Toggle sidebar

Rumor: Rumors & Proposals Thread | Where's The Beef?

  • Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
CupofOil said:
Fabbro is a young ascending player, Klingberg is a much older declining player. I wouldn't count on this guy as anything more than a 3rd pair/2nd PP specialist and even more odd that they'd be pursuing Klingberg because he's pretty much a free asset and not offer a very low pick for the Preds who were waiving Fabbro anyway. I know there was salary considerations but $2.5m was very manageable. Oh well

Anyway, I don't like the idea of a top 4 experiment for Klingberg because there's very little upside to it with it being highly likely that he's well past done as a top 4 Dman and while the Oilers are pretty much locked in to a playoff spot they're in a dogfight for the division and possible Presidents Trophy so I don't think experimenting with a top 4 D with a guy who is a real longshot is the best of ideas.

If he's signed as depth or as a rotation guy then I'm fine with it but if this is a plug and play with Nurse I really don't like it.
Click to expand...
I wonder if Klingberg might be more of a research tool. Seems like they might still be doing some testing on what kind of partner they believe will be best type to fit with Nurse. They called Brown up and have given him some time with Nurse to see how he responds with a stay at home type, now maybe they go out and make a no risk signing to bring in an adept right handed puck mover to see how that type of player impacts Nurses game.

So it could just be them trying to get more data for making a decision on who they want to target for a defensive upgrade.
 
  • Like
Reactions: K1984 and Mcnotloilersfan
I kind of really want to get the biggest fish out there up front. Someone who tilts the ice. Where on nights that we load up a top line, this player leads a terrifying 2nd line right after. Will there even be a player like that available?
 
  • Like
Reactions: McDoused
SupremeTeam16 said:
I wonder if Klingberg might be more of a research tool. Seems like they might still be doing some testing on what kind of partner they believe will be best type to fit with Nurse. They called Brown up and have given him some time with Nurse to see how he responds with a stay at home type, now maybe they go out and make a no risk signing to bring in an adept right handed puck mover to see how that type of player impacts Nurses game.

So it could just be them trying to get more data for making a decision on who they want to target for a defensive upgrade.
Click to expand...

Could be. I honestly don’t know what kind of partner he needs.

I think he has to be able to move the puck well and has to have strong defensive instincts. Probably needs a strong sense of composure. While that sounds pretty simple and straightforward. Thats a difficult player to acquire. Especially on the right side.
 
  • Like
Reactions: McDoused
Klingberg at under a mil is a no brainer. He isn't going to be our "big" trade deadline Dman acquisition. He didn't even exist a week ago and now we have the opportunity to get him, the upside far outweighs the negative (if any).

This is his last kick of the can in the league, he will be highly motivated....which should never be underestimated.
 
  • Like
Reactions: McTonyBrar, Oilhawks, McDoused and 2 others
CupofOil said:
Fabbro is a young ascending player, Klingberg is a much older declining player. I wouldn't count on this guy as anything more than a 3rd pair/2nd PP specialist and even more odd that they'd be pursuing Klingberg because he's pretty much a free asset and not offer a very low pick for the Preds who were waiving Fabbro anyway. I know there was salary considerations but $2.5m was very manageable. Oh well

Anyway, I don't like the idea of a top 4 experiment for Klingberg because there's very little upside to it with it being highly likely that he's well past done as a top 4 Dman and while the Oilers are pretty much locked in to a playoff spot they're in a dogfight for the division and possible Presidents Trophy so I don't think experimenting with a top 4 D with a guy who is a real longshot is the best of ideas.

If he's signed as depth or as a rotation guy then I'm fine with it but if this is a plug and play with Nurse I really don't like it.
Click to expand...
Fabbro and Klingberg have the most important things in common though, as a potential option for our top 4 RD. And sure Fabbro has a brighter future and Klingberg is only a short term option, but I'm looking at this up coming playoffs first and foremost. Also, of course we missed the boat on Fabbro, while Klingberg is right here for the taking, and most assume that it would be for a low enough dollar so that we can still make a run at someone better at the deadline

I agree with you on what we should expect from Klingberg, but no one really knows what he'll be like. He really could be a noticeable upgrade on Stecher.
 
Jimmi McJenkins said:
I'm glad Philp is up, I'm still really hoping for a look for Savoie and Rodrigue before Feb 12th.
Click to expand...

Agree about Savoie if their is an injury. Otherwise we already have too many guys up (Jeff Skinner wasting away on the bench). Rodrigues, I honestly don't see it. After Pickards performance and Skinner getting a shutout, I think what we have currently is better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jimmi McJenkins
McDoused said:
Agree about Savoie if their is an injury. Otherwise we already have too many guys up (Jeff Skinner wasting away on the bench). Rodrigues, I honestly don't see it. After Pickards performance and Skinner getting a shutout, I think what we have currently is better.
Click to expand...
Fair, but honestly if one of those 2 go down, you need to know if he can handle himself and this window until Feb 12th is a good time to "try" guys imo.

I also agree about Skinner not getting in, but Savoie is playing so well he needs a look, because injuries or no, they may need him in the playoffs to change the look.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom