The 10 best listed players are ... You can vote for 10.

[amnesiac]

Gretz
Orr
Mario
Howe
Crosby
Beliveau
Hull
Jagr
Hasek
Richard

 

[Grifter3511]

I wonder if there was a goalie in MTL for Lemaire's entire tenure there. Imagine if that goalie never won another vezina after Lemaire left the organization.

Surely that goalie would also gets his accomplishments discredited like broduer does

Brodeur vezinas without lemaire: 4
Roy vezinas without lemaire: 0

Oh, oh.....now do Conn Smythes!

 

[dgibb10]

Oh, oh.....now do Conn Smythes!

Broduer had 7 shutouts in a playoff run and didn't get it. Roy had that many in a REGULAR season just 3 times in 2 decades.

If only brodeur bitched his way to a superteam the second the team wasn't stacked around him again like roy did.

Roy took over for an already elite team to start his career, then left for another already elite team, then when he retired that team remained elite.

 

[Grifter3511]

Broduer had 7 shutouts in a playoff run and didn't get it. Roy had that many in a REGULAR season just 3 times in 2 decades.

If only brodeur bitched his way to a superteam the second the team wasn't stacked around him again like roy did.

Roy took over for an already elite team to start his career, then left for another already elite team, then when he retired that team remained elite.

Devils and their trapping, all out defense got 7 shutouts and Brodeur didn't get the conn smythe? Shows how much the voters thought it was on him as opposed to the team and structure around him.

 

[Mike C]

Don't see Matthews

He's on the top 10 playoff performers list

 

[dgibb10]

Devils and their trapping, all out defense got 7 shutouts and Brodeur didn't get the conn smythe? Shows how much the voters thought it was on him as opposed to the team and structure around him.

It shows that Gigeure had an also utterly ridiculous run and that media hated Broduer because the way the devils put belt to ass was "boring"

Roy did not win a single Vezina without Lemaire in the organization.

 

[PenguinSuitedUp]

It shows that Gigeure had an also utterly ridiculous run and that media hated Broduer because the way the devils put belt to ass was "boring"

Roy did not win a single Vezina without Lemaire in the organization.

You don’t have to put the quotes around boring. It was boring.

 

[Grifter3511]

It shows that Gigeure had an also utterly ridiculous run and that media hated Broduer because the way the devils put belt to ass was "boring"

Roy did not win a single Vezina without Lemaire in the organization.

For my money, the most prestigious individual player award is the conn smythe. Meant you were more or less the best player when it mattered most and your team had success. Whether he was a rookie (86), on a lunch pail team (93) or a team of HoFers (01), Roy was the most valuable player.