I consider it a success, given the context of this entire season, but considering it a failure is not off base, nor is it even a bad thing.
The loss last night stings, especially after coming all the way back from 3-0 and losing by a single goal, but this was a hell of an effort after teetering on the brink of destruction after the opening of the regular season. Though I’ve been hopeful, I always had that sneaking feeling that McDavid and the Oilers might “have to” lose their first SCF appearance, ala Gretzky and Crosby (a fate I think Lemieux was able to avoid because his opponent was a 27 win/68 point/15 seed who still took 2 of the first 3 games). I was hoping to avoid that, but it is what it is.
Florida is a great team. The Oilers lost to a 110 point team that are now champions, have been to back to back Finals, and preceded that by winning the Presidents’ trophy two years ago. Terrific squad.
Now, if the Oilers are not champions next year at this point, sure, I will call that a failure. They’ve been to the dance, they were agonizingly close to a historic comeback, and I don’t see why they can’t pick themselves up, dust themselves off, get back to work and use this “failure” to get them over the hump.