Speculation: Sabres Roster Speculation - Pre-season 2023 Edition

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is a controversial argument. Each player has some idol and players they look up to, but this does not mean that we should trade for them. I do not think that the conditional Helle will be a mentor for Levi worse than Saros, the same goes for other goalies. I like Saros, but I won't trade for him at that price.
I totally get not wanting to give up that price. But for me, personally, Saros' game and how he plays coupled with the chances we let up I think is the ideal fit for us and is one of the few I'd be willing to bleed in a trade for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NotABadPeriod
I totally get not wanting to give up that price. But for me, personally, Saros' game and how he plays coupled with the chances we let up I think is the ideal fit for us and is one of the few I'd be willing to bleed in a trade for.
I partly agree, but not at this cost. I think even Ostlund/Rosen + #13 would be a very worthy offer, goaltenders don't usually get even that much, but I don't want to trade our two best attacking prospects.
 
Apparently Nashville fans want at least Kulich/Savoie + #13 for Saros. I wouldn't do it, I don't think Adams either.

Well, there are still some options.
If Adams is serious about adding a difference making #1 goalie this off season, then he is likely going to have to move something that he does not want to move.

I would rather pay a price that hurts for Saros than go UFA shopping or just running it back with Levi, UPL, and Comrie and hoping for the best.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NotABadPeriod
I partly agree, but not at this cost. I think even Ostlund/Rosen + #13 would be a very worthy offer, goaltenders don't usually get even that much, but I don't want to trade our two best attacking prospects.
What do you mean attacking prospects? Surely Savoie and Kulich would out rank those two offensively.
 
What do you mean attacking prospects? Surely Savoie and Kulich would out rank those two offensively.
I meant our best prospects. I do not trade Savoie/Kulich + #13 for goalie.

If Adams is serious about adding a difference making #1 goalie this off season, then he is likely going to have to move something that he does not want to move.

I would rather pay a price that hurts for Saros than go UFA shopping or just running it back with Levi, UPL, and Comrie and hoping for the best.
Goalies do not cost that much, especially those who are 1-2 years old from the UFA. You can just look at the history trades and there is nothing like this value, although there were trades of Andersen, Schneider and Raanta + Stepan.

I think we can get a good goalie for less than Kulich/Savoie + #13.
 

Buffalo Sabres​

Devon Levi needs a mentor and the Sabres need a solid starter as their young team continues its resurgence. Buffalo doesn’t seem that far off from being a playoff team annually again.

The folks in Buffalo this year couldn’t stop raving about Hellebuyck when he stopped 39 shots in a 4-2 win back in January, for what that’s worth.

A long-term deal may block Levi down the road, so there’s that risk for Buffalo.

Who should the Jets target?

Peyton Krebs.

Krebs is a solid up-and-coming centre that could solve a problem the Jets have down the middle if Dubois and Scheifele are gone (not to mention the lack of centre depth in Winnipeg’s prospect pool).

Krebs, goalie Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen and Matthew Savoie/Buffalo’s 13th overall pick at next month’s draft? The only thing with Savoie is the Jets have enough guys like him.

You could ask for defenceman Owen Power, but you’d likely hear a dial tone soon after.

The Winnipeg media have high hopes for a trade return for Hellebuyck.

Goalies do not cost that much, especially those who are 1-2 years old from the UFA. You can just look at the history trades and there is nothing like this value, although there were trades of Andersen, Schneider and Raanta + Stepan.

I think we can get a good goalie for less than Kulich/Savoie + #13.
Goalies like Saros rarely get dealt because they cost so much.

Saros is not going to move cheaply, like say MAF, because Nashville is not in cap jail.

Saros is not just a "good goalie" though. He is an elite Vezina-caliber #1 goalie. Those types do not move cheaply.
 



The Winnipeg media have high hopes for a trade return for Hellebuyck.
'You could ask for Owen Power, but you'd likely hear a dial tone soon after'

I love how they write likely as if there's even the slightest chance Buffalo would trade Power for a soon-to-be UFA goalie.

Krebs+13th or Savoie is laughable as well. C'mon, man!
 
Goalies like Saros rarely get dealt because they cost so much.

Saros is not going to move cheaply, like say MAF, because Nashville is not in cap jail.

Saros is not just a "good goalie" though. He is an elite Vezina-caliber #1 goalie. Those types do not move cheaply.
Helle is also an elite goalie and I think he will cost less. I gave an example that goalies usually don't cost that much if they don't want to trade Saros, that's another matter, there's no point in even trying, it would be very expensive.
 
'You could ask for Owen Power, but you'd likely hear a dial tone soon after'

I love how they write likely as if there's even the slightest chance Buffalo would trade Power for a soon-to-be UFA goalie.

