OT: The Music Thread Part Six

Status
Not open for further replies.

GordonHowe

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Sep 21, 2005
17,330
18,840
Newton, MA.
Keith Moon was the soul of the band for sure, but I also think Kenney Jones is underrated as their replacement drummer. Eminence Front is a jam.
Moonie is my favorite. Not as technically sound as Neil Peart or bombastic like Bonzo, he was all over the place but it worked spectacularly.

Someone described Theodore Roosevelt (accurately) as "a tornado in pants." That was Moonie.
 
  • Love
Reactions: eightspokedb

GordonHowe

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Sep 21, 2005
17,330
18,840
Newton, MA.
I don't care for her (at all) so I am all set.

Unfortunately, most of the artist I want to see are dead or too old to do concerts.

Taylor Swift is extremely talented, extremely ambitious, and extremely calculating.

Swift has taken the modern celebrity tactic of parading her personal life before the public to its logical extreme.

In a word, she has commodified it.

Narcissism to the nth degree, as with someone else I might name, is repulsive.

I leave her to it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TD Charlie and BMC

eightspokedb

pickee chickadee
Sponsor
Jul 17, 2002
9,508
6,163
cave of caerbannog
Visit site
Moonie is my favorite. Not as technically sound as Neil Peart or bombastic like Bonzo, he was all over the place but it worked spectacularly.

Someone described Theodore Roosevelt (accurately) as "a tornado in pants." That was Moonie.
Saw the original Who line up in concert about a month before Keith passed....
 

GordonHowe

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Sep 21, 2005
17,330
18,840
Newton, MA.
Saw the original Who line up in concert about a month before Keith passed....

I wish I could say that. I hope he was reasonably coherent, drumming wise. Good for you. A messy, fantasticly emotional drummer.

No expert but,

I love Peart -- exact and exacting as a musican, mathamatical; not that big on Bonham though I realize many believe he was the best, and Ginger Baker is often mentioned in this company.

Ringo was a great, no frills, few fills, in the pocket rock & roll/pop drummer.

I understand that upon hearing/hiring Starkey in 1962, neither Lennon nor McCartney were major musicial experts. Yet according to McCartney, a look between John & Paul -- "Who the f*** is this guy?" -- and Ringo was in.

Ringo has often been slagged off by those who don't know better. He was not a showy guy, but he could swing easy & tight, and play aggressively as well.

You have to remember, too, that until 1965 and the advent of Keith Moon, few pop drummers, outside of session men, were distinctive. They kept time.

Starr eschewed showy fills, but listen to "Ticket to Ride." Listen to his light touch, evident on many tracks, like "If I Fell."

Listen, too, to "Rain," one of my all time favorite Beatle tracks, not least because of Ringo's drumming, which he adjudged his finest.

Starr's work on "Strawberry Fields Forever" and Abbey Road are equally noetworthy.

Besides, Ringo was good for at least one warble per album. I'd lay "Boys," "Honey Don't," "What Goes On," "Yellow Submarine," "A Little Help From My Friends," and the self-penned "Octopus's Garden" ahead of any vocal effort from Bonzo or Ginger, largely because they offered none.

Outside of "Bell Boy," I don't recall Keith on lead vocals, either.
 
Last edited:

McGarnagle

Yes.
Aug 5, 2017
30,357
41,646
l.

You have to remember, too, that until 1965 and the advent of Keith Moon, few pop drummers, outside of session men, were distinctive. They kept time.

The guy I always hear about as having been the best drummer in the British Invasion scene and the guy who broke the ground for the Moons and Bakers who came after was Chris Curtis of the Searchers. Unfortunately he had some mental illnesses that cost him any chance of holding a long career in the music business and the Searchers self-destructed.

 

aguineapig

Guest
Six months prior they were playing to a coupe hundred thousand at Woodstock. The couple dozen kids at this TV studio performance were all outfitted at Finetone later in life for hearing aids.

