Prospect Info: San Jose Sharks #4 Prospect

[Lebanezer]

You know the drill. Age cutoff 25, NHL games played cutoff 40. Poll will close after 2 days unless the results are incredibly lopsided.

1. Macklin Celebrini ~95%
2. Will Smith ~90%
3. Sam Dickinson ~95%

Click to read more...

 

[one2gamble]

I want to say musty but I think I am going with Shak this time. Musty needs to prove that he can perform like that outside of juniors and that it wasnt a one off.

 

[CHALUPA]

Went with Musty for his upside, but I like Mukh’s floor. Could have gone either way with this one.

 

[TheBeard]

I actually took Edstrom. I think what he does has a greater path to the NHL as the 3C. Musty and Halt I'm hesitant until it's above OHL.

 

[ChompChomp]

I'm the lone Chern vote. I think of who is in development now with the Sharks, he's got the most upside and potential after Celebrini, Smith and Dickinson.

 

[timorous me]

Went with Musty for his upside, but I like Mukh’s floor. Could have gone either way with this one.

I really like Musty but I decided to go with Mukhamadullin as well. I think he showed enough last season to make it pretty clear to me that he's a top-four defenseman in the future and I would be happy to see him get a shot to prove that on a regular basis this year.

Musty is in a tough situation in terms of where he plays and how he'll develop this coming season, but I'm still very excited by him and have big-time hopes for his future. This is more just wanting to give Shak some love since I think he won't get as much as he should (he's not home-grown and he's not as exciting of a prospect).

 

[gaucholoco3]

I went with Muk even though I think Musty has the higher raw ceiling.

I think Musty can be a Guentzel (90-100 point 1st line wing) where as Muk’s ceiling is a high end #3.

 

[llamanby]

Muk is a NHLer this year and been playing against men for 4-5 years.

Musty is the exciting flashy junior player that will be in juniors again. Doesnt have the pedigree of someone like Dickinson so he gets bumped by Muk.

Give me the solid 2nd pair dman over the winger who has a huge range of possible outcomes.

 

[DG93]

Шакир Маратович Мухамадуллин

 

[StrawHatEklund]

It’s Muk until Musty proves otherwise. Will have to wait on Chernyshov to see how he performs the next 2 years.

 

[landshark]

I'm the lone Chern vote. I think of who is in development now with the Sharks, he's got the most upside and potential after Celebrini, Smith and Dickinson.

I Chern'd also. I think this guy has "it"

 

[gaucholoco3]

So close. Musty is only 2 votes ahead.

 

[PacificOceanPotion]

Muk

 

[OrrNumber4]

Think we need a tiebreaker for this (and the loser is automatically #5)

 

[landshark]

Think we need a tiebreaker for this (and the loser is automatically #5)

Could maybe @Kcoyote3 or @Sheng Peng please get them to maybe rock-paper-scissors for HFBoardsSJS Prospect#4 spot at some upcoming media availability?

 

[Juxtaposer]

I’ve listed Musty higher on my lists recently but I decided to go with Mukhamadullin on this one. More valuable position, significantly less risk even though I do love Musty and think his ceiling is sky-high.

 

[Jargon]

Muhk played a bit in the NHL and had a good year in the AHL - he’s likely winning a spot next year and is much further along than most of our prospects. I think his “everything goes right” ceiling is a #2, which I think makes him the winner here.

 

[Patty Ice]

I’ve listed Musty higher on my lists recently but I decided to go with Mukhamadullin on this one. More valuable position, significantly less risk even though I do love Musty and think his ceiling is sky-high.

 

[pappaf2]

Maybe they just split and are each 4.5

 

[sharks_dynasty]

Muk is closer to being NHL ready and has top 4 potential. Musty also has top 6 potential and can be a potential game breaker. He also had an insane junior season. For that reason, I went with Musty.

 

[Skeksis25]

I voted for Mukh because I feel that we need Mukh to pan out a lot more than we do Musty.

 

[67 others]

Another vote for Musty

 

[Stewie Griffin]

Musty
Muhkamadulin
Chernyshov
Bystedt
Edstrom
Haltunnen
Sahlin-Wallenius/Cagnoni as #10

 

[gaucholoco3]

Musty is starting to pull away. 9 vote lead now.

 

[Juxtaposer]

If Musty wins this, I say just give it to him. There aren’t really enough non-Musty/Mukh votes to warrant a tiebreaker.