Ehh. No.
His teams are consistently unprepared. They start slow, sometimes ridiculously so….this season we set records for getting owned in the first half.
They’re consistently undisciplined, and Tomlin shows double standards all the time, I.e, forgiving Ray Ray the taunting.
He’s a horrible game manager, his choices of 2-pointers, time outs, time mgmt, frequently are unexplainable.
His Coordinators suck. He can’t get them to scheme to the strengths of his personnel, or get his players in best position to succeed. Witness our LBs chasing WRs all over the field.
He’s terrible at adjusting. Both during games, and over the season, witness the multiple late season collapses when other coaches figure him out (Harbaugh last year for ex) and he does…..nothing.
We can argue about personal evaluation. We’ve obviously had great results w WRs and RBs, but the rest is a real mess. Kendrick Green starting (w Pouncey’s nbr???) , destroying play after play then f8nally getting replaced via injury w a C sitting on the bench lol year, and whoa lookey, we can run now.
Tomlin is below the line. In loads and loads of areas. 3 playoff Ws in 10 yrs, w the Nbr of Pro Bowlers (on both sides of the ball) is a travesty.
There’s no other team in the NFL where that kind of under performance would be acceptable.