Krebs+13th or Savoie is laughable as well. C'mon, man!
Classic homer article. I would offer 2nd UPL and Rosen. If they say no then good day.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: Irie and RefsIdeas



The Winnipeg media have high hopes for a trade return for Hellebuyck.


Goalies like Saros rarely get dealt because they cost so much.

Saros is not going to move cheaply, like say MAF, because Nashville is not in cap jail.

Saros is not just a "good goalie" though. He is an elite Vezina-caliber #1 goalie. Those types do not move cheaply.

WPG's media is definitely on some good drugs if they think they'll get anything close to that for a non-extended rental goalie.
 
I’d be all over Saros if he became available. But if you’re dropping 2 premium assets on Saros then there’s no half measures, you need that #4 dman as well. 2 years of Saros to be the first wild card in exchange for premium assets is not a great thing. Same goes for really any move.
 
Helle is also an elite goalie and I think he will cost less. I gave an example that goalies usually don't cost that much if they don't want to trade Saros, that's another matter, there's no point in even trying, it would be very expensive.
Hellebuyck is also under contract for only one season versus two for Saros.

I doubt the trade package would be markedly different between the two. And I would value that second year with Saros and I think he would be a better fit with the Sabres.

WPG's media is definitely on some good drugs if they think they'll get anything close to that for a non-extended rental goalie.
It will all depend on how many teams they get in the bidding for him. If they can get NJ, LAK, and Buffalo all interested in a deal, the price is going to go up.
 
Hellebuyck is also under contract for only one season versus two for Saros.

I doubt the trade package would be markedly different between the two. And I would value that second year with Saros and I think he would be a better fit with the Sabres.


It will all depend on how many teams they get in the bidding for him. If they can get NJ, LAK, and Buffalo all interested in a deal, the price is going to go up.
I think it will be different, that's the point. Again, look at the trades goalies and what they returned, and there were also very good goalies, with good stats. Chad said that the price of Helle would not be astronomical.

I have already said that I do not trade Savoie/Kulich + #13 for Saros, I see no reason to continue the dispute.
 
I think it will be different, that's the point. Again, look at the trades goalies and what they returned, and there were also very good goalies, with good stats. Chad said that the price of Helle would not be astronomical.

I have already said that I do not trade Savoie/Kulich + #13 for Saros, I see no reason to continue the dispute.
Show me a trade for a goalie who was traded before they turned 35 with a Vezina trophy and 2 or 3 top 5 Vezina voting finishes.

The last under 35yo goalie with a Vezina to get traded was when the Sabres traded Ryan Miller to St Louis at the trade deadline.


So, comparing Hellebuyck for lesser goalies is not likely to get you what he would cost in a trade.
 
Show me a trade for a goalie who was traded before they turned 35 with a Vezina trophy and 2 or 3 top 5 Vezina voting finishes.

The last under 35yo goalie with a Vezina to get traded was when the Sabres traded Ryan Miller to St Louis at the trade deadline.


So, comparing Hellebuyck for lesser goalies is not likely to get you what he would cost in a trade.
If one year for Helle costs too much, then I'll just move on to the next target. Just not sure if he's going to return a ton because term. It is clear that such goaliess are not often traded, but the same Andersen was a very solid goalie and return late 1st and 2nd. I just don't want to overpay. We almost made the playoffs with 41 year old Anderson and he had average stats, so there are different goaltenders who will fit us and help us get into the playoffs.
 
That's a lot more words than is necessary to say you won't engage in a hypothetical.
You mean the hypothetical underpinned by the misguided belief Pegula imposed a spending limit below the lower limit? Which leads to the debate over cap-hits for the “overpaid” depth vets vs the mid roster ones we could have acquired at “value”, because of course we could. Which leads to the debate about what Joker would get paid in a role he never played or likely would have.

The Sabres were never adding those mid roster vets due to their plan for last season. Going heavy on youth and development. They added vets to support that and were open to other players who fit the age of the core and had term/team control beyond this past season. Examples of those types of adds; Jost, Greenway, Stillman and they were in on Chychrun

Those types of mid roster vets not being an option doesnt require a meddling Pegula. Just a GM with a plan that doesn’t include them. I also highly doubt Adams is on Matt Murray if Pegula was budget conscience. Murray’s actually salary was 7mil last season and 8mil this coming one.
Re: The bolded.
The cognitive dissonance is astounding. You are again saying that Joker is a top 4d in all worlds, hypothetical and otherwise, when in your last post before this one you claim you never said he is a top4 d.
15mins atoi at 5v5 is pretty normal for a bottom pairing dman. Why would you think it means he’s top 4?

Foote’s 12-13mins at 5v5 is depth 6/7 dmen minutes.
 
