Le Barron de HF
Justin make me proud
Rules:
There are no rules, choose by your own standards (longevity, peak, both).
There are no rules, choose by your own standards (longevity, peak, both).
Rules:
There are no rules, choose by your own standards (longevity, peak, both).
I've already made a list of players made. I put 5 for this one since I think these guys are a tier above everyone else.I had to choose Max, 'cause of his 2x30 goals seasons in the last 3. Who knows how many he would have scores if there wasn't a lockout 2 years ago. That 33 goals season in which he came back from an injury is what truly made me choose him over Koivu and Kovalev.
Koivu would be my #2 and Kovy might be my #3
Add Ribeiro, Ryder, Cole, Gionta, Zednik for the next polls?
I dont have Cammy on my top5. Zednik ahead of him at the very least.
Pacioretty is probably the best goal-scorer of the bunch, but I'm not sure if he is the best forward. There is a lot I want to see improved in Max's game before I would give him that honor.
That's debatable in my opinion, Zednik at his best was Cammy at his worse. Cammalleri was on pace for 30+ goals in his first season here and it's not like he was given the most minutes offensively. Plek & Gomez were splitting duties. His playoff performances put him above Zednik in my books.
Zednik barely missed any games with Montreal and his best season is equivalent to Cammalleri's worse in terms of points. Zednik played four full seasons with Montreal, Cammalleri almost played three. Zednik might have played in a period where it was harder to score but Cammalleri played under Jacques Martin and his defensive system. Also Zednik saw more PP time in his time here than Cammy did.Zednik wasn't as soft, and if you factor Cammy's injuries, you have to factor in Zednik injuries as well. Zednik also played more seasons. Not to mention that points were statistically harder to come by when Zednik had his best seasons. ....
Zednik barely missed any games with Montreal and his best season is equivalent to Cammalleri's worse in terms of points. Zednik played four full seasons with Montreal, Cammalleri almost played three. Zednik might have played in a period where it was harder to score but Cammalleri played under Jacques Martin and his defensive system. Also Zednik saw more PP time in his time here than Cammy did.
I only saw the worst version of Zednik (post-lockout) but I think many will argue that Cammalleri was more memorable in his time than Zednik.
...That's what I figured.
Doesn't change my arguments...
I haven't seen Stephane Richer play, doesn't mean I wouldn't rank him higher than Pacioretty.
That goes straight in line with Cammy before Zedik....
Indeed, Sergei Kostitsyn/Matt D'Agostini/Marcel Hossa/Chris Higgins name it.Saku for me, but it was close between him and kovalev. Koivu gets the edge from me because of how much responsibility he had on the ice. If anyone was struggling or a rookie was having some trouble, they always got put with Saku.
You can make a poll if you want, t.
That would actually measure the ignorance level of this board.