You go with three A's.
The captaincy for this org isn't a light matter. Brad Richards, MSL... those were really good veteran leaders. The Rangers need a guy like that.
I love Zucc, but he's not the guy imo. Neither is Staal. Zucc due to how friendly and likeable he is, doesn't strike me as a guy that will come down on his teammates and hold them accountable.
Staal too casual. You need a guy that is either a very respected veteran, or a guy that can't stand losing with every inch in his body.
I always thought Ryan McD got the captaincy because some of the other guys didn't want it. Looking at Nash in particular. McD was not a good captain imo. Good guy, but not all good guys make good captains.