His first round picks have been absolutely solid. His mid-to-late round picks leave something to be desired but McNally and Corrado have shown some promise.
I think his mid-to-late round picks are underrated actually. Based on past stats, getting 2-3 good AHLers from a draft is good, getting 1 full-time NHLer is better, getting 2 full-time NHLers would be considered excellent.
If you look at 2009, we have Schroeder, Rodin, Connnauton, Andersson, and Cannata playing/played in the AHL. Jeremy Price looks like he will clearly make the AHL too. That's 6 out of 7 that year. Schroeder looks like a clear NHLer at this point. Andersson and Cannata, IMO, have both NHL potential and are showing it this season. Connauton is probably a career AHLer.
We didn't have that many picks in 2010, but McNally looks good right now even if he's not playing at the moment. I do think Polasek has #7/#8 upside so also a marginal NHLer.
2011: Jensen is a future 2nd liner, at the very least. Blomstrand, LaBate, and Corrado are going to be at least AHLers. With Corrado showing clear upside for the NHL. Blomstrand was a pick that was heavily criticized at the time and now look at him...
I think people around here need to give these drafts more time to show results. A year ago Andersson was considered a bust and it turns out he was just being mishanded in Sweden and is now one of the best D in Chicago. Schroeder was considered a bust based solely on his stats.
I stand by my past statement that this team's drafting and prospect pool has been completely undermined by the 2006 and 2007 drafts. Outside of Grabner we didn't even get a single AHLer.