Watching Weber, along with Petry, Eddie and Chariot play big boy hockey in our own end and grind almost every opponent into submission in the SCF run (before they too got worn down) is an immortal memory.
Shea Weber Hockey Hall of Fame
- Thread starter waitin425
- Start date
-
We sincerely apologize for the extended downtime. Our hosting provider, XenForo Cloud, encountered a major issue with their backup system, which unfortunately resulted in the loss of some critical data from the past year.
What This Means for You:
- If you created an account after March 2024, it no longer exists. You will need to sign up again to access the forum.
- If you registered before March 2024 but changed your email, username, or password in the past year, those changes were lost. You’ll need to update your account details manually once you're logged in.
- Threads and posts created within the last year have been restored.
- Our 2025 light and dark themes were lost, so we are rebuilding them. Light theme is currently available, but work in progress
Our team is working with Xenforo Cloud to recover data using backups, sitemaps, and other available resources. We know this is frustrating, and we deeply regret the impact on our community. We are taking steps with Xenforo Cloud to ensure this never happens again. This is work in progress. Thank you for your patience and support as we work through this.
In the meantime, feel free to join our Discord Server
You mean leak chances like crazy and get bailed out by Price? Lol. Weber wasn't bad but he wasn't playing his usual quality even in the POs.
I feel like there is a lot of revisionist history.
The way Weber played in that run was not at all the way he played during his tenure here. He was entirely disappointing and unmemorable. Hell even in that run he looked awful in the leafs series.
The way Weber played in that run was not at all the way he played during his tenure here. He was entirely disappointing and unmemorable. Hell even in that run he looked awful in the leafs series.
He wasn’t all that great in any playoff games as far as I remember. That’s okay though he was pretty banged up in that final run. He did what he could.
I'd say he was clearly the best D we had but he was probably closer to 2nd pair than Shea Weber.
It was all Carey.
He really gutted it out but yes, Weber wasn't the same in that final year. Defensively it was more subtle, but it was visible from an offensive standpoint.
I imagine it was quite inspirational for the club to see what price and weber were putting themselves through just to get ready for each game, not to mention the added mental component of the whole covid ordeal.
The way they huddled around an emotional Weber after the final buzzer, you knew something was up.
Wish we still had him. His teams were full of heart and work ethic. Things be different on Montreal Blueline.
We had our fair share of bottom of the league teams with Weber.
Zero Norris trophies and one of the most overrated players in league history. Was a very good player, for sure, but the stories told about this guy like he’s some sort of legend are comical to me. I’d take a prime Markov any day.
I was a big markov fan, but since you are using norris trophies as a metric in your post, I will say Weber was alot closer than markov.
He lost a couple close norris races, and one of them was closest race of all time where he barely got beat out by lidstrom.
He was a lock to play on the best on best Canadian teams among guys like Keith and doughty as well.
I don't use overrated and underrated terms because everyone is basing the benchmark on their own perceptions, but it should not be a controversial take to say thay he was an excellent dman in his era.
Weber's a legit HOFer, that's why he's going in first ballot. Maybe a little overrated in the sense that he wasn't really mobile or great with puck control. But he did some things very, very well. That shot lands him in elite company for goals by a blueliner. And he was really good at clearing the crease. Strong in his own zone without the puck. 5 times top five in Norris and runner up twice. 16th all time in goals. No brainer.
I've spoken about Markov before, not a HOFer. Hall of the very good. Funny but he's the opposite coin of Weber. Everything Weber was excellent at Markov wasn't great. But Markov had vision like few bluelieners and his passing was spectacular. He wasn't a rushing blueliner either but great vision. Much better than Weber in that respect.
Sidenote: Price should go in next year but unfortunately it's a really crowded field. Chara, Getzlaff, Thornton, Price and Keith. Rask is also eligible. Only four get in. Really tough year... he may have to wait. Getzlaf is probably his best shot. Price has better Hart placements but a shorter career. Getlaf has a cup... only three seasons in top ten points.
Last edited:
I’m
I don’t think Markov should be in either, but I think a prime markov impacts the ice in more ways than Weber and has a greater impact on a teams results.
We had Cup Finals also.
Took terrible team to Cup Finals also. On pure leadership. Those were bad teams he was on
Cup Final. Singular.
Carey Price did almost everything. Weber was rather pedestrian in his final season with the Habs.
I'd take Weber over pretty much any Canadien the past 30 years aside from Price.
Can't even imagine how much better the Habs would have been with a prime Weber, a Weber that wasn't broken.
Such a shame he and Price had Bergevin as a GM who, as everyone knows was rather in ept.
Can't even imagine how much better the Habs would have been with a prime Weber, a Weber that wasn't broken.
Such a shame he and Price had Bergevin as a GM who, as everyone knows was rather in ept.
Habs were dead meat in Toronto, before Weber stood up and called that meeting before Game 5. Habs were down 3-1. That's with your immortal Carry Price. Wasn't Price that did it. It was great leadership.
Nobody on here gave us a chance until then.
“Your immortal Carey Price”
I’m referring to hockey as it is played on ice. You’re talking about motivational speeches like he’s Tony Robbins
- 10x top 10 finaliste for the Norris (Only Chara and Lindstrom did that in 2000’s
- top 20 for goals from Dmen
- nominate multiple times as the toughest Dmen to face by other NHL players
- 2x Gold medal at the Olympic (1 where he was on the all star team and the other one where he was the #1 D)
- 1 gold at the World Cup
- Gold medal at the WJC + WC
- Memorial Cup
- One of the most respected player of his era
He totally deserve to be in the HOF
Some critics his plays with MTL but don’t forget that he got freaking Victor Mete, Alexei Emelin, Jordon Benn and Ben Chiarot as partner
- top 20 for goals from Dmen
- nominate multiple times as the toughest Dmen to face by other NHL players
- 2x Gold medal at the Olympic (1 where he was on the all star team and the other one where he was the #1 D)
- 1 gold at the World Cup
- Gold medal at the WJC + WC
- Memorial Cup
- One of the most respected player of his era
He totally deserve to be in the HOF
Some critics his plays with MTL but don’t forget that he got freaking Victor Mete, Alexei Emelin, Jordon Benn and Ben Chiarot as partner
Last edited:
