Rumor: Rumors & Proposals Thread | The Oilers Biggest Roster Need Is?

Oilers Biggest Roster Need?

  • 2nd Pairing RD

    Votes: 86 40.0%
  • Starting Goalie

    Votes: 120 55.8%
  • Top 6 LW (RNH, Podkolzin and Jeff Skinner Aren't Getting it Done)

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • Top 6 RW (Arvidsson and Hyman Aren't Getting it Done)

    Votes: 1 0.5%
  • 3C

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Physical Bottom 6 Wingers

    Votes: 1 0.5%
  • Other (Post Your Opinion)

    Votes: 4 1.9%

  • Total voters
    215

Soundwave

Registered User
Mar 1, 2007
74,434
30,706
Gibson with 43 saves and posts a 0.956 tonight.

He is now 4-1 (he has four 900+ starts out of 5 games). 950,900,906,929,956

Seattle with 5 PP's tonight. Dostal is playing great, but ANA gets bombarded most games. I can see both goalies obviously trend downwards there.
-----------------------------------

Anaheim allows the 3rd most HDC per game all strengths. Edmonton allows the LEAST in the NHL at all strengths

Skinner has played 15 games. He has seven 900+ starts. Less than 50%. I would be happy if Skinner could go 6/10 games with a 900+.
--------------

My prediction. Colorado trades for him with retention.

Yeah I'm getting more sold on going after this guy. He has elite level reflexes. Having him on the team will make a bigger difference than having a OK no.4 or a more expensive tier no.4 D.

LOL The great Blackwood lets in 4 goals on 11 shots. Hopefully this will stop some of the --------- here.

I would still take him, he plays on the worst team in the NHL, nights like that will happen to anyone.
 

Soundwave

Registered User
Mar 1, 2007
74,434
30,706
Stan Bowman interviewed by Sportsnet a couple of days ago:


With even average goaltending, the Oilers would likely be in the top third of the league defensively.

“Maybe on paper (the D-corps) doesn't look great, but when you look at actually the way they perform they’ve done a pretty good job,” Bowman surmised. “We don't give up a ton of opportunities — and our overall team deserves a little credit for … helping our D out.

“I think our D has been fine.”

In the end, Bowman presides over a team that appears to be finding its legs after a slow start, with 60 games of runway still left in the season. It is not the time for the GM to rattle the pots, nor is it appropriate to praise a team that has appeared disinterested through the opening 22 games of Bowman’s tenure in Edmonton.

“I wouldn't say I'm panicked. But I'm also not pleased,” he said. “I’m sort of in the middle, where I think we can do things better.

“We haven't played our best, but we're still in contention.”
 
  • Like
Reactions: TB12 and Vagabond

Took a pill in Sbisa

2showToffoliIwascool
Apr 23, 2004
16,771
7,785
Australia
Stan Bowman interviewed by Sportsnet a couple of days ago:


With even average goaltending, the Oilers would likely be in the top third of the league defensively.

“Maybe on paper (the D-corps) doesn't look great, but when you look at actually the way they perform they’ve done a pretty good job,” Bowman surmised. “We don't give up a ton of opportunities — and our overall team deserves a little credit for … helping our D out.

“I think our D has been fine.”

In the end, Bowman presides over a team that appears to be finding its legs after a slow start, with 60 games of runway still left in the season. It is not the time for the GM to rattle the pots, nor is it appropriate to praise a team that has appeared disinterested through the opening 22 games of Bowman’s tenure in Edmonton.

“I wouldn't say I'm panicked. But I'm also not pleased,” he said. “I’m sort of in the middle, where I think we can do things better.

“We haven't played our best, but we're still in contention.”

He's not wrong. We're 6th in expected goals against and 10th in high danger shots against.

Our record is a reflection of bad goaltending, a bottom-5 PP, and a forward group of exactly 2.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NeverForget06

McDNicks17

Moderator
Jul 1, 2010
42,783
33,164
Ontario
Thanks. List is filling out nicely, and now in favor of taking the high pedigree Jiricek.

1st Round Defenceman Moved Early in their Careers:

Sandin - Success
Broberg - Success
Byram - Success
Larsson - Success
Smid - Success
McDonagh - Success
Johnson - Success (I think)
Sergachev - Success
Drysdale - Fail
Lundkvist - Fail
Reinhart - Fail
Jiricek - ?
To be fair, we're going to remember the successes more than the failures.

Like does anyone even remember David Rundblad? There's probably dozens of guys like that.
 

Whoshattenkirkshoes

Registered User
Aug 11, 2014
4,555
2,071
Ah so it's a "I like Bouchard, but he should be more like this" issue. That's a you thing.

Because of his struggles this year and the fact he makes mistakes, you've convinced yourself he's a taller Tyson Barrie, which just isn't true.
No it's more like some people are calling out Bouchard for his horrible play this year and others have some weird bias blinders on where in their world Bouchard can do no wrong. He has some immunity.
 

FlameChampion

Registered User
Jul 13, 2011
14,821
17,482
Thanks. List is filling out nicely, and now in favor of taking the high pedigree Jiricek.

1st Round Defenceman Moved Early in their Careers:

Sandin - Success
Broberg - Success
Byram - Success
Larsson - Success
Smid - Success
McDonagh - Success
Johnson - Success (I think)
Sergachev - Success
Drysdale - Fail
Lundkvist - Fail
Reinhart - Fail
Jiricek - ?

It’s interesting when it’s written out like this. But I would argue while some of these guys may be successful after leaving, not many of them really turned out to be amazing. Byram for example has been fine.

McDonaugh probably turned into a top pairing guy. The other are middling to bottom pairing guys. Still useful but not amazing.

Sergachev I think is too old/established compared to the rest to be considered.
 

TopShelfGloveSide

Registered User
Dec 10, 2018
20,182
29,323
Stan Bowman interviewed by Sportsnet a couple of days ago:


With even average goaltending, the Oilers would likely be in the top third of the league defensively.

“Maybe on paper (the D-corps) doesn't look great, but when you look at actually the way they perform they’ve done a pretty good job,” Bowman surmised. “We don't give up a ton of opportunities — and our overall team deserves a little credit for … helping our D out.

“I think our D has been fine.”

In the end, Bowman presides over a team that appears to be finding its legs after a slow start, with 60 games of runway still left in the season. It is not the time for the GM to rattle the pots, nor is it appropriate to praise a team that has appeared disinterested through the opening 22 games of Bowman’s tenure in Edmonton.

“I wouldn't say I'm panicked. But I'm also not pleased,” he said. “I’m sort of in the middle, where I think we can do things better.

“We haven't played our best, but we're still in contention.”
If he is saying our D has been fine then he is very aware of the goaltending issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TB12

Whoshattenkirkshoes

Registered User
Aug 11, 2014
4,555
2,071
Im a bit worried about Savoie’s production. But I don’t watch Bako. So I won’t say nothing. But the production is underwhelming. Yamamoto is out producing him right now.
I've personally never been a big fan of Savoie. In junior he was on strong teams and seemed to really lack IQ. He's a small, speedy north south player

There is a reason Buffalo moved on from him....

I think it's another JJ strike out, unless we can move him for an asset.
 

TopShelfGloveSide

Registered User
Dec 10, 2018
20,182
29,323
I've personally never been a big fan of Savoie. In junior he was on strong teams and seemed to really lack IQ. He's a small, speedy north south player

There is a reason Buffalo moved on from him....

I think it's another JJ strike out, unless we can move him for an asset.
Hockey IQ has never been an issue for Savoie. Interesting that you think it is.
 

Whoshattenkirkshoes

Registered User
Aug 11, 2014
4,555
2,071
Hockey IQ has never been an issue for Savoie. Interesting that you think it is.
For me he is a guy that goes 100 miles an hour and has relied on his speed and athleticism growing up over his IQ. (similar to Mcleod, Athanasiou, etc)

I don't really see him as anything more than an average run of the mill NHL winger


Time will tell, but this is my stance.
 

Whoshattenkirkshoes

Registered User
Aug 11, 2014
4,555
2,071
Bedard finally gets off the schnide. And Taylor "It's All About Me" Hall goes and gets a Hat Trick. See, this is why we traded him in the first place, to give McDavid the spotlight. But now that McDavid is all grown up, it's time for the reunion.
I know this WON'T happen, but can we at least visualize this?

Podkolzin Mcdavid Hyman
Hall Draisaitl Arvidsson
Kane Nuge Kapanen
Janmark Henrique Brown

Even without Hall I think the potential with our forward group is there. Somehow get Nuge to 3c where he belongs.
 

Scrapin Ice

Registered User
Oct 25, 2024
197
56
I've personally never been a big fan of Savoie. In junior he was on strong teams and seemed to really lack IQ. He's a small, speedy north south player

There is a reason Buffalo moved on from him....

I think it's another JJ strike out, unless we can move him for an asset.
Well im not sure i would give up on him so soon but if you do want to trade him Montreal loves these types of guys. Just tell them he is 'the flower' in the making. And ask them for Reinbacher. Ken Hughes will initially tell you to f off as he should but who knows what you will get a shot at. They have all kinds of prospects we could use, some this year and some for the future. Right now i suspect (i dont know cause haven't watched a full game yet in the A this year) that they have Savoie focused on the south side of the puck which is smart and they are making sure he isnt going to wall and battling hard against the bigger guys. PLus the guy really needs a big center with some good vision -- maybe Jarventie will come back healthy. (We have a BIG center that likes to go to the right wall and battle and can execute blind passes like nobodies business and able to find guy sneaking into the slot. Big german MF.
But don't get it wrong. Unlike his brother Muck (Carter) this kid has wheels. And a great set of mitts. And excellent anticipation. And a fine tuned trigger on the PP. He will one day be a good maybe not great NHLer.
Sometimes the little guys need time to adapt their game -- they played one way in junior but cant play that exact way as a professional.
Don't you wish he would grow an inch? And get his real man strength on him now?
 
Last edited:

Jimmi McJenkins

Sometimes miracles
Jan 12, 2006
78,888
41,906
Alberta
No it's more like some people are calling out Bouchard for his horrible play this year and others have some weird bias blinders on where in their world Bouchard can do no wrong. He has some immunity.
I mean no right, again, your shit posting is not clever or funny.

Bouchard has had struggles this year, but he's still a net positive player and an elite defenseman. No amount of dumb "but like they're just like calling out that's he's played SO bad this year you guys" nonsense make him not elite.

still that butthurt he got hired eh?
Get f***ed, and no I'm still upset he was hired and has the nerve to say something like that after his dithering.

You guys don't have to lick Stan's boots, there's no prizes for it.
 

CantHaveTkachev

Cap Space > NHL players
Nov 30, 2004
52,384
34,435
St. OILbert, AB
Stan Bowman should be subject to intense scrutiny until he delivers this team a championship. Same as Holland, same as Chiarelli, same as all the other OBC toadies that haven't delivered since '06.
Yawn, you would say the same thing about any GM that came in here

that's your schtick

Get f***ed, and no I'm still upset he was hired and has the nerve to say something like that after his dithering.

You guys don't have to lick Stan's boots, there's no prizes for it.
dithering? dude got hired AFTER Jackson decided to play GM for a few weeks and the money was all gone

and even then, he acquired 2 decent pieces in Podz and Emberson...then re-signed Drai to a max deal
I guess that doesn't count eh?
 
Apr 12, 2010
75,445
34,674
Calgary
Yawn, you would say the same thing about any GM that came in here

that's your schtick
Of course I would. No other team in the league has Connor McDavid. Delivering a team with him and Draisatl a championship should be child's play and yet here we are in year 10 and still no championship and the same issues plaguing the team that have been there since basically the day McDavid was drafted. I'm not convinced that Bowman is any better than his predecessors so far and him being "not pleased" is laughable. It's your team, dude.

Of course they won't. This is a imagery post that allows the Oilers to dump all the deadweights for someone good
Also we should still stay away from Gibson. A few good games doesn't magically erase a half decade of subpar play.
 

CantHaveTkachev

Cap Space > NHL players
Nov 30, 2004
52,384
34,435
St. OILbert, AB
Of course I would. No other team in the league has Connor McDavid. Delivering a team with him and Draisatl a championship should be child's play and yet here we are in year 10 and still no championship and the same issues plaguing the team that have been there since basically the day McDavid was drafted. I'm not convinced that Bowman is any better than his predecessors so far and him being "not pleased" is laughable. It's your team, dude.
you new to hockey? having 2 of the best players in hockey doesn't guarantee anything...this isn't basketball where the stars play most of the games
nothing is guaranteed or "easy"
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad