HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #88: 2024-25 Season

Runner77

**********************************************
Sponsor
Jun 24, 2012
85,561
157,197
People in New York this weekend told me they'd never seen Jeff Gorton so angry." - Elliotte Friedman


Does this spark trade talks or what??
I believe he was angry about the refereeing. Maybe losing to the team that dumped him, also played a part. Not gonna change anything going forward, IMHO — Hughes keeps beating the same drum about staying the course.
 

salbutera

Registered User
Sep 10, 2019
15,358
17,162
Did I hear correctly on BPM from Laraque? Said that Friedman said Zegras to MTL is close? Not sure if I heard that properly lol
Georges got that from some guy who heard from some other guy who said he saw Friedman “in a restaurant”… turns out it was Nick Offerman …. oh well

1733164343687.jpeg
 

1909

Registered User
Jul 6, 2016
21,341
11,855
Newhook OR Dach for Zegras would make sense…. But would it made Habs better ?

And if Anaheim is willing, they can also trade Luneau (RD) Or Warren (RD) OR Gaucher(big center) for Barron + Dvorak or Armia ???
 
Last edited:

vokiel

#DanzeMolsonMix
Jan 31, 2007
18,820
4,366
Montréal
Newhook OR Dach for Zegras would make sense…. But would it made Habs better ?

And if Anaheim is willing, they can also trade Luneau (RD) Or Warren (RD) OR Gaucher(big center) for Barron + Dvorak or Armia ???
I don't think I care if it makes Habs better :laugh:

I'd trade something for Klim Kostin atm, and that would probably make us better, but do we care?
 

sheed36

Registered User
Jan 8, 2005
47,746
36,512
No Man's Land
Friedman on 32 Thoughts that the belief was that Waddell didn't want to trade Jiricek in the Eastern Conference.


I've never quite understood this logic from NHL GM's about not wanting to trade a player to a team within the same division or conference as your team.

So you're potentially taking a lesser player or package back in return for your player because you don't want to play against your former player 3 or 4 times per season vs playing him twice by trading him to the other conference. Unless I'm missing something that's the only reason I could really see for not wanting to trade within your own division or conference.

GM's would help their team much more by taking back the best return possible regardless of what division or conference you traded your player to and if that deal is with a team in your division or conference then so be it.

Maybe in this case though the Wild did have the best offer on the table for Jiricek but who really knows but you're not really helping yourself by eliminating half of the NHL teams when trying to make a deal either.
 

Sterling Archer

Registered User
Sep 26, 2006
23,376
14,153
I've never quite understood this logic from NHL GM's about not wanting to trade a player to a team within the same division or conference as your team.

So you're potentially taking a lesser player or package back in return for your player because you don't want to play against your former player 3 or 4 times per season vs playing him twice by trading him to the other conference. Unless I'm missing something that's the only reason I could really see for not wanting to trade within your own division or conference.

GM's would help their team much more by taking back the best return possible regardless of what division or conference you traded your player to and if that deal is with a team in your division or conference then so be it.

Maybe in this case though the Wild did have the best offer on the table for Jiricek but who really knows but you're not really helping yourself by eliminating half of the NHL teams when trying to make a deal either.
I can see when all things being equal, you'd rather not face that player multiple times a year when he wants nothing more then to scorch his former club, particularly against a fierce rival, think Habs, Leafs, Bruins, Sens.

If the offer is significantly better than anything out there from the rival team, and I think I'm getting the best deal and "winning" the trade, or it's fairly insignificant assets being traded, then I'd have no problem with it.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad