Proposal: - Threeway crazy trade COL-CGY-BUF | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League
Toggle sidebar

Proposal: Threeway crazy trade COL-CGY-BUF

landy

landy

Registered User
Mar 20, 2025
961
1,045
To BUF:
Necas - $6.5 UFA 26-27
Huberdeau - $10.5 UFA 30-31
Rights to Nelson - maybe worthless, maybe sign and trade.
CGY 1st 2025 (Panthers original pick - obv will be bottom 8 at minimum)
CGY 1st 2026 (Knights original pick top 15 protected)

- A lot going on and trying to bring in some value for losing Byram/Peterka potentially, but comes at the expense of Tuch which Im guessing no BUF fans will like, but assuming he wont re-sign there.

To CGY:
Byram: RFA signs 8x$x
Peterka: RFA signs 8x$x
Girard: $5M UFA 27-28
- Gets rid of the old guys and their cap hits and starts the rebuild with young RFA's. Paying to get rid of that Hubby contract with 1sts and Buf is one of the few teams that can absorb it.

To COL:
Kadri: $7M UFA 28-29
Tuch: $4.75 UFA 26-27
-Goes again with the win now mode. Gets their 2C back and basically a swap Necas for Tuch because I cant stand Necas right now. I wanted to go Thompson, but because of his contract he is near untouchable value wise.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: Fatass and Shonky
Value aside. I'd argue that Calgary gets worse in the short term and gives up two firsts that could very well be top 5-10 picks with a move like this.

It's a move that could and likely would backfire tremendously. We struggle to score as is, and this only further compounds the issue.

Just not a move that makes sense.

Edit : I see it's a 2025 1st and as Quatre mentioned we don't have that. I read it as 2026/2027 1st's.
 
Last edited:
No from Colorado
Giving Necas Girard and received only Kadri and tuch

Necas a P/G players
Girard a good 4th and can be a pp top guy in CGY.

received
Kadri (older player and not even a p/g guy most probably a 60 pts
Tuch Can he played a full season without injury
 
landy said:
To BUF:
Necas - $6.5 UFA 26-27
Huberdeau - $10.5 UFA 30-31
Rights to Nelson - maybe worthless, maybe sign and trade.
CGY 1st 2025
CGY 1st 2026

- A lot going on and trying to bring in some value for losing Byram/Peterka potentially, but comes at the expense of Tuch which Im guessing no BUF fans will like, but assuming he wont re-sign there.

To CGY:
Byram: RFA signs 8x$x
Peterka: RFA signs 8x$x
Girard: $5M UFA 27-28
- Gets rid of the old guys and their cap hits and starts the rebuild with young RFA's. Paying to get rid of that Hubby contract with 1sts and Buf is one of the few teams that can absorb it.

To COL:
Kadri: $7M UFA 28-29
Tuch: $4.75 UFA 26-27
-Goes again with the win now mode. Gets their 2C back and basically a swap Necas for Tuch because I cant stand Necas right now. I wanted to go Thompson, but because of his contract he is near untouchable value wise.
Click to expand...
Calgary doesn't have their first this year, Montreal does
 
  • Like
Reactions: TFHockey, CF84, Ragdoll and 1 other person
landy said:
To BUF:
Necas - $6.5 UFA 26-27
Huberdeau - $10.5 UFA 30-31
Rights to Nelson - maybe worthless, maybe sign and trade.
CGY 1st 2025
CGY 1st 2026

- A lot going on and trying to bring in some value for losing Byram/Peterka potentially, but comes at the expense of Tuch which Im guessing no BUF fans will like, but assuming he wont re-sign there.

To CGY:
Byram: RFA signs 8x$x
Peterka: RFA signs 8x$x
Girard: $5M UFA 27-28
- Gets rid of the old guys and their cap hits and starts the rebuild with young RFA's. Paying to get rid of that Hubby contract with 1sts and Buf is one of the few teams that can absorb it.

