Ritchie Valens
Registered User
- Sep 24, 2007
- 30,054
- 43,449
I can’t understand either how he has survived all these years. Rumours must be true he’s married into the Katz family.
Post-Game Talk: This team has a problem in net
- Thread starter Spawn
- Start date
-
Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
If the Oilers acquired even James Reimer (which would cost like maybe a 4th round pick), I bet he would eventually take the starter's net away from Skinner.
Dude is making peanuts in Buffalo and no spring chicken, but he honestly is probably still a better goalie than the 2 guys we have here. Pickard is an AHL goalie and Skinner is very marginally better at best if at all with worse athletic ability than Pickard (Picks has faster reflexes and lateral movement).
Dude is making peanuts in Buffalo and no spring chicken, but he honestly is probably still a better goalie than the 2 guys we have here. Pickard is an AHL goalie and Skinner is very marginally better at best if at all with worse athletic ability than Pickard (Picks has faster reflexes and lateral movement).
Ritchie Valens
Registered User
- Sep 24, 2007
- 30,054
- 43,449
He’s too busy whipping his long hair back and forth and bopping to the music to care enough.Has Skinner tried playing net with his eyes open?
Ritchie Valens
Registered User
- Sep 24, 2007
- 30,054
- 43,449
As funny (and true) as this is, the bolded speaks to his lack of concentration during the game.
Messrules11
6 Cups, elbows up.
- Nov 23, 2018
- 6,075
- 7,051
This might be the worst take of about 20 stupid takes you’ve made in this thread.
Change your username, you’re a disgrace.
Missing smitty
Registered User
- Oct 1, 2018
- 1,954
- 2,152
There isn't a chance season ticket holders would be selling their tickets for a Stanley Cup Finals game
That's the only reason they're are so many Leafs fans in the stands the 1 time they come because season ticket holders milk then for every penny.
Fishy McScales
Registered User
I call you out on your pathological need to complain and you jump to the conclusion that I'm "defending management".
How annoyingly expected of you.
Missing smitty
Registered User
- Oct 1, 2018
- 1,954
- 2,152
KeithIsActuallyBad
SPEEN!
Management has yet to deliver this team a championship. Simple as that. Goaltending is a hot topic around these parts but they seem content to let it ride. Firing Dustin Schwartz would be a step in the right direction. The Klingbergs and Kapanens of the world aren’t going to move the needle.
Even putting stats aside, the fact that basically all his stats all below average this year and his win loss record is mediocre and his record against good teams in terrible, from the eye test can anyone really say
1.) His game has matured this year? (ie: you feel he's more steady in net versus last year or the year before). I would say the answer is no.
2.) Are the weaknesses in his game (slow athleticism, poor lateral movement, often times poor puck tracking) improving? Again I would say no.
3.) Is he making like more high danger saves/outstanding saves this year versus previous years? Again I would say no. He has his moments here and there, but largely it's the same ol', same ol' with this guy.
I don't think that's a minority opinion on this board or for anyone who's watched him play this year. He took the experience of being in a Cup Final and instead of becoming better for it is just basically stuck in the same tier.
He's not improving his game, didn't come into camp in any better of shape, etc. etc. I don't think he'll ever overcome his lack of athletic ability, it's a hard limit on how good he can be in this league.
1.) His game has matured this year? (ie: you feel he's more steady in net versus last year or the year before). I would say the answer is no.
2.) Are the weaknesses in his game (slow athleticism, poor lateral movement, often times poor puck tracking) improving? Again I would say no.
3.) Is he making like more high danger saves/outstanding saves this year versus previous years? Again I would say no. He has his moments here and there, but largely it's the same ol', same ol' with this guy.
I don't think that's a minority opinion on this board or for anyone who's watched him play this year. He took the experience of being in a Cup Final and instead of becoming better for it is just basically stuck in the same tier.
