Proposal: Ryan Pulock or Noah Dobson for your Top 6 Winger or Center

[Gabouch04]

I can see Montreal offering something like our 2 1st this year (MTL +CGY) that should be between 10-15 and Mailloux

 

[miscs75]

Also includes Boeser, FWIW.

Too many random trades that I didn’t even see Boeser. Still don’t want Soucy or that punching bag. Reaves is half the waste of salary as Pierre Engvall and that’s only because his cap hit is roughly half.

 

[impaaaaaact]

Lets have another Generation Lindros like trade ...

Canucks send E. Petey + Boeser + Carson Soucy + to Islanders

Canucks send Lekkerimaki + first to Maple Leafs

Islanders send Noah Dobson + Anders Lee pick to Maple Leafs

Maple Leafs send Mitch Marner to Canucks

Islanders send Brock Nelson (extended) and a first to Canucks

Maple Leads send their first and Ryan Reaves to the Isles

Now why?

Isles can put Barzal to the wing and also have brock boeser and still have 2 1b centers, Scouy is a cheapp Dobson replacement.

Maple leafs replace a super star scoring machine with a playoff winning gritty power winger, defense is greatly improved ad enough futures that the sting of losing marner to the fans in not that bad (really great return)

Canucks get a replacement for pettersson, not a super star but a bo horvat light like guy, but receive probably the best player in the deal overall marner.

horrible for islanders

 

[seabass45]

Noted source “RG Media”, which just popped up on twitter two years ago and has 500 followers, now referenced on NHL Network. Fun.

 

[Szechwan]

Man WTF happened to Dobson. Wasn't it just this offseason people were putting him in polls with Seider/Power/Sanderson?

This a good chunk of this website thought he was more valuable than Hughes

 

[SeanMoneyHands]

Dobson and Nelson for Mittelstadt, Malinski and 1st.

 

[8EJS9]

Dobson and Nelson for Mittelstadt, Malinski and 1st.

Dobson for that, maybe. Dobson and Nelson? No thank you

 

[604]

Can VAN just give NYI the right to negotiate with Boeser now...

If they come to a deal:

Boeser + Soucy + 1st for Dobson + Nelson?

 

[David71]

vancouver doesnt need dobson... hes not gonna overtake quinn on powerplay 1 and is redundant. maybe if ryan pulock is avaliable than sure.

 

[BigDaddyLurch]

...are the Isles looking for prospects/picks to restock the cupboard??...

 

[miscs75]

Can VAN just give NYI the right to negotiate with Boeser now...

If they come to a deal:

Boeser + Soucy + 1st for Dobson + Nelson?

Isles still don’t need Soucy (too many years left and too much money) for the 86th time and this is a lowball offer from Vancouver.

 

[miscs75]

What are NYI needs right now?

Proven top 6 scoring threat (defensively responsible and of a similar age to Barzal) that can offset the loss of Barzal due to injury.

...are the Isles looking for prospects/picks to restock the cupboard??...

Got any high scoring Russian forwards tearing up the KHL to move?

 

[impaaaaaact]

Can VAN just give NYI the right to negotiate with Boeser now...

If they come to a deal:

Boeser + Soucy + 1st for Dobson + Nelson?

No way, way off

...are the Isles looking for prospects/picks to restock the cupboard??...

Yes, in addition to a top 6er

 

[Dion TheFluff]

would definitely be willing to offer Knies + for Dobson depending on what the Islanders are looking for.

 

[miscs75]

would definitely be willing to offer Knies + for Dobson depending on what the Islanders are looking for.

The winger currently leading your team in goals…

 

[Dion TheFluff]

The winger currently leading your team in goals…

Knies + Nylander ???
we ain't talking about Cale Makar here.
If Marner had an extension I would probably move Nylander for him 1 for 1 but otherwise no.

 

[Vergil]

Nemec and Meier would make sense for us I think

It would be a good return. Maybe not the best the Islanders can get for Dobson, but it's solid.

 

[miscs75]

Knies + Nylander ???
we ain't talking about Cale Makar here.
If Marner had an extension I would probably move Nylander for him 1 for 1 but otherwise no.

I never said it was realisitic but it is what the Islanders are looking for that’s currently missing.

 

[ReginKarlssonLehner]

Batherson + Zub for Dobson?

 

[Glorydays22]

Dobson and Nelson for Mittelstadt, Malinski and 1st.

No

 

[SirKillalot]

Dobson for Compher or Copp, make it happen Yzerman. Can tell Lou anything, he will believe it.