The Worst player since the last lockout(04-05) for the Leafs?

[Bomber0104]

Sundin was payed over 8M per year on avg over his last 2 contracts.

So don't make it sound like he was a 10yr old mine worker putting in 14hrs a day.

He was very well, perhaps overly, compensated for his carreer in Toronto. So damn straight I think he should have left when asked to leave.

You are asking the very heart and soul, pride and joy a ticket out of town for a prospect?

Never.

I'd never ask that of such a heroic captain.

That's not the way I'd want such an esteemed Leaf treated.

Kaberle was bad enough.

Not Sundin.

 

[charliolemieux]

You are asking the very heart and soul, pride and joy a ticket out of town for a prospect?

Never.

I'd never ask that of such a heroic captain.

That's not the way I'd want such an esteemed Leaf treated.

Kaberle was bad enough.

Not Sundin.

Sundin was a good captain but c'mon man that is stretching it.

You make it sound like he was Gilmour, Clark and Salming all rolled into one. ANd He simply wasn't.

Even esteemed players get traded. Ask Sittler, Gretzky, Bourque, Francis, Shanahan, Pronger, Gilmour and about 100 other of some of the best to ever play the game.


EDIT nother name just popped inot my head: Ryan Smyth.

 

[Bomber0104]

Sundin was a good captain but c'mon man that is stretching it.

You make it sound like he was Gilmour, Clark and Salming all rolled into one. ANd He simply wasn't.

Even esteemed players get traded. Ask Sittler, Gretzky, Bourque, Francis, Shanahan, Pronger, Gilmour and about 100 other of some of the best to ever play the game.


EDIT nother name just popped inot my head: Ryan Smyth.

Sundin was the greatest Leaf since Vaive/Salming

 

[charliolemieux]

Sundin was the greatest Leaf since Vaive/Salming

Sundin wasn't as good as Gilmour.

IF you think Vaive was anywhere near as good as Gilmour you never watched both play.

 

[Bomber0104]

Sundin wasn't as good as Gilmour.

IF you think Vaive was anywhere near as good as Gilmour you never watched both play.

Gilmour was a beneficiary of circumstance.

Greatest Leaf was Salming OR Vaive since Sundin

 

[charliolemieux]

Gilmour was a beneficiary of circumstance.

Greatest Leaf was Salming OR Vaive since Sundin

Dear god please go start a thread Titled "Gilmour was a beneficiary of circumstance." on the HoH board.

 

[Bomber0104]

Dear god please go start a thread Titled "Gilmour was a beneficiary of circumstance." on the HoH board.

I am considering it.

 

[charliolemieux]

I am considering it.

Do it. I would love to read the explaination.

Don't forget to put Sundin and Vaive in there.

 

[Bomber0104]

Do it. I would love to read the explaination.

Don't forget to put Sundin and Vaive in there.

And Salming...

But this is off-topic..and has gone on long enough

 

[charliolemieux]

And Salming...

But this is off-topic..and has gone on long enough

Still waiting on that thread on the HoH board.

 

[Michel Beauchamp]

You too should consider getting a room... or a sitcom called "The Odd Couple".

 

[charliolemieux]

You too should consider getting a room... or a sitcom called "The Odd Couple".

YEs we too should get a room. Would just love 5min.

Do you actually ever post on the Habs boards?

Or are you becoming a closet Leafs fan?

 

[AvroArrow]

tie , toskala + lebda

 

[Phion Keneuf]

Definitely Lebda

There is no comparable

 

[Cor]

#LikeALebda

 

[Bomber0104]

YEs we too should get a room. Would just love 5min.

Do you actually ever post on the Habs boards?

Or are you becoming a closet Leafs fan?

Not sure how to react to this....

(Being a Catholic and all..)

 

[Eye of Ra]

 

[Leaf Rocket]

tie , toskala + lebda

toskala played some games atleast gotta go with lebda.

 

[Erdinger]

Lebda. Not only totally incompetent but we ended up stuck with Lombardi just to get rid of him. One of the few bad trades by Burke there.

 

[Rockinz]

Toskala by far... Lebad at least was signed at a reasonable contract and we gave up nothing.

 

[Wendelstache]

The answer is Scott Gomez.


I know he doesn't play for the Leafs but it hurts being a "fan" and watching that guy play.

 

[Michel Beauchamp]

YEs we too should get a room. Would just love 5min.

Do you actually ever post on the Habs boards?

Or are you becoming a closet Leafs fan?

Got me.

That'll teach me to post at 1:40AM...

 

[Michel Beauchamp]

Toskala by far... Lebad at least was signed at a reasonable contract and we gave up nothing.

Was there anything reasonable about signing him?

 

[charliolemieux]

Got me.

That'll teach me to post at 1:40AM...

But that's when the classic posts happen.

I know my logic level is usually impared or should I say lowered by that time.

 

[Crispy Crust]

Andy ****ing Wozniewski.