tarheelhockey
Offside Review Specialist
Hainsworth 4 times led the NHL in wins, twice won the cup, 8 times was top 2 in wins.
Lu? Never was a 1st team all star, never won the cup, once in 19 years led the league in wins.
Hainsworth was inducted well before Clint Benedict and Frank Brimsek. Maybe we should read some history to find out why!
Revisionist stats-crunching re-ranking may be 21st century cool, but it seems historically hollow.
Stats aside, I've spent enough time working with primary sources from the 20s and 30s to notice a lack of special regard for Hainsworth. Even back then, people were able to make the common-sense distinction between leading the league in Ws and being the best goalie in the league. He's a lot closer to a Luongo than a Price.
Of the goalies you mentioned -- yes, Thompson and Worters and Lehman belong in this conversation. I would need to be convinced I've missed something major before I put Hainsworth in that category.