Toggle sidebar

Strome or Hanifin

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bomber0104

Bomber0104

Registered User
Apr 8, 2007
15,237
7,307
Burlington
The_Chosen_One said:
I agree. Hanifin looks like a near-generational talent to me. Strome may become a top line centre but I think his impact will be less. Now if we can somehow snatch Barzal by trading our assets, we'd go a long way.
Click to expand...

You won't hear this often from me but I actually agree.

The Leafs should be looking at this draft as an opportunity to parlay their roster assets into at least one more first rounder, ideally one in the top twelve picks.

Barzal would be nice but I believe he's going top 7 which is a bit rich for what we have to trade.
 

tolwyn

Registered User
Feb 4, 2015
196
3
It's impossible for us to get better than 4th pick if we don't win the lottery, and I really doubt Edmonton passes up the opportunity to land a potential franchise defender. We're better off talking the Strome/Marner pick than hoping we get Hanifin. I do hope I'm wrong and we get him but... I just don't see it.
 

The_Chosen_One

Registered User
Jul 4, 2006
6,285
27
Melbourne, Australia
tolwyn said:
It's impossible for us to get better than 4th pick if we don't win the lottery, and I really doubt Edmonton passes up the opportunity to land a potential franchise defender. We're better off talking the Strome/Marner pick than hoping we get Hanifin. I do hope I'm wrong and we get him but... I just don't see it.
Click to expand...
Same here. Hanifin seems like the #3 to me. He's that Lidstrom/ Suter-like hybrid that EVERY team wants. We're talking elite, approaching-generational #1.
 
Sundinisagod

Sundinisagod

****
Jul 10, 2003
14,051
1,217
KW
Hanifin dropping to 5th, would be similar to how Seth Jones dropped to 4th...the latter ranked Barkov and Drouin going ahead of him, who are comparable to Strome and Marner, and Hanifin is a Seth Jones caliber prospect but with more polish. Tampa should have taken Jones, imagine a Jones-Hedman pairing? Hanifin is perfect for Edm at 3 though, I can't see them passing him up...we have a difficult decision between Strome and Marner imho. It will be interesting to see how they perform head to head in the playoffs, some say it won't make a difference at this point, but don't forget in 2013 Seth Jones was ranked ahead of MacKinnon but Nate's memorial cup performance got him back to 1st overall.
 

YorkshireRose

Registered User
Apr 9, 2014
57
0
Halifax, England
Edmonton picking at 3rd who have an abundance of forward prospects and a future 1st line big skilled centre in Leon Draisaitl. Edmonton will take Hanifin, who by all accounts is a franchise defenseman which they need.
We will take Strome because of his size, which despite some opinions is a massive factor in this league, leaving the canes, who already have good size down the middle, with Marner.

I dont think any of the teams drafting 3rd to 5th in this draft lose.
 
BlueBaron

BlueBaron

Registered User
May 29, 2006
15,752
6,350
Sarnia, On
YorkshireRose said:
Edmonton picking at 3rd who have an abundance of forward prospects and a future 1st line big skilled centre in Leon Draisaitl. Edmonton will take Hanifin, who by all accounts is a franchise defenseman which they need.
We will take Strome because of his size, which despite some opinions is a massive factor in this league, leaving the canes, who already have good size down the middle, with Marner.

I dont think any of the teams drafting 3rd to 5th in this draft lose.
Click to expand...

It does seem logical, but Edmonton has passed on high ranked D before. Nurse was the lowest (highest ?) pick they have had in years . Would not shock me one bit if they took Strome. If I was their GM I would want Hanifin but they seem to think differently than everyone else.
 
The Winter Soldier

The Winter Soldier

Registered User
Apr 4, 2011
71,029
21,381
I finally voted Strome. Tough decision. But I think there are other D men later in the draft that can be as good or maybe even better than Hanifin.
 
The Winter Soldier

The Winter Soldier

Registered User
Apr 4, 2011
71,029
21,381
BlueBaron said:
Now lets just hope the oilers don't screw up the plan on us :)
Click to expand...

Bobby Mac seems to think the Oil need a D man more than a Center.

Drafting Draisaitl last year would seem to indicate this. They have Nurse on the way, if they add Hanifan(who is a great prospect IMO) and promote Draisaitl next year. They will have a young and upcoming core. But Strome is a great prospect too. If not we can take Hanifin and add him to Rielly. Win - win.
 
mydnyte

mydnyte

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Sep 8, 2004
15,390
2,070
we had better lose the next 2, or we may need to make a thread Barzal, or Provorov
 

Gallagbi

Formerly Eazy_B97
Jul 5, 2005
49,511
12,086
BlueBaron said:
It does seem logical, but Edmonton has passed on high ranked D before. Nurse was the lowest (highest ?) pick they have had in years . Would not shock me one bit if they took Strome. If I was their GM I would want Hanifin but they seem to think differently than everyone else.
Click to expand...
They haven't really passed on a high ranking D. Yak, RNH, Hall were the consensus #1 pick and last year Fleury was the only D option and he wasn't worthy of a top 3 (arguably top 7 even) pick.

If they can land Hanifin, I can't see them passing on him (outside the top 2 of course)
 
Last edited:
BlueBaron

BlueBaron

Registered User
May 29, 2006
15,752
6,350
Sarnia, On
EazyB97 said:
They haven't really passed on a high ranking D. Yak, RNH, Hall were the consensus #1 pick and last year Fleury was the only D option and he wasn't worthy of a top 3 (arguably top 7 even) pick.

If they can land Hanafin, I can't see them passing on him (outside the top 2 of course)
Click to expand...

Jones comes to mind.
 

gabeliscious

Registered User
Jan 8, 2009
7,574
257
tolwyn said:
It's impossible for us to get better than 4th pick if we don't win the lottery, and I really doubt Edmonton passes up the opportunity to land a potential franchise defender. We're better off talking the Strome/Marner pick than hoping we get Hanifin. I do hope I'm wrong and we get him but... I just don't see it.
Click to expand...

EazyB97 said:
They haven't really passed on a high ranking D. Yak, RNH, Hall were the consensus #1 pick and last year Fleury was the only D option and he wasn't worthy of a top 3 (arguably top 7 even) pick.

If they can land Hanafin, I can't see them passing on him (outside the top 2 of course)
Click to expand...

i agree with you guys. edmonton would have to be crazy to pass on hanifin for another center given the state their defense is in. the same argument can be made for toronto but we dont have nuge or leon
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Latest posts

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom
X