For the record, I don't think Sather should be faulted here at all. It was a good signing originally.
Richards was in his prime and really didn't appear to be on the decline. He came off a monster year in Dallas. Sather signed him to a solid contract with a very reasonable cap hit for what we were expecting. Richards by all accounts was a gym rat and a heady player before coming here. We saw traces of the latter but his inability to keep up shrouded his IQ.
Wade Redden was a bad contract by Sather. Brads was actually quite good.
Character? The guy realized he was playing for a job.
You say that as if he needs a job and therefore played hard this season out of necessity. He doesn't need a job, he still wants to be a significant contributor to a winning team. That shows good character. His body just can't perform like it did a few years ago.
Is it so terrible for fans to look at him as a person and thank him for his efforts? He was signed to a huge cap circumventing contract that the new CBA closed the loophole on. I can't blame him for not being worth a cap hit that even Sather didn't plan to take on him.
I hated Richards while he was here.
Reflecting back, the guy wasn't terrible. He just wasn't as good as he was billed. We got him to be a 1C, and he played like a 2C/3C tweener. He was a massive disappointment based on expectations/contract/performance.
He's got great character, he's a great leader, and he was always honest about **** in interviews. I can respect that. I wish him well. I hope he goes somewhere and finds a niche.
You say that as if he needs a job and therefore played hard this season out of necessity. He doesn't need a job, he still wants to be a significant contributor to a winning team. That shows good character. His body just can't perform like it did a few years ago.
Is it so terrible for fans to look at him as a person and thank him for his efforts? He was signed to a huge cap circumventing contract that the new CBA closed the loophole on. I can't blame him for not being worth a cap hit that even Sather didn't plan to take on him.
Good character is getting paid a lot to because you want to be a significant contributor to a winning team?
A few people are talking about brad like he was helpful in the last few playoff runs. The Rangers won in spite of a supposed "star" player being benched and put to the 4th line.
The Rangers have given him million$ of thank yous. I really don't think he needs any more from us.
That's the sentiment that I don't share; the belief that because players are paid a lot of money, we can and should feel free to verbally blast them.
They are big boys and they can take it, so I'm not feeling sorry for them, but it does make me wonder what those fans gets out of it. It'd be interesting to see how many of the people that talk badly about players on message boards or boo them at games also stand in line for their autographs and tell them how great they are in person.
One more thought and then I'll let it go. This reminds me of watching the NFL draft and hearing rude fans, for one reason or anther, boo the commissioner and boo talented players that are drafted in the first round. It's a shame that people can't have enough dignity to restrain themselves from booing a 21 year old who is realizing his dreams on a stage right in front of them.
That's the sentiment that I don't share; the belief that because players are paid a lot of money, we can and should feel free to verbally blast them.
They are big boys and they can take it, so I'm not feeling sorry for them, but it does make me wonder what those fans gets out of it. It'd be interesting to see how many of the people that talk badly about players on message boards or boo them at games also stand in line for their autographs and tell them how great they are in person.
One more thought and then I'll let it go. This reminds me of watching the NFL draft and hearing rude fans, for one reason or anther, boo the commissioner and boo talented players that are drafted in the first round. It's a shame that people can't have enough dignity to restrain themselves from booing a 21 year old who is realizing his dreams on a stage right in front of them.
Sorry but I'm not sure exactly what you're trying to say. There might be a word missing that's throwing me off. But let me sum up my thoughts as clearly as I can and let me know if you still disagree with me:
If Brad Richards put in the effort to be a high-performing, significant contributor to the Rangers, but just didn't have the ability any more to meet the expectations his contract created, I think he should be commended for his effort.
If Brad Richards didn't put in the effort to be a high-performing, significant contributor to the Rangers, then shame on him for cashing those checks and not giving what was expected of him.
I personally believe Brad did put in the effort but just didn't have it any more. If anyone is to blame, I would say it's Sather for signing him to the contract. But I can't even fully blame Sather when considering the climate in the league at the time of the signing. Cap circumvention was in style at the time and you couldn't know for certain that the new CBA would bring penalties for previously signed contracts.
You wrote, "He doesn't need a job, he still wants to be a significant contributor to a winning team. That shows good character."
My response is I don't see how the bolded shows "good character."
What I meant by that line was that I don't think he's playing for the money. His contract was going to get paid out whether he tried hard this season or he didn't try at all and was a healthy scratch. I thought he worked hard to be a contributor this season and it wasn't motivated by money. It's fair to say that is expected behavior, so maybe it doesn't show good character, but it would show a lack of character if he didn't make a strong effort.
You guys raise good points about the fans ultimately being the ones who supply the $$$ for the big contracts, so they have a right to show their displeasure. I tend to hold management responsible for players being over-paid to the point where they can't reasonably be expected to live up to their contracts, and that's what I see the Richards situation being. He was more or less set up to fail. I see it being a lot like the Drury signing really.
It also just bothers me when people are so willing to talk trash about someone that does work very hard but is struggling at the highest level of their profession.