Last edited:


Who should the Jets target?


Peyton Krebs.

Krebs is a solid up-and-coming centre that could solve a problem the Jets have down the middle if Dubois and Scheifele are gone (not to mention the lack of centre depth in Winnipeg’s prospect pool).

**Krebs, goalie Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen and Matthew Savoie/Buffalo’s 13th overall pick at next month’s draft? The only thing with Savoie is the Jets have enough guys like him.**

You could ask for defenceman Owen Power, but you’d likely hear a dial tone soon after.





**I’m assuming those are 4 options not one big trade package.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Der Jaeger


Who should the Jets target?


Peyton Krebs.

Krebs is a solid up-and-coming centre that could solve a problem the Jets have down the middle if Dubois and Scheifele are gone (not to mention the lack of centre depth in Winnipeg’s prospect pool).

**Krebs, goalie Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen and Matthew Savoie/Buffalo’s 13th overall pick at next month’s draft? The only thing with Savoie is the Jets have enough guys like him.**

You could ask for defenceman Owen Power, but you’d likely hear a dial tone soon after.





**I’m assuming those are 4 options not one big trade package.

I'd be fine with UPL and even Krebs, but that package is far too much for a 1-year rental.
 


Who should the Jets target?


Peyton Krebs.

Krebs is a solid up-and-coming centre that could solve a problem the Jets have down the middle if Dubois and Scheifele are gone (not to mention the lack of centre depth in Winnipeg’s prospect pool).

**Krebs, goalie Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen and Matthew Savoie/Buffalo’s 13th overall pick at next month’s draft? The only thing with Savoie is the Jets have enough guys like him.**

You could ask for defenceman Owen Power, but you’d likely hear a dial tone soon after.





**I’m assuming those are 4 options not one big trade package.

I usually like Joe, and am hoping he doesn't actually like that package and is just posing it to fans. I really can't figure out why there are SO many proposals for Savoie the year he is drafted, at 9th as well.
 

Take out Savoie and maybe. But UPL, the 13th, Krebs and Savoie for one year of a goalie. That's just a joke. Ryan Miller did not get that much. Writer is dreaming. The 13th overall and UPL might be enough for Connor. At least the guy is smart enough to understand Power is not going anywhere.
 

Take out Savoie and maybe. But UPL, the 13th, Krebs and Savoie for one year of a goalie. That's just a joke. Ryan Miller did not get that much. Writer is dreaming. The 13th overall and UPL might be enough for Connor. At least the guy is smart enough to understand Power is not going anywhere.

I read it as UPL, Krebs and EITHER 13 OR Savoie.....not both.

Either way, it's too much for a one-year rental.
 
I'd have no issue if Buffalo dangled that 13th overall pick for Hellebuyck, but there shouldn't be much of anything else added to that pick. If they want Savoie or to a lesser extent Krebs involved they can shop him elsewhere.
Personally I'd rather the top priority be improving the blueline. Plenty of average goalies look good in front of a good defense.
 
I'd have no issue if Buffalo dangled that 13th overall pick for Hellebuyck, but there shouldn't be much of anything else added to that pick. If they want Savoie or to a lesser extent Krebs involved they can shop him elsewhere.
Personally I'd rather the top priority be improving the blueline. Plenty of average goalies look good in front of a good defense.
Do we get to add an average goalie in this plan too?

Getting a top 4 D and a meaningful upgrade in goal aren’t either/or scenarios. They’re overdue ones.
 
I'd have no issue if Buffalo dangled that 13th overall pick for Hellebuyck, but there shouldn't be much of anything else added to that pick. If they want Savoie or to a lesser extent Krebs involved they can shop him elsewhere.
Personally I'd rather the top priority be improving the blueline. Plenty of average goalies look good in front of a good defense.
Absolutely, even Anderson, with our defense, system and injuries, didn't look terrible last season.

UFA:

Jarry
Andersen
Hill
Raanta
Varlamov
Talbot (risky)
Korpisalo (risky)

Trade:

Demko
Hart
Ullmark
Vejmelka
Markstrom
Vanecek (if Devils trade for Helle)
Vladar (risky)
 
Last edited:
Absolutely, even Anderson, with our defense, system and injuries, didn't look terrible last season.

UFA:

Jarry
Andersen
Hill
Raanta
Varlamov
Talbot (risky)
Korpisalo (risky)

Trade:

Demko
Hart
Ullmark
Vejmelka
Vanecek (if Devils trade for Helle)
Vladar (risky)
You can’t bring up that two of the four goalies (a senior citizen and a player with no pro experience) looked perfectly fine behind the same team the other 2 were awful behind. Hurts people’s narratives.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fjordy
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad