Tony Marinaro on why Subban was really traded | Page 14 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

Tony Marinaro on why Subban was really traded

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm going to go with a combination of immaturity from PK, perhaps not always being aware of the optics of his decisions or some of the things that he said, and a clash of personalities between some of the more quiet, traditional types likes Patches and Pleks (as well as the team's organizational culture) and PK's flashy, confident demeanor.

I'm sure PK was not universally disliked by his teammates. Gallagher and Price (and others who are no longer there, but were his teammates nonetheless) seemed to like him plenty.

I think that PK comes off as arrogant at times but is actually a reasonably humble guy. His ability to play the way he does is probably predicated on being headstrong and confident and fueled by instinct and emotion. That can lead to some scraps and some inflammatory remarks. I would wager he usually doesn't realize that he's said or done something abrasive until after the fact, if at all. I think he's probably a good natured and genuine person who wishes to be liked by all, but sometimes rubs people the wrong way. I think some of it is immaturity. Some of it may be willful ignorance combined with ego. Ego isn't necessarily a bad thing; athletes all have egos to some degree and need to be confident to perform well. We see it all the time when players who should be scoring start "gripping the stick too tight" and second guessing themselves because they're on a cold streak.

PK hopefully learns from this, but I also would hope it doesn't change him too much. He is a great personality and ambassador for the sport. He needs to remain the exuberant, bright personality that he is but learn to be more aware of the optics of his actions.
 
Last edited:
All of this could be perfectly true without any slant, generalizations or obscurities due to time and it still doesn't seem to be all that compelling of a case against Subban.

I didn't realize that we expected hockey players to be pure and perfect robots that never express real emotions, even when the cameras are off. If you want personality, well this is it. Embrace all of it or don't ask for any of it.
 
Last edited:
The idea that Subbans personality is a problem falls apart when you take a quick glance at other professional sports leagues (basketball, soccer, football) and all of leagues associated with those sports are FILLED with guys that have incredibly strong personalities yet teams there seem to make it work just fine.

Something is very rotten in the Habs organization and Subban is very, very lucky to be ready to a team that will appreciate him.
 
Donates 10 million to a children's hospital, but is apparently selfish.

:laugh::handclap:

Oh please. You actually believe he donated that because he's a nice guy or something? He did it because he thought it would make him look good and because he wanted the love and attention.
 
Oh please. You actually believe he donated that because he's a nice guy or something? He did it because he thought it would make him look good and because he wanted the love and attention.

Sure, because only the self-absorbed or the altruistic donate to charities. Even if it was purely for the attention, what the hell is the problem with that?
 
To me this sounds like the standard character assassination agenda that follows after a star gets traded. Boston does it too. I'll bet two cents that PK will be loved by the fans, the community and the teammates in Nashville, just like Seguin in Dallas.

Exactly. All this "inside info" is nothing new that hasn't be regurgitated before in some manner or fashion. We all knew that every one on the team didn't see eye to eye with Subban, but then again, he was still close with many players on the team. Was he pissed he didn't get the C? Maybe, but don't tell me Pacioretty is this team's leader.

This is all such a crock of s***. We're a classy organization? When was the last time class won us anything or got us a to sign a player? Was it classy how we dealt with Cammalleri, or that our GM and coach continue to lie to through their teeth about our players and our team? Is it classy how our coach and GM play favorites or the way our rookies/prospects are being (mis)handled?

And this line pisses me off:

"PK supposedly said something to the effect of "he'll win the Norris, i mean look who he plays with, look who i play with". ******"

He supposedly said something to the effect of? So he may or may not have said something that was or wasn't insulting to the team? God damn, is Marinaro just spewing pure garbage at this point? What kind of journalism is this?

Agree with these posts. And this will the longer it went since the trade be taken as truths, when it´s pure speculation. Some in this thread are already swallowing it whole.

And for starters, that people even try to belittle an 10 million donation to a children hospital. Of course most people have an agenda with an donation. Be it they would like to feel good for 10 minutes, impress someone, move up in society, and so on... No donation ever is completley selfish. But it´s still a *****ing great thing done! Trying to twist it bad is just silly.

But the things that stands out is trying to turn everything he´s done in to something bad. As an former player in different sports who´s been an part of both great and bad locker rooms 20+ years of my adult years: most of those points could actually as easy be turned to things I´d value in an teammate. Especially if I´m set on winning. Some of the greatest teams I´ve been a part of has had an mix of the kind of mind set Subban has. Not one great team has had the "we´re all friends" mind set.

I mean, the "it´s not my job to score goals" was an answer after an frustrating loss where Subban had his first goal in 34 games. To me an player being upset when loosing, even if he´s scored an goal, is something I´d value if I´d want to win something. He said "I couldn’t give a s— about my f—ing first goal in however long. It doesn’t f—ing matter. I’m not a goal-scorer. It’s not my job to score goals.”. More reminds me of, even if a little clumpsy formulated, one of my favourite storys about young Forsberg. Where he came home from an 7-8 loss with MoDo as an little boy about 8-10 years old. He was crying when he said to his mom he lost. His mom asked if he scored any goals. He answered 7. That´s winning mentality if anything. Kudos for Subban not being satisfied with scoring an goal in an loss.
The next day he said this:
"As a group it's our job to create offence." he said. "I couldn't care less if I score the goal or if I set it up. It doesn't matter to me.
"People are going to look at numbers and stats and I expect that. When you're the highest paid player on the team and one of the highest paid players in the league people are going to do that. That's fine with me. But it's important for people to know that all I care about is winning."

Love it! Sign me up for having him as an leader on my team any day of the week.

And the i didnt think we did enough as an organization to make the playoffs without Price etc... but we have to be better from the TOP OF THE ORGANIZATION TO THE BOTTOM
That´s what I´d want to hear when you placed 22 in the leauge and didn´t make the PO:s. Doesn´t mather if I´m a fan, teammate or GM of the team! Players that ain´t satisified with not winning is the kind of teammates I´d surround me with.

And the: PK Subban was the only person who didn't attend the Habs's Christmas party, now i don't know where PK was... . What the *****. Getting team chemistry threw bonding is great. But if it´s not mandatory or someone has an good excuse (even if only I´d like to spend time with my family, I´ve missed them...) I wouldn´t care a bit.

To me these Subban stories reminds me of some of the greatest team mates I´ve had. Many of them are persons I will never hang out with or even give a call for the rest of my life, because we didn´t match with personal chemistry. But that´s not what building a great team is about. A little bit of fighting, some harsh words in the heat of the moment even in training is also an way of sending an signal that you take every minute serious.

And the "it was an individual mistake that cost us the game" makes Therrien look as Tremblay 21 years ago. Subban, who at the time led the Canadiens in scoring and is your biggest offensive driving force, tried an risky move when you where down 1 goal 5 minutes in to the 3rd period. Trying to recover he blew a tire. Montreal was already loosing that game. Give Subban credit for trying if anything. That´s the way to handle an risk/reward player.

To me this screams Roy pt.2 for Montreal. Letting an coach/some of the players that can´t handle an big ego win the battle in the locker room. Egos are great if you wanna win. Egos ain´t satisfied with anything but wnining. All great teams, dynastys and so have had this kind of "problem players". It´s when an coach/team/GM/team mates can´t handle them it goes bad.

Weber is an great defenceman. He´ll probably be top 10 for 5 more years at least and an great no2 until his contracts up if he wants to. Montreal will be an more stabil team next season and probably get the great RS record, even if Price ain´t healthy. And Subban has the playing style at the moment that won´t age as good as Webers, so maybe they will retire at the same team despite the 4 years age different. But Subban is the kind of risk/reward player that reminds me of just Roy. Even if maybe some of the young ones here won´t remember Roys bad years/series and just how much he was villified in Montreal, especially early 90´s before the 1993 Cup.
Before next season I´m placing an bet on Subban winning the Norris and I´m gonna add Nashville to the 3-4 teams I´ll place an SC bet on.

I´m not an Montreal fan. And I´m not an Nashville fan. And I´m not an Subban fan boy. But this is crap. And as said. It screams Roy pt.2 Tought Montreal had evolved past the "old boys club" and learned from where that put them 20 years ago when they dealt an ego that supposedley was bigger than the team instead of the coach that couldn´t handle him...
 
Last edited:
That's a lot of reaching propoganda, and if anything it makes me think even less about the habs than of pk if they're really that thin skinned
 
More smoke:
Brian Wilde mentions that of PK's close circle that he always hung out with 3 of 4 of them are gone. #4 is Price who obviously they would never get rid of.

Oh BTW Brian Wilde loves PK Subban and hates Michel Therrien from the sounds of the interview. So NO reason for him to make up bull **** about a rift in the locker-room.

A rift between two players doesn't mean the one who was traded was a locker room cancer...
 
Oh please. You actually believe he donated that because he's a nice guy or something? He did it because he thought it would make him look good and because he wanted the love and attention.

You don't donate 10 Million Dollars just to look good. You can get that a lot cheaper.
10 Million is a lot, even for Subban, and everyone should appreciate that
 
You don't donate 10 Million Dollars just to look good. You can get that a lot cheaper.
10 Million is a lot, even for Subban, and everyone should appreciate that

The person to whom you are replying thinks Subban is scum. There really isn't much to say to a person with such a pointed opinion to change their mind. Oddly enough, those kinds of extreme opinions often take very little to begin to manifest, but would take something major to change.

To me, scum would be someone who tries to take away $10m from a children's hospital, maybe even someone who has the ability to give but would rather keep their money (though someone not wanting to donate their money to charity isn't necessarily scum because of it, but, to me, there is a greater chance that they are if they are that greedy), not someone who gives. Even if they only do it for media attention, or so they can file it with their taxes. At least they did something helpful for their own benefit so it wasn't 100% selfish.
 
I honestly think the Subban trade was abuse of power. They don't like him for whatever reason - they have the power to get rid of him and they did. Unless he is hated by the entire team, I don't see any acceptable reason to trade him, I really don't. Mike Richards and Jeff Carter needed to bring in a drinking/partying lifestyle and attitude into the locker room to get booted - Subban shouldn't be anywhere close to that.
 
Donations do not come from character's own pocket, he raised 10M... That's a great donation but do not think he paid it himself...

Ok. So let's say he raises the $10m without even donating any of his own money.

Where should I begin to criticize him for such an effort?
 
Last edited:
No reason to criticize that. As I wrote it is a great donation and PK did great job raising that money. But he didn't give that money, there's a difference. Who does that anyway, Bill Gates?
 
Oh, that ***** donated his 2 annual salaries to charity just to make him look good.
Okay. Please tell me who of you donated even 2 months and not 2 years salaries to any cause in your life.
 
What's really funny is if you go to my workplace you can create a similar list just as easily. Throw in a couple of comments made by me, maybe a couple of the guys who I never got along with can chime in. My boss can say I was late a few times.

The one that cracked up me up was the Christmas party. If PK wants to go home and celebrate Christmas or just wants to be on his own, that is fully his right.

I love how the smear campaign gets right to work when a team trades a big star. It happened to Seguin, Kessel and now Subban.

Edit: Fought about Kesler in Vancouver.
 
Oh please. You actually believe he donated that because he's a nice guy or something? He did it because he thought it would make him look good and because he wanted the love and attention.

This post is cringe worthy. Hypothetically if Subban raised 10M for your sick family member, I'm sure you wouldn't thank him and appreciate the effort because you believed he just wanted love and attention.

The garbage people spew out of their mouths about someone they don't even know and will never meet in their lives.. Just baffling.
 
Donations do not come from character's own pocket, he raised 10M... That's a great donation but do not think he paid it himself...

Who cares. He raised money for kids who need the care. Without Subban, they have 10M less dollars and potentially less living children. It doesn't matter if he didn't pay for the entirety of the funds - I can't believe people are bringing up generous charity work somehow as a negative in this PK witch hunt.
 
All of this sounds like the hearsay that came out of the Boston camp when they traded Sequin on that fateful fourth of July.
 
Agree with these posts. And this will the longer it went since the trade be taken as truths, when it´s pure speculation. Some in this thread are already swallowing it whole.

And for starters, that people even try to belittle an 10 million donation to a children hospital. Of course most people have an agenda with an donation. Be it they would like to feel good for 10 minutes, impress someone, move up in society, and so on... No donation ever is completley selfish. But it´s still a *****ing great thing done! Trying to twist it bad is just silly.

But the things that stands out is trying to turn everything he´s done in to something bad. As an former player in different sports who´s been an part of both great and bad locker rooms 20+ years of my adult years: most of those points could actually as easy be turned to things I´d value in an teammate. Especially if I´m set on winning. Some of the greatest teams I´ve been a part of has had an mix of the kind of mind set Subban has. Not one great team has had the "we´re all friends" mind set.

I mean, the "it´s not my job to score goals" was an answer after an frustrating loss where Subban had his first goal in 34 games. To me an player being upset when loosing, even if he´s scored an goal, is something I´d value if I´d want to win something. He said "I couldn’t give a s— about my f—ing first goal in however long. It doesn’t f—ing matter. I’m not a goal-scorer. It’s not my job to score goals.â€. More reminds me of, even if a little clumpsy formulated, one of my favourite storys about young Forsberg. Where he came home from an 7-8 loss with MoDo as an little boy about 8-10 years old. He was crying when he said to his mom he lost. His mom asked if he scored any goals. He answered 7. That´s winning mentality if anything. Kudos for Subban not being satisfied with scoring an goal in an loss.
The next day he said this:
"As a group it's our job to create offence." he said. "I couldn't care less if I score the goal or if I set it up. It doesn't matter to me.
"People are going to look at numbers and stats and I expect that. When you're the highest paid player on the team and one of the highest paid players in the league people are going to do that. That's fine with me. But it's important for people to know that all I care about is winning."

Love it! Sign me up for having him as an leader on my team any day of the week.

And the i didnt think we did enough as an organization to make the playoffs without Price etc... but we have to be better from the TOP OF THE ORGANIZATION TO THE BOTTOM
That´s what I´d want to hear when you placed 22 in the leauge and didn´t make the PO:s. Doesn´t mather if I´m a fan, teammate or GM of the team! Players that ain´t satisified with not winning is the kind of teammates I´d surround me with.

And the: PK Subban was the only person who didn't attend the Habs's Christmas party, now i don't know where PK was... . What the *****. Getting team chemistry threw bonding is great. But if it´s not mandatory or someone has an good excuse (even if only I´d like to spend time with my family, I´ve missed them...) I wouldn´t care a bit.

To me these Subban stories reminds me of some of the greatest team mates I´ve had. Many of them are persons I will never hang out with or even give a call for the rest of my life, because we didn´t match with personal chemistry. But that´s not what building a great team is about. A little bit of fighting, some harsh words in the heat of the moment even in training is also an way of sending an signal that you take every minute serious.

And the "it was an individual mistake that cost us the game" makes Therrien look as Tremblay 21 years ago. Subban, who at the time led the Canadiens in scoring and is your biggest offensive driving force, tried an risky move when you where down 1 goal 5 minutes in to the 3rd period. Trying to recover he blew a tire. Montreal was already loosing that game. Give Subban credit for trying if anything. That´s the way to handle an risk/reward player.

To me this screams Roy pt.2 for Montreal. Letting an coach/some of the players that can´t handle an big ego win the battle in the locker room. Egos are great if you wanna win. Egos ain´t satisfied with anything but wnining. All great teams, dynastys and so have had this kind of "problem players". It´s when an coach/team/GM/team mates can´t handle them it goes bad.

Weber is an great defenceman. He´ll probably be top 10 for 5 more years at least and an great no2 until his contracts up if he wants to. Montreal will be an more stabil team next season and probably get the great RS record, even if Price ain´t healthy. And Subban has the playing style at the moment that won´t age as good as Webers, so maybe they will retire at the same team despite the 4 years age different. But Subban is the kind of risk/reward player that reminds me of just Roy. Even if maybe some of the young ones here won´t remember Roys bad years/series and just how much he was villified in Montreal, especially early 90´s before the 1993 Cup.
Before next season I´m placing an bet on Subban winning the Norris and I´m gonna add Nashville to the 3-4 teams I´ll place an SC bet on.

I´m not an Montreal fan. And I´m not an Nashville fan. And I´m not an Subban fan boy. But this is crap. And as said. It screams Roy pt.2 Tought Montreal had evolved past the "old boys club" and learned from where that put them 20 years ago when they dealt an ego that supposedley was bigger than the team instead of the coach that couldn´t handle him...

This is a great post. Spot on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad