I'm 100% confident both Lou and Trotz would prefer to bring Cizikas back over Palms. He is the "identity" after all. Not to mention Palms was pretty underwhelming(not bad, just not great), will make more than Cizikas, and can be replaced in theory by Wahlstrom. Who replaces Cizikas? Koivula? That's trial by fire considering that line's responsibilities.
I think if more term keeps the cap-hit down I'm all for it. 4 years isn't ideal but $1.5M for Martin is about as good as it gets IMO. If 4 years for Cizikas keeps his hit at or under $3M then I think you do it.
I'd argue that he's been eased into the league at this point, and I'd hope he has made new friends. Plus part of me is hoping that we can trade Varly(for a good return of course) and bring in Lundqvist to be the new backup, just so I can rock a Henrik-Isles sweater in front of my Rag-fan friends.