For sure, but the reality is that we will qualify him this offseason and drastically limit his options to accomplish that goal. I'll be pretty surprised if we give him a 1 year, 1 way deal. Why pay him $775k+ to play in the AHL and potentially walk him right to UFA? He's probably going to have to choose between locking in $1.5M over 2 years or locking in $85k for 1 year in order to (hopefully) get a 1 way contract and potentially better NHL opportunity in 2026/27.
By the end of this season, he will have made about $570k in his career since signing with the Blues in March of 2021. He's extremely far away from lifetime financial security and isn't too far off from the financial realities of us regular people. He's made a hell of a lot more than I did in my early-to-mid 20s, but he also passed up college and lost out on his QMJHL scholarship to play pro hockey. If his career ended tomorrow, he almost certainly doesn't have more than a few years of savings/investments to last while he starts a new career path. He made $85k this year and that is what he'll make next year if he simply signs a QO to get himself to UFA quicker. Given the short window to earn money in this career, delaying that first real NHL payday by a year is really, really risky.
I get that pro athletes are wired different and often want to bet on themselves. But his agent has a duty to sit him down and explain just how much financial security he'd be giving up to bet on himself if the Blues do in fact bring a 2 year, 1 way deal to the table. $1.5M paid out over 2 years is objectively life-changing money for someone in his position.
What happens to him if he signs a 1 year deal this summer and then doesn't outplay Zherenko in 2025/26? Or he gets hurt? Or he still outplays Zherenko, but "only" with a .910 in the AHL? Sure he would be a UFA in the summer of 2026, but how many teams would come knocking with a 1 way deal or a guaranteed NHL roster spot? Suddenly he would likely be taking a 2 way deal that pays $250k in the AHL with a team that is bringing him to camp to battle with someone else for their NHL #2 job. There are so many realistic paths where 'betting on himself' could cause him to go from making $1.5M to less than $500k over the next 2 years.
He has 40 career AHL games and that number will probably be more like 60 at the end of the year. If you can turn that into 2 years of guaranteed NHL money, I think you just have to take that deal even if it pushes your potential NHL start date back a year. And not for nothing, but he'll require waivers next season so there would be that (very small) chance of getting claimed.