Simon Edvinsson
- Thread starter Dtybur
- Start date
Pavels Dog
Registered User
Absolutely still see elite #1D potential in him.
Yeah, he has tons of potential. No doubt in my mind he becomes a top pair 22+ minute/game D in the NHL. His offensive ceiling remains to be seen, but he'll log big minutes in the NHL for sure.
JohanFranzenstein
Registered User
- Dec 6, 2013
- 2,630
- 3,163
Lil Sebastian Cossa
Opinions are share are my own personal opinions.
- Jul 6, 2012
- 11,436
- 7,448
Has something happened with him that should change what people think his ceiling is? I haven't heard anything in particular about him. So if you think he was really good, you should still think that.
HisNoodliness
Good things come to those who wait
I think it's a few things working in concert. Firstly, I just think that there's impatience for huge numbers and consistent offensive dominance from any top pick. It's unfair and frankly, Edvinsson is doing really well so it shouldn't be effecting him much, but that always contributes.
Secondly, I think that there's a sort of identity crisis with him and the fans. I was super bullish on Edvinsson in his draft year not because of the Hedman-esque puck rushes, but because of the way his skating and size let him totally lock down a defensive zone. At the time, he was prone to defensive mental mistakes-chasing people out of position and getting caught in no man's land- and thus in the public discourse got labeled as an offensive defenseman. Sometimes he does play with a lot of risk and carries the puck up ice all the time, but as he's developed, he's been playing a more mature game. If you go into watching just a few games expecting him to rush it all the time and he's playing more responsibly, he doesn't jump off the ice with the same pop.
But his defensive game is getting really good to compensate and he really did used to play with too much risk. I think he's still figuring out how to pick his spots for rushes. He either overdoes it, or plays too safe. I'm not worried about this though, but I can see how someone who watched highlights from his draft year and caught 3 games this year might feel like he's not developing how he should. We're trying to develop him into a true two-way, full ice impact D and I think depending on what he's focusing on improving at any particular time, you can get fairly different viewings.
I also think that his offensive skills haven't developed much more pop though. He passes, shoots and stick handles well, but he's not a highlight machine and I don't think that's where he's focusing on improving. He's making steady progress in all of these areas, but besides his skating, his offensive game is a little understated. Someone expecting Dahlin or Q Hughes might find him to be disappointing as a result, but I think that they're missing just how globally dominant he's becoming.
SoupNazi
Gee Wally/SoupNazi 2024
- Feb 6, 2010
- 27,100
- 17,249
I think it's the fact that he hasn't been called up that has people questioning. I don't think that's justified because we aren't into the "overripe" territory, but I'm assuming that's why people are asking.
RED WINGS STOMP
Registered User
- Nov 28, 2022
- 1,264
- 1,686
My question would be how they work him into the lineup next year. Who does he pair with? Hronek might make the most sense. But that would require the team to do something they have been totally reluctant to do this year, put Chiarot on third pair and shelter his minutes.
Also, the call up isn't happening until end of year. The point in calling him up now when if they wait a little longer and slide his ELC a year.
Also, the call up isn't happening until end of year. The point in calling him up now when if they wait a little longer and slide his ELC a year.
KasperTheGrittyGhost
Registered User
Depends on what you want from him. I see Simon more in the mold of Slavin, Ekholm, Lindholm than some of the more offensive players he was compared to in his draft year.
Pavels Dog
Registered User
The theory that's been floated a bit is moving Chiarot to the right side and playing him on a 3rd pairing with Edvinsson.
As for the ELC sometimes it makes sense to burn a year, it could be beneficial for getting that 2nd contract cheaper.
Frk It
Mo Seider Less Problems
- Jul 27, 2010
- 36,892
- 15,813
I'm just as optimistic about him as I have been, personally.
He is .5 PPG on a team that is bottom 5 in the AHL in goals. He has been consistently .5 PPG over the last 2 years in 2 different pro leagues. I think he has continued to show he is a very effective puck mover while working on his defense.
Looking forward to see him play in Detroit whenever that ends up being.
norrisnick
The best...
- Apr 14, 2005
- 31,284
- 16,669
Floor is post-Florida Bouwmeester. Ceiling is Hedman.
Either and anything between is huge for the Wings moving forward.
Either and anything between is huge for the Wings moving forward.
Last edited:
Pavels Dog
Registered User
Floor is Brett Lebda with hands. Ceiling is Hedman with better flow.
RED WINGS STOMP
Registered User
- Nov 28, 2022
- 1,264
- 1,686
Really? After the disaster that was Seider Chiarot, they want to try wrecking another big time youngster by playing him with Chiarot? And with Chiarot on his off hand no less? Plus, I thought one of the reasons they kept Simon down this year was they want him in a top 4 role?
I get the idea behind the ELC burn, but I wouldn't do it.
Detroit Knights
Registered User
- Feb 29, 2012
- 3,602
- 2,105
I would say he comes in for 1 or 2 games at the end of the season. Maybe just hit his 8 games so it doesn't burn a contract year if that is still a thing.
Just to see where he is at and gauge for next year possible starting rotation.
Number1RedWingsFan52
Registered User
For 9 games after the trade deadline Yes, Not like Grand Rapids is going anywhere this year.
lilidk
Registered User
- Mar 4, 2008
- 11,059
- 4,283
I don't think he's quite the prospect that Seider was, but he still looks like a top pairing defenseman in the future and a top prospect throughout the NHL.
I'm hoping he'll play in the top 4 next year with Hronek and Walman will re-sign and Seider will play with Walman on the top pairing. They can't ruin his year by playing him with Chiarot. I'm hoping the Wings are smart enough to learn from that after Chiarot's play this season and he'll likely only get worse.
The other scenario is maybe they re-sign Pysyk after missing the season or sign someone similar and pair said player on the 3rd pairing with Edvinsson and start him off with more sheltered minutes.
I'm hoping he'll play in the top 4 next year with Hronek and Walman will re-sign and Seider will play with Walman on the top pairing. They can't ruin his year by playing him with Chiarot. I'm hoping the Wings are smart enough to learn from that after Chiarot's play this season and he'll likely only get worse.
The other scenario is maybe they re-sign Pysyk after missing the season or sign someone similar and pair said player on the 3rd pairing with Edvinsson and start him off with more sheltered minutes.
lilidk
Registered User
- Mar 4, 2008
- 11,059
- 4,283
I wonder if Yzerman think that Chiarot signing was a mistake and he will trade him for little return?
Henkka
Registered User
Think Chiarot could work on his off-side, because it seemed many times guy positioning himself too far right as a left defenceman.
Not sure about that... 23 teams will get to AHL playoffs.
Pavels Dog
Registered User
No solution is perfect.
Top pair with Seider? Toughest matchups, and two very young d-men with eachother.
2nd pair with Hronek, who can be a mess defensively at times?
Who knows, it also depends on whether Määttä sticks around or not.
OgeeOgelthorpe
Riccis per 60 record holder
- Feb 29, 2020
- 18,259
- 19,953
Sign Luke Schenn in the off-season and pair him with Ed. Trade Hronek for a 1st, then sign Dumba.
Win win win.
Gniwder
Registered User
Funny, I said the same about Hronek and Oesterle. They all seem to think they can use their stick to prevent getting beat on the outside, and the top tier players can just skate through a weak poke check.Think Chiarot could work on his off-side, because it seemed many times guy positioning himself too far right as a left defenceman.
Chiarot has played on the right side before, and logged big minutes in Montreal.
What's with the loaded language? Who did he wreck? Seider and him didn't play well together and now Seider is playing with playing with a more symbiotic partner and doing fine. He wasn't wrecked. Some players just don't have chemistry.