Leslie West at an early gig

How Felix got the producers gig with Cream


 

Dennis Bonvie

Registered User
Dec 29, 2007
31,400
20,932
Connecticut
They were surprisingly good,saw Roger Waters who sucked and Eric Clapton who mailed it in within the last 3 months too.

I saw Clapton at the Yale Bowl not long after he got out of rehab. He was somewhat less than gracious.

Saw The Who in Madison Square Garden during the Quadrophenia tour. Seats behind the stage so we got to see Keith Moon go nuts.
 

BNHL

Registered User
Dec 22, 2006
20,023
1,466
Boston
I saw Clapton at the Yale Bowl not long after he got out of rehab. He was somewhat less than gracious.

Saw The Who in Madison Square Garden during the Quadrophenia tour. Seats behind the stage so we got to see Keith Moon go nuts.
Clapton never even addressed the audience at all last month,he simply went through the motions,I can check that box now,but never again. I never saw the Who,and was surprisingly glad I saw the remaining members. They did a great job.
 

EvilElf63

Registered User
Mar 27, 2012
2,263
1,812
Catskills
They were surprisingly good,saw Roger Waters who sucked and Eric Clapton who mailed it in within the last 3 months too.
I saw Roger waters twice about 10 years ago- he was pretty good, but as I recall, his young guitarist stole the show.

Best old-guy performance I've seen, also about 10 years ago now, was Ian Anderson, who still was able to jump around the stage on one leg while playing the flute. Wasn't quite perfect and was noticeably out of breath at times (kind of a hindrance when playing the flute) but overall brought great energy and showmanship.
 

McGarnagle

Yes.
Aug 5, 2017
30,357
41,646
Clapton never even addressed the audience at all last month,he simply went through the motions,I can check that box now,but never again. I never saw the Who,and was surprisingly glad I saw the remaining members. They did a great job.

Well, given his history sometimes it's best if he keeps his mouth shut during concerts.
 

BigBadBruins7708

Registered User
Dec 11, 2017
14,570
19,991
Las Vegas
I saw Roger waters twice about 10 years ago- he was pretty good, but as I recall, his young guitarist stole the show.

Best old-guy performance I've seen, also about 10 years ago now, was Ian Anderson, who still was able to jump around the stage on one leg while playing the flute. Wasn't quite perfect and was noticeably out of breath at times (kind of a hindrance when playing the flute) but overall brought great energy and showmanship.

Speaking of old guys, I saw Elton John last friday in Phoenix and he was great. 2+ hour show, his voice and playing haven't missed a beat and great energy throughout. Too bad he's retiring.

One you can still see, and absolutely should, is Billy Joel. Saw him here in Vegas at Allegiant Stadium and same as Elton played a great, energetic, 2 hour set and hasn't dropped off at all.
 

GordonHowe

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Sep 21, 2005
17,330
18,840
Newton, MA.
The guy I always hear about as having been the best drummer in the British Invasion scene and the guy who broke the ground for the Moons and Bakers who came after was Chris Curtis of the Searchers. Unfortunately he had some mental illnesses that cost him any chance of holding a long career in the music business and the Searchers self-destructed.


Will ✔️
 

jgatie

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Sep 22, 2011
11,815
12,954
Me too. I posted the exact same video weeks ago in the music thread. I bought Eat to the Beat at the time (1979) and it remains a favorite, not least because of Clem Burke's work.

✌️ 😎

The Ramones once hired him for two shows after their drummer quit, but passed on hiring him permanently. I like to think it's because he played too fast for The Ramones. :DD
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

  • HV 71 @ Lulea Hockey
    HV 71 @ Lulea Hockey
    Wagers: 2
    Staked: $85.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Croatia vs Portugal
    Croatia vs Portugal
    Wagers: 1
    Staked: $25.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Luxembourg vs Northern Ireland
    Luxembourg vs Northern Ireland
    Wagers: 2
    Staked: $50,050.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Poland vs Scotland
    Poland vs Scotland
    Wagers: 1
    Staked: $25.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Serbia vs Denmark
    Serbia vs Denmark
    Wagers: 1
    Staked: $25.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:

Ad

Ad