TV: The All - Encompassing Star Trek Thread. Debate Long + Prosper

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
I figured this should go here:

Quentin Tarantino Hatches ‘Star Trek’ Movie Idea; Paramount, JJ Abrams To Assemble Writer’s Room

Quentin Tarantino has plans for a Star Trek picture, and they're putting a writing room together to work on a script.

It feels like it's the type of project that can end up going nowhere, but, if this does go through, it could be great.


This could be interesting.

But can he make a movie without the F word or the N word

That is the question
 
that moment when you watch Sub Rosa, and go "yeup. they truly ran out of ideas."

yet it's still better than Threshold.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blender
that moment when you watch Sub Rosa, and go "yeup. they truly ran out of ideas."

yet it's still better than Threshold.

I'm surprised they got the guy who played Ronan back to play Shakaar on ds9.

"Hey Duncan. Remember when you worked for us and played the candle genie who had ghost sex with beverley? We've got another role for you. No, it's better. Seriously. You can make out with Nana Visitor, but not as a ghost or anthing."
 
I'm surprised they got the guy who played Ronan back to play Shakaar on ds9.

"Hey Duncan. Remember when you worked for us and played the candle genie who had ghost sex with beverley? We've got another role for you. No, it's better. Seriously. You can make out with Nana Visitor, but not as a ghost or anthing."

:laugh:

my question was during the whole thing.
if Ronin basically haunted and ghost-sexed up the Howard women... what the hell was he going to do with Wesley? Like what he went, well I don't want my great great great great great grandma's candle?
 
Tarantino is one of the best directors in Hollywood. But I dont think he is the right choice to be helming any ST film or TV project.
 
as I am winding down my TNG thon - i finally can list the episodes that I feel are important to watch.


1: Encounter at Farpoint
where we meet our plucky crew, and realise they are all very very cranky. also the last time we see Troi in proper uniform until Season 6. Also. Q. Hi Q.

2: The Neutral Zone + Q, Who + Best of Both Worlds + Family.
we first meet Romulans, but they aren't the ones you are worried about, it's the thing that made the big hole in the planet. Then we see Q again (plus the awesome Q v. Guinan fight) actually introducing us to the creepy aliens the Borg, then to get to the Best of Both Worlds/Family where we end that saga for the most part, as the other Borg episodes in the series tends to be another arc and not really linked to this one imo.

3: The Measure of a Man + The Offspring
this is hands down one of my favourite episodes. I don't even think you need to watch any TNG before this episode (truly) and you still wouldn't be "lost" it all really makes sense. one of the best "Data yearns to be human/has rights/but is seen as property" episodes - which ties into the "sequel" of sorts with The Offspring, as Data's child is seen as property, and the lengths Starfleet tends to wrap itself into justify being horrible, ultimately Lal being shut down due to her emotional overload.

4: The Emissary + Sins of the Father + Reunion (Redemption if you squint)
Worf finds his first wife so to speak (more of a mate than what Jadzia ended up being for Worf), but she turns him down, then we learn a lot about Khitomer and how much Romulans took from Worf, and that Worf's dad is a traitor - but no, everyone knows it wasn't Mogh it was Duras, and this really "Honour is everything" species is willing to mud sling a dead man to keep the peace, following into the Reunion where we now have K'hlyar wanting to truly mate with Worf, and a Son, but Worf can't do anything because he's shunned, leading to her death, Worf raising his son and a really big "I give zero craps being a starfleet officer). (plus Worf's first Formal Reprimand. Which adding to the second one he got in DS9, explains a lot of why he chose his future career path)

5: Yesterday's Enterprise + Sarek + Unification
in where we see a really good Historical episode, give Tasha's death more meaning (though it gave us more Worf, so thanks Denise for wanting to quit), leading up to seeing Sarek (one real last time) and actually giving a voice to the emotions we always wondered, into having a great look/insight how Romulans do things (like why try to always annex Vulcan?) what happened to Tasha, and a bridge between Sarek, Picard and Spock that is really well written. quasi arc

6: The Perfect Mate.
there are a few "Picard finds someone" episodes, but I love this one. I think you ultimately get this sense that Picard fell for this woman, you feel heartbroken at the end of it, and then the humour was on point.

