I like Watson, and he's one player on the Sens i would target,
but, Watson has 3 points on the season and played only 29 games, and on the Leafs he's a 4th liner, obviously
Ritchie has not come close to expectations, and has 9 pts in 33 games, and has played on every line from 1st to 4th, but never got PP1 time, and on PP2, Simmonds got the net duties over him, where that is pretty much the only place he's any good
on the Sens he'd be top 9 at worse case scenario, and likely be the net presence on PP1
Watson has only played 29 games due to injury. He would never be healthied.
We have this one guy named Brady Tkachuk who plays net front on PP1, so I don't think Ritchie would feature there, and the marginal upgrade he could potentially be on Zack Sanford is not worth taking on the extra year + higher salary.
Ritchie might be top 9 for us, but that is a BEST case scenario. No chance is he playing in our top 6 when healthy, and almost certainly not our top 9 either. Honestly, I wouldn't be surprised if he would be healthied when we have a full lineup. I would take him if we could send out bad salary for the duration of his deal, but no chance I give Watson for him or a 4th, let alone both.
Watson is probably a top 9 forward for us so far this season going by deployment and value, and fills an important role on the PK and taking tons of defensive shifts against tough competition... Ritchie does not fill an important role for us at all, doesn't fill any of the roles Watson does besides physicality, and we don't have anyone internally to step into that role.
Healthy Sens:
Tkachuk - Norris - Batherson
Formenton - Stutzle - Brown
Paul - Pinto - White
Sanford - Gambrell - Watson
Extra/4th line: Gaudette, Ennis, Tierney, Kastelic
What need does Ritchie fill??? He sure as hell isn't an upgrade on any of the top 9, and the only guy in that lineup who he can replace in any capacity is Zack Sanford.... who we already have 4 other viable replacements for.
You shouldn't be wasting your time here, you should be convincing the other GMs to help Dubas out!
Don't you know? We could get him for the low price of free! This offer might not come up ever again (despite it already being an option earlier and every team in the league passing on it) and is too good to miss out on (despite it already being an option earlier and every team in the league passing on it)!