monitoring_string = "358c248ada348a047a4b9bb27a146148"
Player Discussion - Sam Colangelo | Page 5 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League
  • Xenforo Cloud upgraded our forum to XenForo version 2.3.4. This update has created styling issues to our current templates, this is just a temporary look. We will continue to work on clearing up these issues for the next few days and restore the site to it's more familiar look, but please report any other issues you may experience so we can look into. Thanks for your patience and understanding.

Player Discussion Sam Colangelo

Honestly not bothered whether he signs an ELC or not, if he signs then great, if not oh well. At best he's a 3rd line physical power forward but they've got tons of other prospects who will be competing for future 3rd line roles(Nesterenko, Pastujov, Sidorov, Gaucher, Miyatovic, Pitre, Hvidston, Mysap, King etc) because its pretty much set that Carlsson, McTavish, Cutter, Terry, Zegras are in the top6 and the last spot in top6 could be the 2024 1st round pick if it's Lindstrom, Demigod, Helenius or Celebrini but most likely they draft a Dman.
 
Anaheim4ever said:
Honestly not bothered whether he signs an ELC or not, if he signs then great, if not oh well. At best he's a 3rd line physical power forward but they've got tons of other prospects who will be competing for future 3rd line roles(Nesterenko, Pastujov, Sidorov, Gaucher, Miyatovic, Pitre, Hvidston, Mysap, King etc) because its pretty much set that Carlsson, McTavish, Cutter, Terry, Zegras are in the top6 and the last spot in top6 could be the 2024 1st round pick if it's Lindstrom, Demigod, Helenius or Celebrini but most likely they draft a Dman.
Click to expand...

If our early first round pick isn't used on a forward, then we have a potential top-6 RW spot available.
Verbeek said that Gaucher is a couple of years away from the NHL at the Migration event. (around 36:02 on the video at Youtube). Except for King, all of the other forwards aren't physically wide like Colangelo, who is 6'2 and 209 lbs.

Colangelo scored 24 goals, 7th overall in the NCAA. Goal scorers are difficult to find and if he's a 3rd line, scoring PF, then that helps improve our scoring in the bottom-6.

Oh... Colangelo notched his first goal in the AHL just now. He's further advanced in his development than most of our forward prospects. If our forward prospects were good, then Verbeek wouldn't have traded for Cutter. We can use all the help we can get, especially with a right-hand shooting forward.
 
I certainly hope he is signed, but I am not holding out hope lol. Certainly can foresee it being another Thrun/Schultz situation.
 
Maybe its to give him a chance to prove himself to then play a game for the Ducks to burn a year?
 
Rasp said:
Maybe its to give him a chance to prove himself to then play a game for the Ducks to burn a year?
Click to expand...

Seems like playing with fire to me. Verbeek signed Nesterenko to burn off a year last season, and Nesterenko didn't perform well in his last year in college like Colangelo did.

Last year in college:
Nesterenko: 36 games, 13g + 21a = 34 pts, and +6 rating
Colangelo: 38 games, 24g + 19a = 43 pts, and +19 rating

Don't pull a damned Flyers move, Verbeek. Make Colangelo officially part of the org yesterday.
 
Hockey Duckie said:
Seems like playing with fire to me. Verbeek signed Nesterenko to burn off a year last season, and Nesterenko didn't perform well in his last year in college like Colangelo did.

Last year in college:
Nesterenko: 36 games, 13g + 21a = 34 pts, and +6 rating
Colangelo: 38 games, 24g + 19a = 43 pts, and +19 rating

Don't pull a damned Flyers move, Verbeek. Make Colangelo officially part of the org yesterday.
Click to expand...
I think its different because we traded for Nesterenkos rights which could have been a stipulation before the trade. Either way it would be nice to get some clarity from Verbeek
 
Regarding Colangelo's try out:

I dont think it would be good for Verbeek to come out publicly about it now. Either come out openly about it from the start or don't talk about it. Don't rock the boat when things are already in motion.

It could just as well be about Colangelo wanting a feel of the Gulls/Ducks as much as the opposite. The speculation will be shortlived anyway.
 
Well he is off to a good start.

Does make me curious. Whether this was a Verbeek decision or from Sam’s camp. Wouldn’t he just come out and say he was not signing like Thrun did?

Rather give him a shot in the bottom 6 than to ice the current bottom 6, which i expect a lot of them will be gone next season.
 
I would be shocked if this is some sort of tryout. He is much better than many guys we sign to ELC’s. I think it’s either a structure agreed to by ducks and colangelo’s camp to defer signing of ELC or it is him that has not decided (or decided to go somewhere else)
 
Well, if this is a game of poker between PV and Colangelo then the latter just bet and raised.

The lack of transparency from both sides regarding the "plan" for Colangelo is a little troubling and suggests that things are not quite as straight forward as everyone hoped they would be in signing him.
 
tomd said:
Well, if this is a game of poker between PV and Colangelo then the latter just bet and raised.

The lack of transparency from both sides regarding the "plan" for Colangelo is a little troubling and suggests that things are not quite as straight forward as everyone hoped they would be in signing him.
Click to expand...
Just because there is a lack of transparency to the public doesn’t mean there is any to each of the parties who actually matter.

My personal theory is similar to what @Rasp mentioned. I think both sides have agreed that an ELC will be signed, but Verbeek wants it to start next season while Colangelo wants to burn this season. So maybe the PTO was a middle ground that gives Colangelo a chance to earn that burned year while there is still a couple weeks left in the season.
 
duxfan1101 said:
Just because there is a lack of transparency to the public doesn’t mean there is any to each of the parties who actually matter.

My personal theory is similar to what @Rasp mentioned. I think both sides have agreed that an ELC will be signed, but Verbeek wants it to start next season while Colangelo wants to burn this season. So maybe the PTO was a middle ground that gives Colangelo a chance to earn that burned year while there is still a couple weeks left in the season.
Click to expand...
Well I certainly agree with that but I just don't see the point of it. This is hockey not national security.
 
Yea, we don't need any more speculation about the matter but in general, while transparency is great and often the best policy: sometimes you are in a situation where the other party would happily take a worse position and you would take advantage of that. But when you are totally transparent you don't get to take any advantages because the public opinion would be that of; you take advantage of the other party and be frowned upon.
 
duxfan1101 said:
Just because there is a lack of transparency to the public doesn’t mean there is any to each of the parties who actually matter.

My personal theory is similar to what @Rasp mentioned. I think both sides have agreed that an ELC will be signed, but Verbeek wants it to start next season while Colangelo wants to burn this season. So maybe the PTO was a middle ground that gives Colangelo a chance to earn that burned year while there is still a couple weeks left in the season.
Click to expand...

Again, that's playing with fire as it's similar to the Philly situation. What if Colangelo plays well and thinks being put through this test is stupid that he'd rater eat the year and go somewhere else where he won't be toyed around with.
 
I don't think the transparency thing is a big deal in this case. This board might be the only collection of ducks fans that's even aware this is odd, and we have one (?) writer who might catch it. A canadian market would be different, but not here.
 
Rasp said:
I think its different because we traded for Nesterenkos rights which could have been a stipulation before the trade. Either way it would be nice to get some clarity from Verbeek
Click to expand...

Nestrenko wasn't going to sign with his draft team b/c there was a log jam in front of him. That is what made it easy for us to acquire Nesterenko.

We didn't get clarity of Nesterenko's situation. Verbeek initially stated that we signed Nesterenko to a future contract ELC, but a later tweet changed that to a present contract ELC that burns a year off the contract. I think Nesterenko made Verbeek alter the deal b/c GM's don't make that huge of an official news blunder.
 
I wonder if this has something to do with Colangelo and his agent not wanting to start his arb/UFA clock right away. It makes sense for more highly touted prospects who figure to put up good numbers right away and thus getting to a better payday more quickly. But for someone like Colangelo, maybe they see it more to their benefit to have an extra season to establish his game.

Just throwing out a theory.
 
nbducksfan19 said:
I would be shocked if this is some sort of tryout. He is much better than many guys we sign to ELC’s. I think it’s either a structure agreed to by ducks and colangelo’s camp to defer signing of ELC or it is him that has not decided (or decided to go somewhere else)
Click to expand...

I thought this initially as well, but the more I think about it, the more I wonder why we would do him the favor of playing and boosting his stock if he's just going to sign somewhere else.

I guess you could say it's us boosting his trade stock, but also not sure we would risk him lowering it by playing poorly in the AHL or getting injured.

I'm leaning more towards some agreement to sign him after. Pat has proven himself to be weird about contracts.
 
Weird idea, but hear me out:

Maybe PV knows he will also sign some other player(s) in the off-season (*cough* Hvidston *cough*) and would get to the 50 contracts limit. He therefore lets Colangelo sign a PTO with the Gulls to get him accustomed to the franchise and gets some time to shed other contracts - as we know, Colangelo has until some time in August before he enters the market. We get Henrique (due to retention), Silfverberg and some other contracts off the books and will most likely sign our upcoming 1st round pick to an ELC immediately. So maybe, just maybe, PV is trying to make everything work out contract-limit wise before we finally get Colangelo to sign with us.
 
GermanRocket7 said:
Weird idea, but hear me out:

Maybe PV knows he will also sign some other player(s) in the off-season (*cough* Hvidston *cough*) and would get to the 50 contracts limit. He therefore lets Colangelo sign a PTO with the Gulls to get him accustomed to the franchise and gets some time to shed other contracts - as we know, Colangelo has until some time in August before he enters the market. We get Henrique (due to retention), Silfverberg and some other contracts off the books and will most likely sign our upcoming 1st round pick to an ELC immediately. So maybe, just maybe, PV is trying to make everything work out contract-limit wise before we finally get Colangelo to sign with us.
Click to expand...
Not weird at all. To me, this makes the most sense lol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top
-->->