HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread: From Here to Free Agency

[CristianoRonaldo]

f*** Chicago if Buffalo gets Knies with the 4OA

It's the most obvious trade ever, we know it's happening, stay tuned...

 

[CristianoRonaldo]

Gooooooood

If we can't even get EP, we are cooked.

 

[WeThreeKings]

Imagine Rage Baiting yourself over Dave Pagnotta.

 

[JoelWarlord]

Carlo would be a good depth upgrade. Something like

Hutson-Dobson
Matheson-Carlo
Guhle-Carrier

Would be a pretty good reg season rotation

 

[WeThreeKings]

If we can't even get EP, we are cooked.

I know. How are we going to be able to compete with the Sabres losing Byram, Greenway and Tuch or the Lightning losing Raddysh.

 

[scrubadam]

Don't mind Carlo as a cheap pickup
don't want DeBrusk don't like the contract.
But KH is probably setting himself to go dumpster diving after waiting so long to make a move.

 

[WeThreeKings]

Don't mind Carlo as a cheap pickup
don't want DeBrusk don't like the contract.
But KH is probably setting himself to go dumpster diving after waiting so long to make a move.

It's not even draft day lmfao.

 

[Vachon23]

I like Carlo. He’d be a decent pick up. Not every add needs to be a star, and he’s more reliable than Arber-Struble

I like Boston Carlo

Not sure he’s the same now

 

[Andy]

I like Boston Carlo

Not sure he’s the same now

Toronto has been a shit storm. The environment is so much better in Montreal

 

[Leto]

I like Boston Carlo

Not sure he’s the same now

He's not. He was a disaster at the end of his tenure in Boston and he was a disaster in Toronto.

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

Can we get a Sammy Blais extension at least ?

 

[MSLs Parabols]

How do we feel about Brandon Carlo?

6'5, 228lbs, good for just under 20 minutes a game, shoots right and plays a ton on the PK/has a defense-first style.

I feel like he would complement our D pretty nicely.

Not the sexiest pick but definitely improves our D.

 

[Galaxydoggystyle]

How do we feel about Brandon Carlo?

6'5, 228lbs, good for just under 20 minutes a game, shoots right and plays a ton on the PK/has a defense-first style.

I feel like he would complement our D pretty nicely.

Not the sexiest pick but definitely improves our D.

 

[jellybeans]

If Knies can be had with the 4th overall and Chicago traded it for Byram they are stupid. They have good young dmen just grab a UFA vet to help them.

Oh chicago is stupid the Byram trade is horrible

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

How do we feel about Brandon Carlo?

6'5, 228lbs, good for just under 20 minutes a game, shoots right and plays a ton on the PK/has a defense-first style.

I feel like he would complement our D pretty nicely.

Not the sexiest pick but definitely improves our D.

I'm pretty sure he was hurt most of last year and his play suffered.

However, the biggest draw back for him is that hes f***ing soft and doesnt go after anyone, at least as a member of the leafs.

 

[BigDaddyLurch]

Carlo would be a good depth upgrade. Something like

Hutson-Dobson
Matheson-Carlo
Guhle-Carrier

Would be a pretty good reg season rotation

He's not. He was a disaster at the end of his tenure in Boston and he was a disaster in Toronto.

How do we feel about Brandon Carlo?

6'5, 228lbs, good for just under 20 minutes a game, shoots right and plays a ton on the PK/has a defense-first style.

I feel like he would complement our D pretty nicely.

Not the sexiest pick but definitely improves our D.

...the issue with Carlo, imo, is that he's basically a 3rd Pairing guy now...he'd be an upgrade on Carrier and on the PK, but not much else; put him in the Top 4 with heavier minutes and he gets steamrolled...

 

[Skip Bayless]

How do we feel about Brandon Carlo?

6'5, 228lbs, good for just under 20 minutes a game, shoots right and plays a ton on the PK/has a defense-first style.

I feel like he would complement our D pretty nicely.

Not the sexiest pick but definitely improves our D.

He'd be fine with Matheson on the second pairing and 1st PK duties with Guhle.

 

[HFFO]

Why Hughes don't try like 2022?

CHI wanted a top 15 pick for Dach, he traded Romanov for a 13 and trade that for Dach.

Now TOR want a top 10 pick for Knies, trade Guhle and 28 for 8-10.

Trade Hage and 8-10 for Knies.

That's it, that's all.

Maybe he has and they said no...? I'm sure he's been doing his job lol.

 

[scrubadam]

How do we feel about Brandon Carlo?

6'5, 228lbs, good for just under 20 minutes a game, shoots right and plays a ton on the PK/has a defense-first style.

I feel like he would complement our D pretty nicely.

Not the sexiest pick but definitely improves our D.

2 year at 4.1 as well.
I would take him over Struble, keep X as 7th D with Bach/Engstrom getting a chance as 8D and line up time due to injuries and what not.
I think its a realistic move for a slight upgrade on D.
Leaves some money to make a move up front.
But fans won't like it because its not sexy and he is a former leaf and bruin.

 

[MSLs Parabols]

I'm pretty sure he was hurt most of last year and his play suffered.

However, the biggest draw back for him is that hes f***ing soft and doesnt go after anyone, at least as a member of the leafs.

His hit totals is not so bad historically. Last year was an outlier which suggests me he played banged up.

What makes him so attractive to me is his 1 year of contract remaining at a mere 4M.

 

[Apoplectic Habs Fan]

Carlo for as much hate as he gets hate here was one of like 2 Leafs that was a plus player

 

[MarkJ]

I only accept Carlo if Knies is in the deal.

 

[Galaxydoggystyle]

Carlo for as much hate as he gets hate here was one of like 2 Leafs that was a plus player

oh now plus minus is a stat we go by

 

[Apoplectic Habs Fan]

oh now plus minus is a stat we go by

Well its not a lot but on a tire fire like the Leafs, he did something right

Silly roll eyes shows level here these days in the panic of FOMO

 

[Leto]

...the issue with Carlo, imo, is that he's basically a 3rd Pairing guy now...he'd be an upgrade on Carrier and on the PK, but not much else; put him in the Top 4 with heavier minutes and he gets steamrolled...

I do agree on the top 4 comment. I'd also add : people should not be fooled by the 6'5 228lbs package, he's not using it and he's shockingly soft due to a documented history of injuries and concussions.