Of course! Who hasn't? Great to visit...awful to live in. That's my opinion.
Of course the cities are very different for the reasons mentioned. Population density...surrounding population...city landsize.... All these play a huge roll that has nothing to do with culture and lifestyle and regulations.
I worked in the mall for 16 years. I know for a fact that box stores came to Orleans and the mall still thrived...what killed the mall is online shopping. You can say what you want about anchor tenants, and losing them does have an affect, but nowhere as much as online shopping.
Place dorleans filled their anchor tenants...still had the bay...had GoodLife...had sportchek...still dead..why? Online sales.
The point is quite clear that having a bunch of specialty little stores all within walking distance all reachable by public transit is NOT a winning recipe...or else malls would be thriving.
The tax loopholes from the video are interesting, but not substantiated...we have no evidence that that is actually happening here. Their examples were all a small town getting a Wal Mart...well, what about a city of 2 million getting 6 Wal marts spread out...they didn't really explain that or how it might be good to have options of big box stores and smaller stores...which ones do better and why? What's the solution?
You mention the Glebe as walkable...my gf lived there. It was convenient in some ways, yes, but also a pain in many other ways...
Was nice to wake up and walk to kettlemans bagels and enjoy a breakfast...but was also a pain in the ass to get many things....need supplies at a Canadian Tire/home Depot...well, good luck. Nothing in the downtown core. Wanted some cheap cereal. Wal Mart always has a 3 boxes for $9...but the local store was selling boxes for like $7-8 each...instead of $3.33...said f*** that and didn't get cereal.
They lack a lot of options. Grocery shopping at the metro Glebe is like shopping for groceries at a 7-11...no options...
Walkable cities are trash BECAUSE they lack options, in my opinion.
I would rather be able to own land with a pool and hot tub and patio and have a multi car garage and drive 5 mins down the road in my FUN car to get anything I need...rather than have to live in a tiny place sharing walls with neighbours, have to walk, have to pay more for everything, and lack a lot of options. That sounds fun for a one week trip, but sounds awful for many others.
Like I said, my gf lived right near bank street and she is much happier living in Orleans with a car and able to drive wherever she wants than living in the Glebe without a car having to walk or bus or be out of luck to go somewhere.
It's not even close.
I've visited many people who live in central apartments where you're walking distance from all the store and downtown...cool for a 22 year old...complete nightmare for someone raising a family.
Where I live, I can easily have 10 of my closest couples over for a nice big dinner party. Everyone can get ther easily and park for free...there's space of having many different rooms so you're not claustrophobic in some tiny apartment kitchen or dining room.