He's not improving his game, didn't come into camp in any better of shape, etc. etc. I don't think he'll ever overcome his lack of athletic ability, it's a hard limit on how good he can be in this league.
bobbythebrain
Registered User
- Jul 30, 2016
- 14,372
- 14,381
Nah man. HFOil has become pretty clueless. He's absolutely right. Every goal that goes in someone is whining and crying to fire the goalie or the coach. It's literally believed that EVERY goal is due to bad goal tending and every goal we score is deserved or a high skill play or shot
Marner scores thru a screen....it's Skinners fault!! Bouchard scores thru a screen....what a goal!!!
Skinner gets beat on a post....he looks terrible. Woll gets beat on 3......we got outplayed by goal tending again
2 goals were scored on point blank rebounds where the D could have stopped if played properly......F+++ Stuart Skinner!!! Nuge and another Oiler were stuffed on the goal line by TO"s D.....We got out goalied again lolol
Nylander scores 1 of 3 breakaways last nite....it's Skinner sucks!!!!! How many breakaways did McDavid have last night? I can sure as shit guarantee say if he scored 1 or 2 this fan base would be praising him
Woll let's in 4 goals but we lose 4-3...it's we lost b/c of Skinner. Why can't we get goal tending like TO did?
It's comical at this point how illogical this place has become
19-15 record this year overall (that would be just at the cutoff if not slightly below for playoffs)
2-9-2 .874 save perentage against top 10 teams.
25th in save percentage.
56th in goals saved above expected.
Got himself cut off Team Canada even though he probably had a gimme spot waiting for him by virtue of being in the Cup Final.
Those are pretty much facts.
It's only in the Edmonton market this guy is coddled and treated with kiddie gloves because he's a local boy with a narrative the local media wants so badly to turn out well.
If this was Toronto or Montreal and they had McDavid and were in a Cup window, he would be getting MURDERED by the press. This would be the no.1 story in town. So please spare me the boo-hoo sobbing about poor Skinner getting picked on by HFBoards, we're only saying what the freaking silent media here doesn't have the balls to say.
McJadeddog
Registered User
Expecting Spec, of all people, to understand something is really the problem. He might be dumbest Edmonton sports reporter in history, at least for those that made it to a relatively large stage. He is beyond stupid and has no concept of almost anything. He is a clickbait journalist with no understanding of the game whatsoever.
Every normal stat, every advanced stat, and every eye-test, tells you that Skinner is a below average tender. Anybody who doesn't see this is being willfully ignorant, or really is just ignorant.
LevelingSolo
Registered User
- Jan 15, 2012
- 4,981
- 6,938
Just listened to KK's post game, he's subtly saying Skinner let them down in the first
Fishy McScales
Registered User
Stan Bowman has been in charge for six months. For the record I was against hiring him.
Dirty Mind
Registered User
- Apr 26, 2022
- 60
- 172
Trade Not My Fault already. Maybe Pittsburgh so he can be reunited with his best bro Vinny. Literally any other goaltender is better. I don’t know how this guy made the NHL, I knew he was poo ever since his debut in January 2021 when he was .868 versus a hapless Sens team that was 1-6-1. He will be the reason the Oilers won’t win the Cup for the third straight season.
And don’t give me this nonsense about blaming Draisaitl or the freaking Conn Smythe winner for not scoring in an extremely tightly-contested game 7 especially after doing most of the legwork just to get to that point, that was a garbage winning goal to give up even though they should have scored on that glorious chance right before.
If he wasn’t so putrid against the Canucks that series is done in 5, 6 at the most. Which would have been beneficial for the subsequent rounds.
I’ll believe the Oilers can win the Cup with Skinner only if it actually happens.
And don’t give me this nonsense about blaming Draisaitl or the freaking Conn Smythe winner for not scoring in an extremely tightly-contested game 7 especially after doing most of the legwork just to get to that point, that was a garbage winning goal to give up even though they should have scored on that glorious chance right before.
If he wasn’t so putrid against the Canucks that series is done in 5, 6 at the most. Which would have been beneficial for the subsequent rounds.
I’ll believe the Oilers can win the Cup with Skinner only if it actually happens.
Ritchie Valens
Registered User
- Sep 24, 2007
- 30,054
- 43,449
Did you see the 4th goal? Skinner went for a poke check, whiffed on it and the puck went through his legs. Shit you see in beer league. Marner barely had control of the puck. That’s the kind of stuff he does that winds up in losses. Some of the saves Woll made at the other end were some great stops.
For a guy who is 6’4, Skinner sure gets beat clean up high a lot and is slow as f***. Had Pickard played last night, that’s a W for the Oilers. He’s way quicker and seems more focused in the net, whereas another poster said Skinner is dancing to the arena music.
The stats don’t lie, Skinner is not a good goalie.
KeithIsActuallyBad
SPEEN!
My question is why didn’t any of the five skaters on the ice even attempt to stop Marner? He skated through the team like they weren’t even there.
Louis Cypher
Boys are back in town
- Jun 11, 2007
- 4,223
- 3,770
Our D has to clean up the front of the net and tie guys up but he also needs to make the saves.
You think it will be easier in the playoffs for our forwards. Vegas will roll over us with their size and quality D if Skinner doesn't out perform Hill.
Louis Cypher
Boys are back in town
- Jun 11, 2007
- 4,223
- 3,770
He is a good 1B and Pickard is a good 1C. You don't win cups with that. They have to address it or we are not getting out of our conference this year and maybe not even the division.
4 Goals allowed on 28 shots.
Terrible rebound control all night. One bad game right? Everyone has a bad game. No big deal.
56th in overall Goals saved above expected
27th (out of 31) in Goals saved above expected in goalies with minimum 25 games played.
The stats coming out on how he plays against top 10 teams in the league?
Yes we made it to game 7 of the cup finals. But he didn't win us a single series. And although I don't blame the game 7 loss on him, the cup winning goal is one he should have had. The fact we went down 0-3 with him sporting a .882, .893 and .826. I get it, the team didn't play well in games 1 and 2. Game three though? How many times do we just need "one more save".
You can't logically defend the guy. I like him, but he can't be "our guy". He just isn't good enough.
Jimmi McJenkins
Sometimes miracles
TB12
get a f***ing goalie
- Apr 5, 2015
- 4,867
- 17,156
Haven't read this thread or the GDT but I'm assuming Moustache's fanclub is defending him with some variation of these talking points:
-he only makes 2.6 million
-not his fault
-his numbers since *insert date* means he's good
-his numbers against teams that aren't in the bottom of the league don't count because *reasons*
-blaming the D
-blaming the coach
-blaming the forwards
-just had a kid, lack of sleep
-"no goalies make those saves"
It's criminal to tie McDavid's legacy to these Moustache shenanigans. Get a f***ing goalie.
-he only makes 2.6 million
-not his fault
-his numbers since *insert date* means he's good
-his numbers against teams that aren't in the bottom of the league don't count because *reasons*
-blaming the D
-blaming the coach
-blaming the forwards
-just had a kid, lack of sleep
-"no goalies make those saves"
It's criminal to tie McDavid's legacy to these Moustache shenanigans. Get a f***ing goalie.
Exactly this. How many times did we yell for a good goalie then we sort of forced Koski out (who actually may have won us a game or two against the Avalanche but who knows) and then got Smith thank god, for us to Campbell it up. Skinner has no chance to get better he's so in his own f***ing head he thinks his team is REALLY practicing against him hard or something but then is surprised other teams have much, much, MUCH better shooters than us and therefore he NEVER gets better as we have NO ONE TO PUSH HIM. Dustin is a f***in scrub he couldn't coach me to be shit let alone anyone who came in through our organization.
Exactly alll of this on reddit! Don't forget the "If you minus these 5 games and add these 5 games from last year and disregard all of 2024 but not 2025 January we have a really good goalie guys? upvotes please" and then I tag them in big red letters "FOOL" thanks to Reddit Enhancement Suite, and I go about my day not making logical fallacies to appease the masses. Skinner stinks as a goalie and our stupid coach can never pull the idiot.