6: The Chains of Command
I! SEE! FOUR! LIGHTS! no really, , this is hands down one of the best episodes of the series, I think it really puts you in the frame of mind of how Cardassians really are and how everyone keeps waltzing on this line of "hey you know we have this peace but we really do not like you or trust you" then you have Jellico who tells deanna to dress properly (finally), who kinda hates the hand holding Picard has this crew on, then you get the whole torture scene. so awesome.


7: Lower Decks
I would have added "The First Duty" (in my HM) as something to watch, but I don't think you need it truly to appreciate this episode, and I honestly feel that a great way to have more startrek is to have the lower desk style. written well it won't be too "high-school" feeling. anyway. we have a great intermingling of senior staff, Ensigns fighting for promotions, and sacrifice.

8: Ensign Ro + Journey's End +Preemptive Strike
the first Ensign Ro episode, the last Ensign Ro episode, sandwiched in between a Wesley choosing to screw Starfleet episode. (You could skip Journey's End, I mean it's not a MUST WATCH) but I feel that these three episodes explain the Bajorans (specifically) why they are in Starfleet (makes you wonder who sponsors them to join Starfleet), leads up the TNG portion of the Maquis and how Starfleet is wrong in a way in how they are handling the DMZ, the Treaty etc.

9: The Inner Light + Lessons
we had the argument if Inner Light is overrated or not - but I do feel this is one of the episodes that everyone should watch at least once, and then make the decision on their own. Lessons (where Picard falls in love), is the direct sequel as we hear how it impacted him and how he got into music because of these experiences.

10: Tapestry + All Good Things....
I linked this because, Tapestry needs to be in the top ten. and I didn't know what to kick out So you watch this one. Where we find out Jean Luc was very not diplomatic growing up, and Q'.. just being Q. - followed by Q telling everyone "Hey guess what. everything from Farpoint - still going on!" and we try to unravel the mystery, and we are left wondering if Humanity was truly on trial, or Q always forcing the crew (and ultimately us) into thinking beyond what we know, see etc.

Honourable Mentions:
The Price, A Matter of Perspective, clues, Nth Degree, The First Duty, the Chase. oh and the Drumhead and Force of Nature.
 
Last edited:
Romulan Heavy episodes that I think are among the best in no particular order.

Balance of Terror (TOS)
The Enterprise Incident (TOS)
The Defector (TNG)
Unification (TNG)
The Enemy (TNG)
Face of the Enemy (TNG)
The Mind's Eye (TNG)
In the Pale Moonlight (DS9)
The Die is Cast (DS9)
Inter Arma Enim Silint Leges (DS9)




 
Last edited:
Chain of Command is one of the best episodes of the entire franchise. The Cardassians are such an interesting enemy, and this episode does a great job of building them up in to amazing enemy they will become in DS9.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Daisy Jane
Tarantino directing a Trek movie would be one of the most anticipated sci-fi movies in the last 20 years. It'd be just a tier below TFA and TPM in terms of anticipation. Provided they would keep the details under wraps, it could also have the biggest Trek movie opening of all-time too.
 
Romulan Heavy episodes that I think are among the best in no particular order.

Balance of Terror (TOS)
The Enterprise Incident (TOS)
The Defector (TNG)
Unification (TNG)
The Enemy (TNG)
Face of the Enemy (TNG)
Birthright, Part II (TNG)
The Mind's Eye (TNG)
In the Pale Moonlight (DS9)
The Die is Cast (DS9)


I would take out Birthright II and put in Inter Arma Enim Silint Leges.


 
Tarantino directing a Trek movie would be one of the most anticipated sci-fi movies in the last 20 years. It'd be just a tier below TFA and TPM in terms of anticipation. Provided they would keep the details under wraps, it could also have the biggest Trek movie opening of all-time too.
Gives Kill Bill a whole new meaning. :laugh:
 
Klingon Heavy episodes that I think are among the best in no particular order.

Errand of Mercy (TOS)
The Trouble With Tribbles (TOS)
A Matter of Honor (TNG)
Redemption (TNG)
Birthright (TNG)
Blood Oath (DS9)
The Way of the Warrior (DS9)
The Sword of Kahless (DS9)
Apocalypse Rising (DS9)
Once More Unto the Breach (DS9)
 
Klingon Heavy episodes that I think are among the best in no particular order.

Errand of Mercy (TOS)
The Trouble With Tribbles (TOS)
A Matter of Honor (TNG)
Redemption (TNG)
Birthright (TNG)
Blood Oath (DS9)
The Way of the Warrior (DS9)
The Sword of Kahless (DS9)
Apocalypse Rising (DS9)
Once More Unto the Breach (DS9)

I think Sins of the Father needs to be in here.
 
I figured this should go here:

Quentin Tarantino Hatches ‘Star Trek’ Movie Idea; Paramount, JJ Abrams To Assemble Writer’s Room

Quentin Tarantino has plans for a Star Trek picture, and they're putting a writing room together to work on a script.

It feels like it's the type of project that can end up going nowhere, but, if this does go through, it could be great.

Patrick Stewart says that he might be interested in playing Jean-Luc Picard again if Tarantino will be directing.

Patrick Stewart Might Reprise Jean-Luc Picard Role if Tarantino Directs 'Star Trek'

Following the news that Quentin Tarantino was working on a new idea for the franchise alongside J.J. Abrams, with plans to direct, Patrick Stewart
has thrown an unlikely hat back into the intergalactic ring."People are always saying to me, 'Will you be Jean-Luc Picard again?' And I cannot think
that would be possible, but there are ways in which something like that might come about," the iconic actor told The Hollywood
 
All star crew

Captain-Picard
First Officer-Spock
Science officer-Data
Security officer-Worf
Chief Engineer- O'Brien
Medical Officer- Bashier
Helmsman- Paris

All fail crew

Captain-Archer
First Officer-Burnham
Science officer-Kim
Security Officer-Reed
Chief Engineer-Stamets
Medical Officer-Polaski
Helmsman-Counselor Troi :laugh:
 
Last edited:
First Officer-Michaels

Who?

.And you pretty much have to pry the "worst helmsman" title out of Travis Mayweather's blank, irrelevant hands. Or maybe Wesley if you shoehorn Space Doogie into the role of helmsman instead of his usual gig of "non-departmental awesomeness officer"

Also if I'm being petty, neither Data nor Kim were science officers. They were Operations officers. Considering it was a science and exploration vessel by design, it was always kind of weird that they didn't really have a dedicated science officer/station on Voyager.
 
Who?

.And you pretty much have to pry the "worst helmsman" title out of Travis Mayweather's blank, irrelevant hands. Or maybe Wesley if you shoehorn Space Doogie into the role of helmsman instead of his usual gig of "non-departmental awesomeness officer"

Also if I'm being petty, neither Data nor Kim were science officers. They were Operations officers. Considering it was a science and exploration vessel by design, it was always kind of weird that they didn't really have a dedicated science officer/station on Voyager.


I wonder if they poopooed it because they were going on the "Let's save Tuvok" mission so they didn't need a science officer, and then Seven kinda became it. (that little box thing was the science station)

Who is Michaels?

I would swap Worf with Odo
Pulaski wasn't that bad at all.

hmmmhmmm
Picard vs. Sisko has to make me think.
 
Using the list above, I'll go with this. I've split hairs a bit because some characters on the show filled multiple roles either simultaneously or at different points in the series.

Stamets isn't actually the Chief Engineering by the way. He's only in charge of the spore drive.

All star crew

Captain - James T. Kirk
First Officer - Kyra Nerys
Operations Officer - Data
Science Officer - Spock
Security Officer - Odo
Chief Engineer - Miles O'Brien
Medical Officer - Julian Bashier
Helmsman - Tom Paris

All fail crew

Captain - Jonathan Archer
First Officer - Michael Burnham
Operations Officer - Harry Kim
Science Officer - T'Pol
Security Officer - Malcolm Reed
Chief Engineer - Geordi LaForge
Medical Officer - Katherine Polaski
Helmsman - Travis Mayweather
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad