Value of: Soon to be Ex-Blackhawks

[Pertti]

The longer they hold on to him the better the chances are. But the team trading for him may add conditions based upon games played in the playoffs and getting to the 2nd round

Considering Murphy's injury history this probably won't work.

 

[Blackhawkswincup]

How about something around Jokiharju and Murphy without retention.

While I like Joker, and it was mistake to trade him but I doubt Hawks would have interest in 25 yr old defender (Turns 26 in offseason) who reaches UFA this summer

Will require extension and sizeable $ to keep him around and its pretty likely Joker tests UFA (As a young RHD he would be foolish not too) rather than sign extension with any team that trades for him

 

[Jared Dunn]

The only RD that are likely to be available imo are Andersson who Calgary may re-sign, Savard, Ceci, Jokiharju and maybe Borgen again so could see Murphy @50 returning a 1st just based off of that.

Hall @50 for a 2nd or 3rd. I feel like they'll get late 4th/5th/6ths for Maroon, Smith, Martinez. Wonder if they re-sign Donato if the return is just a 2nd/3rd

 

[MB3]

look at what Toffoli brought back last year in a depressed market. Hall is worth a little less than that; so — maybe a 2nd on his own, if retained?

 

[qc14]

They will actually. It happens almost every trade deadline. Teams will overpay for these type of players.

While I agree with you in principle Hall doesn't have the grit/leadership/winner/center factor that it usually takes. I think he becomes the latest in a long line of scoring middle 6 wingers that get a 2nd.

 

[Mrfenn92]

If the hawks can get a second for Taylor they’ll be ecstatic

 

[Petes2424]

Good bet Alec Martinez ends up on a contender, and Murphy is always intriguing. He just always seems to survive in Chicago.

 

[Uberpecker]

While I like Joker, and it was mistake to trade him but I doubt Hawks would have interest in 25 yr old defender (Turns 26 in offseason) who reaches UFA this summer

Will require extension and sizeable $ to keep him around and its pretty likely Joker tests UFA (As a young RHD he would be foolish not too) rather than sign extension with any team that trades for him

Fair enough, that makes sense, I kinda forgot he was going to be UFA already, thought of him as a future RFA.
Anyway, Murphy without retention to Sabres. What would be a reasonable proposal?

 

[DJN21]

Foligno for Joker....go

 

[Blackhawkswincup]

Foligno for Joker....go

Best I can do is TJ Brodie for Joker...

 

[DJN21]

Best I can do is TJ Brodie for Joker...

best I can do is Terry Pegula provides an ice cream truck from 10am until 11am.....

 

[Mrfenn92]

best I can do is Terry Pegula provides an ice cream truck from 10am until 11am.....

Sold

 

[DJN21]

Sold

man we should be GMs.....

 

[Mrfenn92]

man we should be GMs.....

Better then what we have

 

[TheNumber4]

If Hall keeps up his form and hits around 45/50 pts, he could possibly get Hawks a 1st rounder, especially at 50% retain.

But why would Hawks pay a 3rd + Hall at 50% just to get a 2nd?

Cause a turning a 3rd into a 2nd is better than f*** all?

Ultimately, Hall will get moved. And the Hawks would be dumb not to get some value over nothing. Whatever that value will be depends on Hall's performance. No way is that performance near a 1st right now btw.

Henrique did return just that.

Henrique is a Center. Much higher value than Wingers. The comparison makes no sense.

 

[hawksrule]

Murphy 50% retained would possibly bring 1st but not many current playoff teams have one. Hall would probably get a 2nd. Only 8 teams currently in the playoffs have a 1st rounder unless Calgary (1st team out) wants to use one of its two late 1sts.

Alec M. and C. Smith maybe a 4th. Even Donato might get moved.

Doesn’t have to be a 1st this year.

 

[Space umpire]

Cause a turning a 3rd into a 2nd is better than f*** all?

Ultimately, Hall will get moved. And the Hawks would be dumb not to get some value over nothing. Whatever that value will be depends on Hall's performance. No way is that performance near a 1st right now btw.


Henrique is a Center. Much higher value than Wingers. The comparison makes no sense.

Did you even read what you wrote before you posted it?
Do you really think Hall at 50% retained is only worth moving up from pick 65 to pick 55-64?
I’m sure to the uneducated mind using terms like “turning a 3rd into a 2nd” appears valuable but the educated among us realizes you are referencing a maximum 8 to 10 slot gain and possibly as little as 1 slot.

To use your term … that is f*** all.

The player himself holds value.
The retention amount holds value.
The retention slot itself holds value.
You may be new but a team giving all 3 is getting more than the tiny bump you propose, which is not very high in the draft.

If you proposed Chicago moving pick 33 with Hall for pick 23 them maybe you have something workable but again ANYONE who follows the game knows that because the deeper into a draft you get the greater variation there is within each team’s prospect evaluation. Moving a few slots that far into the draft has little/no value. … or as you put it, f*** ALL.

 

[TheNumber4]

Did you even read what you wrote before you posted it?
Do you really think Hall at 50% retained is only worth moving up from pick 65 to pick 55-64?
I’m sure to the uneducated mind using terms like “turning a 3rd into a 2nd” appears valuable but the educated among us realizes you are referencing a maximum 8 to 10 slot gain and possibly as little as 1 slot.

To use your term … that is f*** all.

The player himself holds value.
The retention amount holds value.
The retention slot itself holds value.
You may be new but a team giving all 3 is getting more than the tiny bump you propose, which is not very high in the draft.

If you proposed Chicago moving pick 33 with Hall for pick 23 them maybe you have something workable but again ANYONE who follows the game knows that because the deeper into a draft you get the greater variation there is within each team’s prospect evaluation. Moving a few slots that far into the draft has little/no value. … or as you put it, f*** ALL.

Did you even read what I wrote?

Something is better than nothing. And nothing is what you are looking at with pending UFA.

I’m NOT saying Halls value is a 2nd to 3rd swap though. Which you’ve focused on in your reply.

Like I said in my post, his performance will determine what he gets. Maybe that’s a 2nd all by itself. Maybe it’s as low a 5th round pick. It will depend on how Hall plays out this season, and WHATEVER that value ends up being, you take that over NOTHING.

 

[SPV]

I’d like Murphy on the Bruins, especially at 50%. Maybe would allow us to ship on Carlo in a separate deal for a young forward

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

Hall gets a second at most, he doesn't have the playoff pedigree to carry his value to a 1st.

His playoff numbers are pretty good. And playoff pedigree means nothing. A bum like Goodrow got a 1st and he was shit in the playoffs before that.

 

[canuckslover10]

His playoff numbers are pretty good. And playoff pedigree means nothing. A bum like Goodrow got a 1st and he was shit in the playoffs before that.

Pedigree means something to NHL GMs when they are trading for veteran players at the TDL, Hall doesn't have the stats currently to get him a 1st and nor has he gone deep enough in the playoffs to garner playoff pedigree.