Make em sweat

 

[ACC1224]

This is the problem .every year for the past like 10,the leafs let their plans public so they can be bent over
Wait till 255 pm fri make your offer and get on with it
Unless schenn is taking tavaras spot ill pass
Obviously its a salary dump for the blues
Make em sweat

Once you target the player you want you make a move. Waiting until the last minute more than likely will leave you with scraps or nothing.

 

[hullsy47]

Once you target the player you want you make a move. Waiting until the last minute more than likely will leave you with scraps or nothing.

I dont want him ,florida put vegas on notice grabbing seth jones
For a 1st and a goalie not much better than hildeby
Ive got no cinfidence in treliving

 

[Americanadian]

The thread I created asking “would you take Brayden Schenn’s contract for free?” was merged with an unrelated thread. The poll ended at 25 “Yes”, 24 “No” last I checked. It would have been a good time capsule as we watch Brayden Schenn’s contract age but unfortunately the poll disappeared when someone merged the thread.

 

[Budz]

Just over 24 hours later and it’s basically an even split. 49% of voters would not take on Brayden Schenn’s contract for free.

We’re in for a fun week.

Just shows how stupid our fanbase truly is.

I don’t think Brayden is a great fit

Expand on the why here…

 

[Ianturnedbull]

Spector's Hockey Rumors

"SPORTSNET: Elliotte Friedman reports the Toronto Maple Leafs have a list of centers they’re looking at in the trade market. One player they’re considering is Brayden Schenn of the St. Louis Blues, but they’re not the only club interested in the 33-year-old center. Friedman suggested the Vegas Golden Knights could also be looking at him."

So Treliving sucks and has no imagination in trying to acquire B. Schenn, but VGK can do no wrong?

 

[Leafs87]

Just shows how stupid our fanbase truly is.


Expand on the why here…

His age, his caphit, and he’s declined from the sparkplug people are imagining we’re getting