Top 20 Minnesotans in the NHL

[MNRube]

Inspired by the Quebec thread.

Oettinger
Guentzel
Faber
Boeser
B.Nelson
Skjei
C. Lindgren
Middlestadt
McDonagh
K. Miller
R. Lindgren
M.Anderson
Novak
A. Lee
J.Faulk
B.Brink
N.Bjugstad
N.Leddy
W.Borden
N.Perbix

Click to read more...

 

[Coffees]

tier 1
Oettinger
Guentzel
Faber

I’m still going to edit and do the rest, but first let me ask fellow posters, does Boeser belong in tier 1?

 

[MNRube]

tier 1
Oettinger
Guentzel
Faber

I’m still going to edit and do the rest, but first let me ask fellow posters, does Boeser belong in tier 1?

If he’s not Tier 1, he’s all alone in Tier 2.

 

[Coffees]

If he’s not Tier 1, he’s all alone in Tier 2.

Agreed, I mean honestly the dude changed his game and is a good two way winger now , I would not have a problem putting him in tier 1

@LemonSauceD want your opinion as well

 

[stymie]

I vote Prince.

 

[AKL]

does Boeser belong in tier 1?

Given his track record, let's see him do it again first

 

[BKarchitect]

tier 1
Oettinger
Guentzel
Faber

I’m still going to edit and do the rest, but first let me ask fellow posters, does Boeser belong in tier 1?

I don’t think he deserves to be ahead of Brock Nelson or Ryan McDonagh yet. Although as others have mentioned, another season like last year will go a long ways…I feel the same about Skjei on the blueline.

Nelson is super underrated. Such a strong player and great goal scorer as a center for a low-offense operation. I think Mikey Anderson is overlooked too…just a rock solid 20-22 minutes a night every single year.

Mittelstadt has a window here to really open eyes as well as the #2 behind MacKinnon on a powerhouse team. He’s one of those guys who has really turned some of his scouting weaknesses as a younger player into actual strengths through hard work.

 

[LemonSauceD]

Given his track record, let's see him do it again first

179g, 384pts in 479gp. I mean what more of a track record do you need?

 

[Coffees]

179g, 384pts in 479gp. I mean what more of a track record do you need?

Also this , can you briefly describe his current play style as well?


Thanks

I don’t think he deserves to be ahead of Brock Nelson or Ryan McDonagh yet. Although as others have mentioned, another season like last year will go a long ways…I feel the same about Skjei on the blueline.

Nelson is super underrated. Such a strong player and great goal scorer as a center for a low-offense operation. I think Mikey Anderson is overlooked too…just a rock solid 20-22 minutes a night every single year.

Mittelstadt has a window here to really open eyes as well as the #2 behind MacKinnon on a powerhouse team. He’s one of those guys who has really turned some of his scouting weaknesses as a younger player into actual strengths through hard work.

@SI90 asking you because you’re a Islanders fan and also you call things like you see it.

Is Nelson the better player over Boeser ?

 

[LemonSauceD]

Also this , can you briefly describe his current play style as well?


Thanks

Reliable scorer.

 

[KirkAlbuquerque]

Shotty the Top 20 Italian Paisanos in the NHL thread next

 

[Coffees]

Reliable scorer.

Whatever , dude

 

[SI90]

Also this , can you briefly describe his current play style as well?


Thanks


@SI90 asking you because you’re a Islanders fan and also you call things like you see it.

Is Nelson the better player over Boeser ?

I appreciate you asking my opinion. Boeser is younger so just comparing both of their first 7 full seasons they’re actually pretty similar in production. Boeser does have the one 40 goal season which was this passed year and that’s huge. Have to expect he’ll continue to score 30+ plus if healthy.

It all depends what you prefer. Nelson is so consistent and has been an automatic 30+ goal scorer the last few years plus he’s great defensively and is a center.

It all depends on the team and what you prefer. I don’t think it’s crazy to rank Boeser ahead of Nelson if you prefer a winger with an elite shot and scoring ability.

If Boeser goes on to score 35+ goals by the time he’s Nelson’s age then he’s probably a no brainer but right now I think I would choose Nelson if I’m talking 1 season and career thus far to this point.

I’d we’re talking going forward would take Boeser because of his age and scoring ability. While Nelson has scored 30+ and always seems to hit 20+ his whole career he’s getting to the point where he may slow down.

 

[Dr Jan Itor]

Seeing that list, it actually falls off pretty hard.

 

[Bender Duster]

I don’t know much about some of the guys near the bottom of the list but I think Samberg will bump someone off the list by mid season.

 

[Sasha Orlov]

The hell is N Perbix

 

[hamzarocks]

The hell is N Perbix

Nick perbix

Tampa D-man, solid 4/5D from 2017 draft class

 

[hotcabbagesoup]

Where are Zach Parise and Ryan Suter?

Shouldn't it count more that they've came home to Minnesota because they love Minnesota so much.

 

[Ace of Hades]

Given his track record, let's see him do it again first

He has a more accomplished track record than Faber.
---
1. Oettinger
2. Guentzel
3. Boeser

The rest.

 

[JoVel]

Did Faber have any say in the trade that had him shipped to the Wild, or was it just a coincidence for him? It looks like he has played in Minnesota all his life and now continued to do so, even though he was drafted by the Kings.

 

[AKL]

He has a more accomplished track record than Faber.
---
1. Oettinger
2. Guentzel
3. Boeser

The rest.

Faber has very little track record of anything, but 100% of his track record consists of being a more valuable player than Boeser.

Boeser has a longer track record, 85% of it is him not being a tier 1 player.

Did Faber have any say in the trade that had him shipped to the Wild, or was it just a coincidence for him? It looks like he has played in Minnesota all his life and now continued to do so, even though he was drafted by the Kings.

No one knows how much "say" he had in it, but he's from Minnesota, and it's almost certain that his preference was to play for the Wild. Maybe LA thought he might go the NCAA UFA route to sign with Minnesota.

 

[AKL]

Where are Zach Parise

Retired

and Ryan Suter?

Wisconsin

 

[Obvious Fabertism]

Where are Zach Parise and Ryan Suter?

Shouldn't it count more that they've came home to Minnesota because they love Minnesota so much.

Suter is from WI. Parise is retired.

 

[Ace of Hades]

Faber has very little track record of anything, but 100% of his track record consists of being a more valuable player than Boeser.

Boeser has a longer track record, 85% of it is him not being a tier 1 player.

Faber has more value but he sure isn't a better overall player than Boeser at this point in time. Boeser is the more proven player and had to deal with personal issues (father dying) that hampered his career until now.

Faber didn't have the better season either.

 

[Obvious Fabertism]

Faber has more value but he sure isn't a better overall player than Boeser at this point in time. Boeser is the more proven player and had to deal with personal issues (father dying) that hampered his career until now.

Faber didn't have the better season either.

Going to sound crazy, but I am honestly not sure about that, Faber looks incredible at this point in time, he appears to have had a monster summer.