To COL:
Kadri: $7M UFA 28-29
Tuch: $4.75 UFA 26-27
-Goes again with the win now mode. Gets their 2C back and basically a swap Necas for Tuch because I cant stand Necas right now. I wanted to go Thompson, but because of his contract he is near untouchable value wise.
Click to expand...
CGY doesn't hold their 2025 1st.
Value is horrible for the Avs.
 
Quatre Vingt Treize said:
Calgary doesn't have their first this year, Montreal does
Click to expand...
Right i assume the worst ones.

B.png
 
Aves do fairly in this trade. But they gave up multiple picks and prospects and roster players just to end up back with Kadri.

Aves need a rebuild so they should never do this. But the Kadri wasted assets trade tree needs to get bigger until every team can link it to a cup win.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AslanRH
ForsbergMoDo21 said:
It takes sincere effort to come up with a trade proposal this bad for Buffalo.

Much appreciated.
Click to expand...
So lose Byram, Peterka, and Tuch for peanuts/nothing potentially? Watch both RFA's get offer-sheeted and all you get are more picks.
 
landy said:
To BUF:
Necas - $6.5 UFA 26-27
Huberdeau - $10.5 UFA 30-31
Rights to Nelson - maybe worthless, maybe sign and trade.
CGY 1st 2025
CGY 1st 2026

- A lot going on and trying to bring in some value for losing Byram/Peterka potentially, but comes at the expense of Tuch which Im guessing no BUF fans will like, but assuming he wont re-sign there.

To CGY:
Byram: RFA signs 8x$x
Peterka: RFA signs 8x$x
Girard: $5M UFA 27-28
- Gets rid of the old guys and their cap hits and starts the rebuild with young RFA's. Paying to get rid of that Hubby contract with 1sts and Buf is one of the few teams that can absorb it.

To COL:
Kadri: $7M UFA 28-29
Tuch: $4.75 UFA 26-27
-Goes again with the win now mode. Gets their 2C back and basically a swap Necas for Tuch because I cant stand Necas right now. I wanted to go Thompson, but because of his contract he is near untouchable value wise.
Click to expand...
I’m gonna guess that you are a Calgary fan
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nikolajs Sillers and Ragdoll
Jimmybarndoor2 said:
I’m gonna guess that you are a Calgary fan
Click to expand...
I actually think CGY gets the crap end of this, but gets out of Hubbys deal. Buffalo gets the most but their fans are delusional overvaluing RFA's that want to leave and assuming Tuch will stay. Basically a wash for COL
 
NOTENOUGHRYJOTHINGS said:
Aves do fairly in this trade. But they gave up multiple picks and prospects and roster players just to end up back with Kadri.

Aves need a rebuild so they should never do this. But the Kadri wasted assets trade tree needs to get bigger until every team can link it to a cup win
Click to expand...
They don't need a rebuild but more a retool
 
landy said:
lol they have the same UFA year currently. No guarantee either stays with their current team.
Click to expand...
With Tuch there is at least a chance e (re-)signs with Necas we already know he won't sihn in Buffalo mr. lol
 
Weltschmerz said:
With Tuch there is at least a chance e (re-)signs with Necas we already know he won't sihn in Buffalo mr. lol
Click to expand...
None of that is true and it is easily arguable Necas > Tuch value wise. I wanted Thompson but there really isnt a deal that makes sense for the Sabres to move him. They'd want a 1C which no team would move for him.
 
landy said:
So lose Byram, Peterka, and Tuch for peanuts/nothing potentially? Watch both RFA's get offer-sheeted and all you get are more picks.
Click to expand...

We would love JJ to sign an offersheet... would make life easy.. we would just match.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sabreality
landy said:
I actually think CGY gets the crap end of this, but gets out of Hubbys deal. Buffalo gets the most but their fans are delusional overvaluing RFA's that want to leave and assuming Tuch will stay. Basically a wash for COL
Click to expand...
So a Calgary fan?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)

Latest posts

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom