Otto
Lynch Syndrome. Know your families cancer history
That was me... but in this case you need to follow the thread.. or just read the first five words.
SSM Greyhounds 2023 - 2024 Season Thread (Part 3)
- Thread starter SoupNazi
- Start date
- Status
The closest comparison I can find is Marty McSorely on Donald Brashear a long time ago in the NHL. Same type of swing to the same part of the head.
Chris Coutu
Registered User
There is no way he gets away with no suspension on that. Especially with the league already admitting to missed calls in game 5 against the Spirit.
Otto
Lynch Syndrome. Know your families cancer history
HockeyPops
Registered User
- Aug 20, 2018
- 7,947
- 7,081
i didn't think suggesting the guy who got his bell rung needs re-education was silly so much as it was stupid and beneath the conversation but that's just me!
i agree although i thought the same of parekh! but i guess Guo doesn't have starpower to hide behind like his teammate.
Otto
Lynch Syndrome. Know your families cancer history
It was just as silly as suggesting the player committing the infraction should be out just as long as the injured player
i don't think Sawyer Boulton should have been on the ice until McConnell-Barker was able to return (and probably not even after) and i don't feel silly in the least saying it.
Otto
Lynch Syndrome. Know your families cancer history
Ok, but what if the roles were reversed? As I said previously, what's to stop any team from saying their 4th liner is going to be out for a month? You'd be OK with your Star player sitting out that month?
Dude you are way off topic.
We are at odds over disciplinary action for a pick play and whether or not there is shared responsibility for the injury.
interesting hypothetical, but could be hypothetically interpreted as fraud.
I'm right on topic. Soo greyhounds, injuries, and suspensions etc.
Otto
Lynch Syndrome. Know your families cancer history
How are you going to prove it though? And also, what if a situation like Guo happens and the player isn't hurt? No suspension then?
Is this where I suggest you take it to DM Otto? Asking for a friend
All good here but I thinking I read that advice somewhere recently. ( and it was good advice )
I agree with the penalties/suspensions should not be based on length of injury but rather perceived intent and action ( which on a judgement call will always lead us back to the circular arguements, esp with this league lol) Two players get called on boarding with exact intent and action could have hugely different outcomes for the player cheap shotted.
Otto
Lynch Syndrome. Know your families cancer history
I think you missed the sarcasmIs this where I suggest you take it to DM Otto? Asking for a friend
All good here but I thinking I read that advice somewhere recently. ( and it was good advice )
Lycanthrope
Registered User
- Dec 3, 2011
- 5,901
- 2,696
Well, you did what you had to do Soo (isn’t that a crafty rhyme). Game seven on the road, the way this series has gone. I’d say flip a coin. The pressure is on them Good luck.
faking a concussion after a headshot or any other serious injury is quite easy to prove/disprove. what srr yih talking about?
and no, Guo deserves a suspension and will receive one, probably about 5 games.
for arguments sake, had he collapsed Hayes trachea, I'd assume that his suspension would be longer, (and could be facing charges off the ice).
Otto
Lynch Syndrome. Know your families cancer history
You didn't answer my question. How are you going to prove it? Say the incident happens on a Friday? You going to send a league mandated doctor to investigate? Good luck.
Conkys can be tough as symptoms can vary greatly. Even for those that get the premium medical access.
Yes Guo def. should be out a handful or more games based on the video I saw posted somewhere here. Definitely a brain cramp moment. Hopefully the other player is ok.
And what if ya get the LVK.TBL doctors, they can seemingly play the game
Or its just a huge coincidence the stars align and long term injuries magically go away once the POs starts. Bad look for cap circumvention. I know that's not exactly tky the same but it is doc's okay ing it. Basing the length of a suspension on injuries leaves too much wiggle room fircteams to play a game.
And what if a team doc and league doc disagree? Another huge can of worms.
But yes I think theckeague needs more consistency in applying justice.
HockeyPops
Registered User
- Aug 20, 2018
- 7,947
- 7,081
I'm just going to throw this out there, I don't think the Hounds have been outplayed to this point in the series.
Not seeing a game this series.........seems even up
(I get what your saying lol and a coupke others I talked to leaned towards SSM carrying play more often but it's a results oriented game)
Results wise it's been back n forth. SSM just has to find a way to win a couple in a row. Saginaw doesn't.
I'd lean SSM based on reg season n alleged injuries but I wouldn't make a bet.
Enjoy the game. Both sides fans will be on pins n needles ( hopefully for an entire game 7 that goes down to the wire )
HockeyPops
Registered User
- Aug 20, 2018
- 7,947
- 7,081
any doctor will do. an MD isn't going to risk their medical license to facilitate a hockey suspension.
- Status
