F A N
Registered User
- Aug 12, 2005
- 19,661
- 6,465
IIRC, he didn't beat out a single player who had an NHL season under their belt. He was good in camp, and his first season was arguably his best as a Canuck (which is kind of a red flag), but long term it likely didn't help his development very much to go straight to the NHL to play bad hockey in a bad environment.
We have a different recollection. Hutton was a standout at camp/preseason and was clearly one of the top 6 defenseman. There was a lot of hype/excitement surrounding his performance. This really isn't up for debate.
Looking back, Hutton played in the season opener logging over 17 minutes. He went on to play 75 games logging over 19 minutes and leading all Canucks Dmen in points (granted Edler didn't play a full season). Again, the guy was 22 years old, physically developed, and was clearly NHL ready based on his rookie performance. And this was a team with Edler, Hamhuis, and Tanev on the backend to help guide the young player. The guy has never played a single AHL game since. If you believe that Hutton was better off developing under Green in the minors you are free to do so.