I dunno, I thought he was a fun listen on MSG. He was entertaining & insightful, plus for a kid like me who was just learning the subtleties of the sport, he taught me a lot about the game. I really liked his Espo on Ice segments during the intermissions.
Plus he was an unabashed homer & his excitement was contagious. His last year in the MSG booth was 85-86 before he was named GM over the summer. 2nd round of the 86 playoffs Game 1 in Washington, game goes to OT where all over a sudden Phil SCREAMS over Sam "He's in!!!", before Brian MacLellan even took the pass for the breakaway that he scored on for the game winner. I will never forgot how fired up he was. As a 14 year old, Phil was alright by me.